| Category |
Decision |
Discussion_log
|
| 1 and 2 article church categories in New York (state) |
merge all per nominator |
March 10
|
| 1 and 2 article Greek Orthodox church categories |
merge all per nominator. @ |
March 23
|
| 1 article/1 subcategory Halls of Fame parent categories |
upmerge (non-admin closure) |
March 26
|
| Category:1657 in Estonia |
merge all to Category:17th century in Estonia. (non-admin closure) |
March 3
|
| Category:1838 establishments in Oregon Territory |
rename Category:1838 establishments in Oregon Territory to Category:1838 establishments in Oregon Country; delete the rest. Thee is agreement that the current title is an anachronism, and given the small size, a future nomination to upmerge the subcats of Category:1830s establishments in Oregon Country would attract some support |
March 19
|
| Category:2016 murders in Denmark, 2016 murders in Turkey, 2018 murders in Iraq, Category:2018 murders in Pakistan, Category:2019 murders in Pakistan, Category:March 2016 Istanbul bombing |
merge per amended nomination |
March 27
|
| Category:African-American civil rights movement (1954–68) |
no consensus. There is a long-standing practice that category redirects may be kept when a category is moved, as happened here. The nominator has taken a very prescriptive view of WP:CATRED which is not supported by others. I also don't believe that the nominator's is supported by the text, because CATRED does not assert that it includes a full list of the limited circumstances in which category redirects are appropriate ... so I see no reason to add extra weight to the nominator's arguments.
I do question whether several screenfuls of Wikilawyering about one category redirect was a wise use of the nominator's time |
March 9
|
| Age of Discovery |
rename all |
March 25
|
| Category:Alan Davis |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 5
|
| Category:Album covers by label |
delete. There's a consensus to delete, but the nomination was a bit pointless because the only content was a subcategory Category:Mint 400 Records album covers. If the nomination had deleted Category:Mint 400 Records album covers, then Category:Album covers by label would have been speedy- deleted as empty ... but now are left with albums still categorised by label.
Pinging the participants @Starcheerspeaksnewslostwars, NorthPark1417, and Richhoncho: does anyone want to do a followup nomination? |
March 4
|
| Category:Alexz Johnson albums |
keep. Should a proposal raise the minimum, however, this should be rediscussed. (non-admin closure) |
March 22
|
| Category:Alexz Johnson songs |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
March 22
|
| Category:Amazon oil |
delete, with selected upmerging per nominator |
March 11
|
| Category:American "faithful slave" monuments and defenders |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
March 28
|
| Category:American championships |
relisted at WP:Categories for discussion/Log/2019 March 21#Category:American_championships |
March 13
|
| Category:American championships |
rename to Category:International sports championships in the Americas |
March 21
|
| Category:American female rappers |
keep the current name. (non-admin closure) |
March 13
|
| Category:Anchovies |
reverse merge per WP:COMMONNAME, i.e. merge Category:Engraulidae to Category:Anchovies |
March 9
|
| Category:Anti-Christian sentiment |
relisted at WP:Categories for discussion/Log/2019 April 3#Category:Anti-Christian_sentiment |
March 23
|
| Category:Anti-pornography movements |
Opinion is roughly evenly split. Neither side cited any scholarly evidence, and neither had cited any edge in policy or guideline. And so, after 40 days and forty nights, there didst emerge no consensus |
March 11
|
| Category:Arab Moroccans |
merge. I am personally not sure this is a good idea, but consensus is clear |
March 2
|
| Category:Arabic language speaking people |
delete |
March 21
|
| Category:Asian-American novels |
