Talk:1917 Kiev City Duma election

Did you know nomination

The following is an archived discussion of the DYK nomination of the article below. Please do not modify this page. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as this nomination's talk page, the article's talk page or Wikipedia talk:Did you know), unless there is consensus to re-open the discussion at this page. No further edits should be made to this page.

The result was: promoted by Theleekycauldron (talk) 19:55, 17 March 2022 (UTC)

(

• Comment or view
• Article history

)

Propaganda for the Ukrainian Socialist Bloc for the 1917 Kiev City Duma election

• ... that Ukrainian parties (electoral propaganda pictured) merely obtained a fifth of the votes in the 1917 Kiev City Duma election? Source: Дмитро Дорошенко (1954). Історія України, 1917-1923. Булава. p. 117. OCLC 15983699.
  • Reviewed: Template:Did you know nominations/Squib-class torpedo boat

Created by Soman (talk). Self-nominated at 02:55, 28 February 2022 (UTC).

• Article meets DYK requirements, hook is fine, assuming good faith on the book source for the hook. --benlisquare_T•C•E 04:49, 1 March 2022 (UTC)
  • unfortunately, gotta put this one on hold until the DYK RfC on Russia/Ukrain is resolved. theleekycauldron (talk • contribs) (she/they) 21:58, 15 March 2022 (UTC)

To T:DYK/P4 without image

full list of elected members

Mikhail Maslennikov was a Kadet elected, per ru.wiki, with reference to «Киевлянин» №178 от 27 июля 1917 г.. For me I find the scan bit too blurry to make out all the names easily. -- Soman (talk) 10:40, 4 October 2023 (UTC)

Below an attempt to populate the listing of elected members, per the Киевлянин reference linked above. --Soman (talk) 11:06, 4 October 2023 (UTC)

[1] is much clearer --Soman (talk) 11:43, 4 October 2023 (UTC)

Number (in Киевлянин 27 Jul)	Name	List	Appears in Киевская мысль (25 Jul)
1	Dreiling, V. A. (Menshevik)	1	Yes
2	Prilezhaev, I. A. (SR - " Прилежаев , И.А. , член ЦК п.с.-р. , ученый агроном , редактор « Дела Народа » , кандидат совета партии")	1	Yes
3	Rafes, M. G. (Bund)	1	Yes
4	Białogrodzki, J. A. (PPS-Lewica)	1	Yes
5	Kruchinsky, I. M. (Menshevik, per https://vtoraya-literatura.com/pdf/volin_mensheviki_na_ukraine_1921-1921_1990__ocr.pdf )	1	Yes
6	Sukhovikh, K. A.	1	Yes
7	Ginzburg (Naumov), A. M.	1	Yes
8	Shpolyansky, G. M.	1	Yes
9	Dorotov, A. V.	1	Yes
10	Sinikovsky, N. K.	1	Yes
11	Levin, I. L.	1	Yes
12	Dushkan, M. K.	1	Yes
13	Smirnov, V. A.	1	Yes
14	Lvov, V. M.	1	Yes
15	Balabanov, M. S.	1	Yes
16	Moreinis, L. K.	1	Yes
17	Aleksev, I. N.	1	Yes
18	Frumin, I. O.	1	Yes
19	Zolotorev, A. I.	1	Yes
20	Davidzon, I. L. (Menshevik, per https://vtoraya-literatura.com/pdf/volin_mensheviki_na_ukraine_1921-1921_1990__ocr.pdf )	1	Yes
21	Kozachek, A. G.	1	Yes
22	Kononenkov, K. S.	1	Yes
23	Sklovsky, I. L.	1	Yes
24	Loginov, G. K.	1	Yes
25	Ryabtsov, E.P.	1	Yes
26	Orel, V. E.	1	Yes
27	Voropaeva, A. N.	1	Yes
28	Treskin, F. M.	1	Yes
29	Nikolaev, M. N.	1	Yes
30	Braun, E. O.	1	Yes
31	Spitsyn, A. F. (Menshevik, per https://vtoraya-literatura.com/pdf/volin_mensheviki_na_ukraine_1921-1921_1990__ocr.pdf )	1	Yes
32	Zarubin, A. N.	1	Yes
33	Dobkin, S. Y.	1	Yes
34	Pshenichnyi, M. P.	1	Yes
35	Nezlobin, P. I.	1	Yes
36	Teslenko-Prykhodko, G. P.	1	"G. P."
37	Lesnevsky, P. F.	1	Yes
38	Slutsky, L. M.	1	Yes
39	Schlesinger, Y. L.	1	Yes
40	Deshevoi, M. S.	1	Yes
41	Raevsky, V. G.	1	Yes
42	Lagunov, S. I.	1	Yes
43	Logachev, P. N.	1	Yes
44	Krokos, G. S.	1	Yes
45	Lestschinsky, Y. D.	2	Yes
46	Kornsgold, S. G.	2	"S. G. Korn..."
47	Lestschinsky, I. D.	2	Yes
48	Shulgin, V. V.	3	Yes
49	Savenko, A. I.	3	Yes
50	Kikh, A. A.	3	Yes
51	Bogaevsky, P. M.	3	Yes
52	Rekashev, I. G.	3	Yes
53	Mossakovsky, A. A.	3	Yes
54	Petrov, G. I.	3	Yes
55	Demchenko, G. V.	3	Yes
56	Podrizan, V. N.	3	Yes
57	Khmelnytsky, S. Y.	3	Yes
58	Iosefi, V. G.	3	Yes
59	Shcheglov, B. N.	3	Yes
60	Grushevsky, S. G.	3	Yes
61	Kolpinkov, N. P.	3	Yes
62	Butovsky, A. M.	3	Yes
63	Moskvichev, I. F.	3	Yes
64	Kushnerchuk, G. G.	3	"G. G. Kushkerchuk"?
65	Tieder, I. M.	3	No
66	Grigorovich-Barsky, D. N.	4	Yes
67	Vasylenko, N. P.	4	Yes
68	Kosinsky, V. A.	4	Yes
69	Butenko, P. E.	4	Yes
70	Cholgansky, L. E.	4	Yes
71	Krupnov, S. G.	4	Yes
72	Tsyvkin, V. G.	4	Yes
73	Ulinitsky, V. V.	4	"V. V. Ulyanitsky"?
74	Maslennikov, M. I.	4	Yes
75	Yaroshevich, A. I.	4	Yes
76	Pietkiewicz, M.	5	"M. M. Petkevich"
77	Szarzyński, D. S.	5	Yes
78	Drogoszewski, A. S. - Aureli Drogoszewski??	5	Yes
79	Krzyżanowski, F. B.	5	Yes
80	Zarębski, M. G.	5	Yes
81	Smólski, I. K.	5	Yes
82	Syrkin, N. S.	8	"M. Sh. Syrkin"
83	Ginzburg, A. I.	8	Yes
84	Aleksandrov, M. I.	8	Yes
85	Surdutovich, M. S.	8	Yes
86	Lestschinsky, N. M.	8	Yes
87	Ivanov, A. I.	10	Yes
88	Bogdanov, M. S.	10	Yes
89	Galperin, R. V.	10	Yes
90	Maevskaya-Masalskaya, A. I.	10	Yes
91	Fialek, I. M.	10	Yes
92	Pyatakov, G. L.	10	Yes
93	Leontyev, M. L.	10	Yes
94	Vynnychenko, V. K. (USD)	12	Yes
95	Tertychny, S. N. (USD)	12	Yes
96	Koval, V. D. (UPSR)	12	Yes
97	Drahomanov, S. M. (USD)	12	Yes
98	Dovzhenko, V. D. (USD)	12	Yes
99	Kovaleva, A. L. (UPSR)	12	Yes
100	Antonovich, D. V. (USD)	12	Yes
101	Mikhail Tkachenko (USD)	12	Yes
102	Virko, I. F. (UPSR)	12	Yes
103	Tymoshenko, A. M. (USD)	12	Yes
104	Verbilenko, I. G. (USD)	12	Yes
105	Koliukh, D. V. (USD)	12	Yes
106	Maevsky, I. A. (UPSR)	12	Yes
107	Bilyashevsky, N. F. (UPSR)	12	Yes
108	Khomenko, P. S. (USD)	12	Yes
109	Kasyanenko, A. I. (USD)	12	Yes
110	Golubenko, A. E. (USD)	12	Yes
111	Bondarenko, M. L. (UPSR)	12	Yes
112	Miroshnichenko, V. K. (UPSR)	12	Yes
113	Ponyatenko, P. D. (USD)	12	Yes
114	Potsubeenko, A. F. (USD)	12	Yes
115	Chyakalenko, L. E. (USD)	12	Yes
116	Shleichenko, A. N. (UPSR)	12	Yes
117	Advienko, M. A. (USD)	12	Yes
118	Domosławski, K. S.	14	Yes
119	Yefremov, S. A.	15	Yes
120	Ilyin, N. I.	17	Yes

