Wikipedia:Peer review/Like Spinning Plates/archive1
Like Spinning Plates[edit]
This peer review discussion has been closed.
I've listed this article for peer review because…
Right, this time the article should work. Please give me your thoughts.
Thanks, Tkotse (talk) 05:10, 31 March 2008 (UTC)
Ruhrfisch comments: A very interesting article, here are some suggestions for improvement:
- The lead is two sentences and should be expanded to summarize the entire article. See WP:LEAD
- What is already there is fairly well written, but I think more could be added.
- For example, is there any information about the musical key, chords, chord progression, time signature?
- Who is credited as the author(s) of the song? Could there be more on the lyrics than the cloud cuckoo land quote? Even the lyrical structure (verse, refrain, verse?)
- Try to be more specific - which songs This technique is similar to ones used by The Beatles and The Stone Roses on some of thier songs.[2] Or what year was the song first performed live?
- For the preceding quote, Wikipedia is not a reliable source - see WP:RS and check all the refs.
- Internet references need url, title, publisher, author if known, and date accessed. Try using the {{cite web}} for consistency
- There is no critical reception information - this is a major album by a major group and was reviewed widely at the time, get to a library and look up the reviews and see what critics said about this.
- Music video, Notes and Hidden Booklet sections are all way too short, and why are notes on the lyrics and a hidden booklet a subsection of the video?
- The hidden booklet should be a normal image, not a gallery. It needs a valid fair use summary - see WP:FAIR USE
- Find a model article to follow here, preferably a GA or FA.
- There are several Radiohead FAs, see who were major contributors to them and ask them for assistance / advice.
- You could probably have a brief sound clip (fair use) in this article.