no consensus, mostly because of uncertainty about what the current titles are trying to convey. The fuzziness of the category titles here seems to be matched by the nationality categories, e.g. Category:British novels. Does the adjective "British" refer to the topic/setting, the author, or the place of publication? An RFC might help |
March 19
|
| Category:Associate wardens of Alcatraz Federal Penitentiary |
merge (non-admin closure) |
March 17
|
| Category:Astrology Wikipedian userboxes |
merge |
March 25
|
| Category:ATP World Tour Masters 1000 |
rename. (non-admin closure) |
March 22
|
| Category:Automobiles with hidden headlamps |
delete |
March 5
|
| Category:AVCA Hall of Fame |
delete |
March 30
|
| Category:Bajo Nuevo Bank |
delete |
March 15
|
| Category:Bankroll Mafia albums |
keep (non-admin closure) |
March 21
|
| Category:Best-selling singles worldwide (by year) |
delete |
March 18
|
| Category:Billy Wilder |
delete |
March 4
|
| Biological toxin weapons |
procedural close. Not a CFD issue |
March 19
|
| Books about environmentalism |
merge/renameper nominator |
March 19
|
| Category:Books featured on Reading Rainbow |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 8
|
| Category:Bottled water brands in Ghana |
upmerge |
March 13
|
| British Empire |
merge to each category's respective target, as specified in the nomination. (meaning the aren't being merged with each other). (non-admin closure) |
March 1
|
| Category:British honours system |
keep (non-admin closure) |
March 4
|
| Buildings and structures by city |
merge |
March 9
|
| Category:Buildings and structures in Chleby |
merge. (non-admin closure) |
March 26
|
| Category:Buildings and structures in Duitama |
merge |
March 26
|
| Category:Buildings and structures in Ghardaïa |
merge |
March 27
|
| Category:Buildings and structures in Gustavia, Saint Barthélemy |
merge |
March 29
|
| Category:Buildings and structures in Hodonín |
merge |
March 27
|
| Category:Buildings and structures in Kaišiadorys |
merge |
March 30
|
| Category:Buildings and structures in Kalocsa |
upmerge |
March 31
|
| Category:Business CEOs template |
upmerge Category:Business CEOs template to parents Category:Company templates and Category:Businesspeople templates |
March 3
|
| Category:Cameo Records singles |
no consensus. The only editor who made a specific !vote opposes any change, and the two other editor who participated did not cast a !vote. The discussion was mostly unconstructive, which may be why after three weeks there were only four participants.
Towards the end, there seemed to be inconclusive signs of some agreement, so maybe further discussion at Category talk:Cameo Records singles might identify a solution to bring back to CFD |
March 20
|
| Category:Cameo Records singles |
relisted at WP:Categories for discussion/Log/2019 March 20#Category:Cameo_Records_singles |
March 7
|
| Category:Cameron Crowe |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
March 1
|
| Category:Caucasian muhajirs |
foo |
March 17
|
| Category:Caucus |
rename Category:Caucus to Category:Caucuses in the United States |
March 11
|
| Category:CEOs of General Electric |
relisted at WP:Categories for discussion/Log/2019 March 20#Category:CEOs_of_General_Electric |
March 3
|
| Category:Cerebus the Aardvark |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 18
|
| Category:Charles Goodyear Medal recipients |
delete |
March 25
|
| Category:Charlotte Rampling |
delete |
March 5
|
| Category:Child sexual abuse in religious groups |
option B. (non-admin closure) |
March 18
|
| Category:Christchurch mosque shootings |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
March 17
|
| Category:Christianity in Copenhagen |
merge to Category:Religion in Copenhagen |
March 8
|
| Category:Christianity in St. Gallen |
delete |
March 29
|
| Churches in Essex |
merge |
March 27
|
| Churches in Harlow |
merge |
March 27
|
| Category:Civil War defenses of Washington, D.C. |
no consensus.