Robitnycha Hazeta results

Looking at Robitnycha Hazeta (Ukr S.-D. Workers Party organ), issue 94, 1917, p. 4, we find electoral result largely identical to that in 1917 god na Kiyevshchine (1928). One key difference is however that Robitnycha Hazeta gaves List 12 a total of 25 seats and no seat for List 17.

To complicate things further, whilst the UPSR organ Borotba, published a bit later, gives the List 12 bloc 24 seats, it allocates 10 seats to UPSR. Per Robitnycha Hazeta there would be 16 USDRP deputies and 9 UPSR deputies. I'll start marking USDRP/UPSR in list above per RH. -- Soman (talk) 18:34, 7 October 2023 (UTC)

So the 25th List 12 deputy, that doesn't appear in the Kievlyanin ref would be the 9th UPSR deputy V. A. Ignatienko. --Soman (talk) 18:50, 7 October 2023 (UTC)

This would have been Ігнатієнко Варфоломій Андріанович, who according to uk.wiki was elected speaker deputy of the City Duma in the summer of 1917... --Soman (talk) 18:52, 7 October 2023 (UTC)

To complicate even more, Киевская мысль, 25 July 1917 issue http://elib.shpl.ru/ru/nodes/66434-locale-nil-180-25-iyulya#mode/inspect/page/2/zoom/9 , has yet another listing of elected deputies to the City Duma. Moreover, it has voting result district by district, but seemingly with some errors. --Soman (talk) 11:05, 12 October 2023 (UTC)

Here we find a listing of Polish deputies "Wiarą we własne siły mogły Pol . Komitet Wykonawczy natchnąć wybory do rady miejskiej Kijowa : tzw . „ Polska lista wyborcza " otrzymała 6 mandatów ( M. Pietkiewicz , D. Szarzyński , A. Drogoszewski , Krzyżanowski , M. Zarębski , Smólski ) . Tymczasem P.P.S. frakcja tylko 1 ( Kaz . Domosławski ) i P.P.S. lewica 1 ( Jan Białogrodzki )" --Soman (talk) 12:35, 14 October 2023 (UTC)

And here we have the full candidate listing for List 1, all names for 1-44 checks out. I added Russian names in hidden brackets above. --Soman (talk) 18:31, 14 October 2023 (UTC)

References