Wikipedia:New pages patrol/School/New page patrol peer review cohort November 2019

Add links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

For this peer review cohort, each participant will review two other 5 of another participant's recent patrols. While reviewing, focus on providing positive feedback and ask any questions which occur while looking at the reviewed articles.

The cohort assignments are as follows:

  1. Barkeep49 – reviewed by Onel5969 and Atsme
  2. Rosguill – reviewed by Atsme and Barkeep49
  3. Elmidae – reviewed by Barkeep49 and Rosguill
  4. Onel5969 – reviewed by Rosguill and Elmidae

:#Atsme – reviewed by Elmidae and Onel5969

Each participant should choose 3 of their own articles to be reviewed, and 1 for each of the participants that they are assigned to review. Discussion should be held on the talk pages of the articles in question, but for convenience a rubric for putting links is below.

Let's try to list our own patrolled articles by Friday, November 15th, and shoot for completing our reviews of other people's patrols by the end of the month

Assignments[edit]

Barkeep49[edit]

  1. Donglai Commandery
  2. Jo-Ann Roberts Currently under discussion at AfD where there's been a lot of discussion but I would love the peer feedback outside of that context about whether my marking it reviewed was correct Barkeep49 (talk)
  3. Stiglmaierplatz
  4. Long As I Can See the Light -chosen by Onel5969

# -chosen by Atsme

Rosguill[edit]

Finding articles amid the redirects in my patrol log is non-trivial. 2nd-4th of October had a significant concentration of actual article reviews.

  1. Nazanin Karimi -chosen by Rosguill
  2. Draft:Project Awakening -chosen by Rosguill
  3. Villa Costanza -chosen by Rosguill

# -chosen by Atsme

  1. Nicomatic SA -chosen by Barkeep49

Elmidae[edit]

I'm reasonably happy with my AfD outcomes at the moment, so I'm choosing some recent articles with other choices that might be worth discussing.

  1. Ground_(cricket) -chosen by Elmidae
  2. 2019 Pokémon World Championships -chosen by Elmidae
  3. Nationalization of PrivatBank -chosen by Elmidae. Previously redirected by Onel5969, but I signed off later on what I think was pretty much the same state
  4. Baby Keem -chosen by Barkeep49
  5. Calvin Zippin -chosen by Rosguill

Onel5969[edit]

Like Rosguill, occasionally I go through spurts of redirects, but a good clue to ones that aren't redirects is that I either tag them, or do something else to the article (like categorize them, or stub sort them, or simply tag them). For my 3 choices, they are all recent ones, and I tried to pick ones with different outcomes from my review.

  1. Seen in NY -chosen by Onel5969
  2. Draft:Hale Global -chosen by Onel5969
  3. African Americans in California -chosen by Onel5969
  4. Draft:Meta Runner-chosen by Rosguill
  5. Princess Camilla, Duchess of Castro -chosen by Elmidae

===Atsme=== I’ve chosen a few not-so-easy ones. Sorry there’s nothing more recent but this has been an extremely busy few months.

  1. Red, White and Zero chosen by Atsme
  2. Fatima al-Samarqandi chosen by Atsme
  3. MBC Standard FM chosen by Atsme
  4. -chosen by Elmidae
  5. -chosen by Onel5969

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:New_pages_patrol/School/New_page_patrol_peer_review_cohort_November_2019&oldid=928665920"