This seems to come down to whether the category is viewed as topic category (in which case the rename would probably be justified) or as a set category, in which case the current title has merit. But since there is no consensus for a change, we keep the status quo |
March 9
|
| Category:Coffea drinks |
merge. For the record, I'll put the subcat Coffee liqueurs into Alcoholic coffee drinks, and Coffee drinks into the parent Caffeinated drinks. – |
March 22
|
| Category:Comics about spiders |
delete |
March 13
|
| Category:Congregational churches in Cambridge |
merge |
March 27
|
| Category:Conspicuous Service Cross (New York) recipients |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
March 26
|
| Category:Cooklite Magazine |
the category has already been speedy deleted per WP:G11 (unambiguous advertising or promotion) by |
March 20
|
| Category:Coptic Catholics |
upmerge |
March 15
|
| Category:Cory Lee albums |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 22
|
| Category:Cory Lee songs |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
March 22
|
| Category:CPO (group) albums |
keep (non-admin closure) |
March 21
|
| Category:Dan Aykroyd |
relisted, see here (non-admin closure) |
March 1
|
| Category:Danish Sports Hall of Fame inductees |
delete both. For editors interested in creating a list, the current articles in the inductees category are listed at Wikipedia talk:Categories for discussion/Log/2019 March 29. (non-admin closure) |
March 29
|
| Category:Davidson Media Group radio stations |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 5
|
| Death customs by country |
merge all |
March 29
|
| Category:Death customs in Latin America |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
March 29
|
| Decade films by year |
merge all. (non-admin closure) |
March 5
|
| Discovery, Inc. |
merge. It's empty, so there is nothing to merge ... but any contents would have been merged if they existed |
March 31
|
| Category:Disease notification |
merge |
March 30
|
| Category:Don Murray (actor) |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
March 11
|
| Category:Doris Lessing |
delete |
March 15
|
| Dubbed films |
delete all. (non-admin closure) |
March 8
|
| Dubbed television programs |
delete all. (non-admin closure) |
March 7
|
| Category:Earthsea locations |
merge Category:Earthsea locations to Category:Earthsea |
March 25
|
| Category:Eddie Murphy |
keep |
March 19
|
| Category:Education books |
merge. (non-admin closure) |
March 26
|
| Category:Emilia Clarke |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 5
|
| Empty subcategories of Category:Redirects from non-English-language terms |
no consesnsus ... but I will speedy delete all three as empty per WP:C1, without prejudice to re-creation/further CFD discussion if there is something to populate them. But this would all be better dealt with at Template talk:Lang |
March 28
|
| Category:Environmental radio |
purge and merge per nominator |
March 10
|
| Category:Expatriates by country of residence |
keep (non-admin closure) |
March 19
|
| Category:Explosives engineering and bomb disposal in fiction |
rename to Category:Fiction about bomb disposal |
March 9
|
| Category:Festivals in Former Yugoslavia |
|
March 4
|
| Category:Fictional California Institute of Technology people |
delete, along with Category:Fictional California Institute of Technology students.
There is consensus that this category is a WP:NARROWCAT, but some uncertainty on how the articles should be recategorised, so I will listify the contents on the talk page, and leave it to the participants (@Originalmess, Apokrif, and Marcocapelle:) to recategorise the pages in other existing categories.
Note that Category:Fictional California Institute of Technology students was not created by a few hours ago by Apokrif, who created Category:Fictional California Institute of Technology students. I AGF that was not an attempt to evade CFD consensus, but that creation clearly undermines the consensus-building here, so I am treating it as if it had been nominated here |
March 20
|
| Category:Fictional mentors and godparents |
delete |
March 9
|
| Fictional trans people |
rename to Category:Fictional transgender and transsexual men and Category:Fictional transgender and transsexual women. There is consensus against merger, and for renaming away from the current names. As for using short or long names, opinions are evenly divided, therefore the outcome follows the current naming pattern in the parent hierarchy |
March 11
|
| Category:Films by medium |
delete |
March 19
|
| Category:Films produced by B. F. Zeidman |
no consensus without prejudice against a fresh wider nomination |
March 17
|
| Category:Former Victoria's Secret Angels |
merge |
March 22
|
| Category:Foundation members of the Tasmanian Wilderness Society |
delete |
March 19
|
| Category:Gary Cooper |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
March 11
|
| Category:Germanic countries and territories |
no consensus. Nearly every possible permutations of actions had some support |
March 19
|
| Category:Gorizia and Gradisca |
delete |
March 25
|
| Category:Group actions |
rename |
March 13
|
| Category:Health awareness days |
withdrawn (non-admin closure) |
March 27
|
| Category:Health-related timelines by country |
rename to Category:Healthcare-related timelines. (non-admin closure) |
March 2
|
| Category:Houses in San Clemente, California |
merge Category:Houses in San Clemente, California to Category:Buildings and structures in San Clemente, California and Category:Houses in Orange County, California |
March 17
|
| Category:Hulk (comics) in other media |
no consensus (non-admin closure) |
March 7
|
| Category:Hungarian Heritage Award Winners |
delete |
March 22
|
| Category:Independent Eastern Orthodox denominations |
no consensus |
March 10
|
| Category:Indo-Pacific fauna |
delete both |
March 17
|
| Category:Ingersoll Rand |
Withdrawn by nominator. (non-admin closure) |
March 9
|
| Category:International Association of Athletics Federations Hall of Fame inductees |
delete |
March 20
|
| Category:Invasive plant species |
delete. To assist anyone working o the topic, e.g. by list-making, I have left a list of the category's contents at WT:Categories for discussion/Log/2019 March 4#Invasive_plant_species |
March 4
|
| Category:James FitzGerald |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 4
|
| Category:James Ivory |
delete |
March 4
|
| Category:James Montgomery Flagg |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 4
|
| Category:James Turrell |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 5
|
| Category:Jewish anti-communists |
keep. (non-admin closure) |
March 22
|
| Category:Jewish fascists |
no consensus |
March 22
|
| Category:Joan Mitchell |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 5
|
| Category:John Gottman |
delete |
March 10
|
| Category:John Ritter |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
March 11
|
| Category:Kansas Sports Hall of Fame |
delete. The lone keep vote didn't address the WP:SMALLCAT issue |
March 19
|
| Karlskoga |
option B. (non-admin closure) |
March 30
|
| Category:Kenyan superheroes |
no consensus. If normal editing processes conclude that the category's contents don't belong in the category, then it will be speedy deleted as empty |
March 9
|
| Category:Kidnapping in Islamism |
merge to Category:Islamism |
March 19
|
| Category:Kim Basinger |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
March 11
|
| Category:Kim Norton |
delete |
March 12
|
| Category:Kingman Reef |
delete |
March 28
|
| KK Mega Basket |
rename.
@ |
March 8
|
| Category:Languedoc-Roussillon region articles needing translation from French Wikipedia |
rename/merge per nominator |
March 3
|
| Category:League of Ireland U19 Division |
delete |
March 29
|
| Category:Leibniz scholars |
rename to Category:Gottfried Leibniz scholars. The nominator @ |
March 12
|
| Category:Lena Headey |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 5
|
| Category:Linear earthwork |
speedy rename. – |
March 24
|
| Category:List of DAV schools in India |
merge to Category:Schools affiliated with the Arya Samaj |
March 11
|
| Category:Lists of monuments and memorials in Rostov Oblast |
merge |
March 4
|
| Macedonia and international organisations |
rename all per expanded nomination.
(Note: I did participate in this discussion, so I am WP:INVOLVED ... but since every comment supports the proposal, this is an undisputed case per WP:INVOLVED. So I am closing now as part of an effort to clear the big CFD backlog.) |
March 15
|
| Category:Mary Cassatt |
delete (non-admin closure). I have added the biography as the main article in the header of the works category |
March 4
|
| Category:Medieval Iraqi people |
no consensus |
March 19
|
| Category:Medieval Persia |
no consensus. Not many sources cited either  — just one, which isn't enough evidence of a pattern of usage in reliable sources to override the numerical tie between editors |
March 17
|
| Category:Michigan Department of Corrections |
delete |
March 22
|
| Category:Military units and factions of the Syrian Civil War |
no consensus. With the benefit of hindsight, the outcome might have been a consensus of some form if the nominator @ |
March 1
|
| Category:Miloš Forman |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
March 1
|
| Milwaukee Wave players |
merge |
March 14
|
| Category:Miniature wargames |
merge. Both editors agree on a merge, just not in which direction. So to remove the duplication, I'll close as merge per the nominator @ |
March 1
|
| Category:Mint 400 Records album covers |
relisted at WP:Categories for discussion/Log/2019 April 8#Category:Mint_400_Records_album_covers |
March 22
|
| Category:Modern primitive movement |
rename. There was no consensus on deletion |
March 4
|
| Category:Montenegrin Chetniks |
rename per nominator, without prejudice to any future proposal to rename Category:Chetnik personnel of World War II and all its subcats |
March 9
|
| Mosques in India by district |
merge all. (non-admin closure) |
March 28
|
| Category:Mosques in Sri Lanka by city |
merge one, delete others per nominator |
March 15
|
| Category:Multi-touch mobile phones |
delete |
March 19
|
| Category:Museum of Polo and Hall of Fame inductees |
delete |
March 25
|
| Category:Mythological Greek characters |
merge |
March 18
|
| Category:México Indígena |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
March 10
|
| Category:Māngere |
delete |
March 7
|
| Category:National Heroes of Azerbaijan |
withdrawn by nominator after new evidence was presented |
March 31
|
| Needing infoboxes |
speedy delete per WP:G8: Pages dependent on a non-existent or deleted page.
@ |
March 14
|
| Category:Nepalese architecture |
merge (non-admin closure) |
March 5
|
| Category:Nepalese Masculine given names |
rename |
March 16
|
| Category:New Zealand Business Hall of Fame inductees |
delete |
March 27
|
| Category:NHS hospital trusts |
no consensus |
March 10
|
| Category:Nova Scotia Sport Hall of Fame inductees |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 18
|
| Category:Organisations based in Europe |
Procedural close until this RFC is closed |
March 27
|
| Category:Ottawa Sport Hall of Fame inductees |
delete |
March 31
|
| Category:Oxoanions and subcategories |
rename all |
March 9
|
| Category:Pages to import images to Wikidata |
relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2019 April 7#Category:Pages_to_import_images_to_Wikidata |
March 25
|
| Category:Pages using Template:Annual readership |
delete |
March 3
|
| Category:Pages with graphs |
rename both |
March 17
|
| Category:Painting and the environment |
rename to Category:Environmental impact of paint |
March 18
|
| Category:Parties that campaigned for leave/remain during the United Kingdom European Union membership referendum, 2016 |
listify and delete. Both categories have been listified already at Talk:2016 United Kingdom European Union membership referendum#Category:Parties that campaigned for leave/remain during the United Kingdom European Union membership referendum, 2016 has been nominated for discussion. (non-admin closure) |
March 9
|
| Category:People from the Northern Rivers |
no consensus (non-admin closure) |
March 14
|
| Category:People involved in outsourcing |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 21
|
| Category:People permanently banned from Twitter |
delete |
March 14
|
| Category:Peter Cook |
withdrawn by nominator |
March 5
|
| Category:Peter F. Hamilton |
delete |
March 5
|
| Pharaohs by millenium |
keep all |
March 29
|
| Category:Phases of matter |
keep (non-admin closure) |
March 21
|
| Category:Phones with dual rear cameras |
rename |
March 26
|
| Category:Place names |
keep, i.e. do not merge |
March 9
|
| Category:Pope Pius XII encyclicals |
rename |
March 2
|
| Category:Populated places established in 1118 |
merge to Category:Populated places established in the 1110s. There is a clear consensus to upmerge, but no consensus on where. Since no reason was offered why an event in 1118 doesn't belong in an extant 1110s category, I am closing as a merge to the 1110s without prejudice to any followup nomination to upmerge the decade categories to the century. Pinging the participants: @Greenshed and Marcocapelle |
March 23
|
| Category:POV (TV series) films |
no consensus |
March 19
|
| Category:Power Architecture |
moot, but speedy delete as empty.
@ |
March 4
|
| Category:Primates of Eastern Orthodox uncanonical churches |
rename |
March 23
|
| Category:Princely families |
merge |
March 23
|
| Category:Professional wrestling rosters |
rename to Category:Lists of professional wrestling personnel |
March 19
|
| Proponents of Christian feminism |
selectively merge. Pinging the nominator @ |
March 31
|
| Category:Public health education |
keep. – |
March 19
|
| Category:Puerto Rico Economic Development Bank |
delete both |
March 16
|
| Category:Railway accident locations in Western Australia |
delete |
March 19
|
| Category:Railway Union cricket players |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 24
|
| Category:Ralph Bakshi |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 4
|
| Category:Recipients of the Aceh Medal |
delete |
March 15
|
| Category:Recipients of the Carlsberg Architectural Prize |
delete. If anyone wants to make a list, the 4 pages currently in the category are: Carlsberg Architectural Prize, Tadao Ando, Juha Leiviskä, Peter Zumthor |
March 11
|
| Category:Recipients of the Garland Clay Award |
delete. If anyone wants to make a list, the category contained the following 3 pages: Jan E Lovie-Kitchin, Konrad Pesudovs, Max Snodderly |
March 3
|
| Category:Recipients of the Medal of Merit of the GDR |
keep (non-admin closure) |
March 28
|
| Category:Recipients of the Mkhitar Gosh Medal |
delete both |
March 30
|
| Category:Recipients of the National Service Medal (Norway) |
delete |
March 27
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of Abdon Calderón |
delete. A list of the category's current contents is available at Wikipedia talk:Categories for discussion/Log/2019 March 24. (non-admin closure) |
March 24
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of Belize |
delete. I have made a list of the category's contents at WT:Categories for discussion/Log/2019 March 13#Recipients_of_the_Order_of_Belize |
March 13
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of Bernardo O'Higgins |
delete both. The contents of each category is listed on the talk page: at WT:Categories for discussion/Log/2019 March 17#Category:Recipients_of_the_Order_of_Bernardo_O'Higgins and WT:Categories for discussion/Log/2019 March 17#Category:Grand_Crosses_of_the_Order_of_Bernardo_O'Higgins |
March 17
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of Ismail |
delete |
March 21
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of Saint Peter of Cetinje |
delete |
March 16
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of Zayed |
delete |
March 23
|
| Category:Recipients of the Zimbabwean Independence Medal, 1980 |
delete |
March 9
|
| Category:Red Arrows pilots |
delete |
March 2
|
| Category:RedJet Records |
delete |
March 26
|
| Category:Religion in Belarus by city |
delete |
March 3
|
| Category:Religion in Brazil by city |
delete both. (non-admin closure) |
March 22
|
| Category:Religion in Gothenburg |
delete all |
March 1
|
| Category:Religion in Hagerstown, Maryland |
merge per nominator |
March 3
|
| Category:Religion in Kazakhstan by city |
delete |
March 30
|
| Category:Religion in Kievan Rus' |
merge |
March 27
|
| Category:Religion in Lithuania by city |
upmerge. (non-admin closure) |
March 24
|
| Category:Religion in Morocco by city |
delete both |
March 16
|
| Category:Religion in Northampton |
withdrawn. – |
March 27
|
| Category:Religion in Romania by city |
delete |
March 31
|
| Requested moves discussion of North Macedonia stub templates |
Template_talk:NorthMacedonia-stub#Requested_move_4_March_2019 was closed as move |
March 6
|
| Category:Right-Wing Militia |
rename Category:Right-Wing Militia to Category:Right-wing militia organizations in the United States |
March 11
|
| Category:Robert De Niro |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
March 1
|
| Category:Robot Hall of Fame inductees |
Delete |
March 28
|
| Category:Rock and Roll Hall of Fame inductees |
delete |
March 23
|
| Category:Roger Bacon |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 5
|
| Roman limes |
delete and merge. Deleting Category:Roman limes by province, and merging the others as specified in the nomination. (non-admin closure) |
March 24
|
| Category:Royal works by Sirindhorn |
speedy delete. WP:G7 per request of creator @ |
March 7
|
| Category:Rulers of Chaghaniyan |
reverse merge, i.e. merge Category:Muhtajids to Category:Rulers of Chaghaniyan |
March 1
|
| Category:Sarah Michelle Gellar |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
March 11
|
| Scandinavian royalty |
merge 1 / rename 3 per nominator |
March 11
|
| Scottish islands |
no consensus without prejudice against a fresh A/B nomination on a short term. (non-admin closure) |
March 31
|
| Scottish islands |
relisted, see here (non-admin closure) |
March 16
|
| Category:Scrotum piercings |
merge, resisting temptation of double-entendre comments |
March 3
|
| Category:Seth Meyers |
delete |
March 6
|
| Category:Sexuality books |
no consensus |
March 26
|
| Category:Shakespeare Prize recipients |
delete |
March 12
|
| Category:Ships of Egypt |
split. (non-admin closure) |
March 24
|
| Category:Sistanian poetry |
merge |
March 4
|
| Category:Six Russian strategic weapons unveiled on 2018 |
upmerge to Category:Post–Cold War weapons of Russia (non-admin closure) |
March 18
|
| Skateboarders |
merge all per nom to sportspeople-from-FooCity, and also to Category:American skateboarders |
March 23
|
| Category:Slovenian Chetniks |
rename per nominator, without prejudice to any future proposal to rename Category:Chetnik personnel of World War II and all its subcats |
March 9
|
| Category:Smith-Wintemberg Award recipients |
delete. The award-winners are already listed at Canadian Archaeological Association#Smith-Wintemberg_Award |
March 10
|
| Category:Springs (mechanical) |
relisted at WP:Categories for discussion/Log/2019 April 8#Category:Springs_(mechanical) |
March 22
|
| St. Gallen |
rename per option B. (non-admin closure) |
March 29
|
| Category:Stephen Baxter |
delete |
March 5
|
| Category:Subsystem |
delete |
March 10
|
| Category:Tea Tree oils |
delete |
March 16
|
| Category:Tekugu remakes of Tamil films |
speedy delete per WP:G6 (uncontroversial housekeeping). Simple mis-spelling, and the category is already empty |
March 22
|
| Template:Indie-rock-group-stub |
rename to Template:indie-rock-band-stub. (non-admin closure) |
March 8
|
| Category:Temporary Wikipedian user pages |
speedy delete. WP:G4 per WP:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 July 12#Category:Temporary_Wikipedian_userpages |
March 13
|
| Category:Terrorist incidents attributed to Islamic extremism |
merge. (non-admin closure) |
March 26
|
| Category:The Growlers EPs |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
March 30
|
| Category:The Killing of Sister George |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
March 24
|
| Category:Theories of economics |
merge Category:Theories of economics to Category:Schools of economic thought |
March 2
|
| Category:Thiomersal controversy |
rename. The renaming is supported by only a narrow majority of editors in this CFD, but they have on their side the fact that the title of the head article was upheld at Talk:Thiomersal and vaccines#Requested_move_19_February_2019 by what the closer describe as Very little support, much strong opposition . None of the opposes here offer any reason why this category should be an exception to the basic principle that category titles should follow article titles; instead, they were trying to re-argue issues which belong in the RM discussion. CFD is not the venue to challenge an RM outcome: we have WP:Move review for that.
It's likely that someone will ask me why I have closed this differently to the superficially similar WP:CFD 2019 February 5#Category:MMR vaccine controversy, so I will pre-emptively explain that here. The answer is simply that in this case, there is a recent RM discussion upholding the new title, but in the other case there was not.
And yes, per the discussion on my talk at |
March 9
|
| UKBot |
keep non-empty category Category:UKBot for now, and delete the others as empty.
Note to nominator @ |
March 9
|
| Category:Uma Thurman |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 6
|
| Category:Upcoming films by language |
no consensus. The precise intent is unclear, because the only category listed is a {{container category}}, but the rationale refers to (but does not quote) a previous CFD which involved a container category and its subcats. A query was also raised about whether the numerical effect claimed last time still stands.
So this discussion cannot be considered a consensus to do anything. Please feel free to make a fresh nomination which a) lists and tags all the categories which are proposed for merger, and b) sets out clearly what the rationale is, rather than just pointing towards a previous discussion. Pinging the participants: @ |
March 25
|
| Category:USA Shooting Hall of Fame inductees |
delete |
March 21
|
| Category:Utah Aviation Hall of Fame inductees |
delete. (non-admin closure) |
March 24
|
| Category:Vancouver Whitecaps (W-League) players |
rename to Category:Vancouver Whitecaps FC (women) players |
March 10
|
| Category:Video games by island country of setting |
purge; no consensus on merging (non-admin closure) |
March 2
|
| Category:Vikrant-class aircraft carriers |
delete |
March 18
|
| Category:Village in Pakistan |
merge |
March 12
|
| Category:Volleyball Hall of Fame inductees |
delete |
March 23
|
| Category:W. Somerset Maugham |
delete (non-admin closure) |
March 5
|
| Category:Web shells |
no consensus |
March 19
|
| Category:Weekly events |
keep. At first glance, this was a close call with no consensus ... but the existence of Category:Recurring events with subcats for other time periods including the recently kept Category:Daily events (see CFD 2019 February 17) means that there would need to be some persuasive reason to make weekly events an exception, and those arguments were not clearly made, let alone clearly endorsed. So the result has to be keep.
However, there is some dispute about what the scope of the category should be, and that may need further discussion |
March 17
|
| Category:WikiPathways |
rename |
March 9
|
| Category:Wikipedia character-substitution templates |
rename |
March 10
|
| Category:Wikipedia men |
merge both. (non-admin closure) |
March 24
|
| Category:Women in film |
split |
March 12
|
| Category:Works about technology |
keep (non-admin closure) |
March 28
|
| Years in London |
merge per amended nomination |
March 14
|
| Years in the Captaincy General of Chile |
rename/merge/delete as nominated (non-admin closure) |
March 1
|
