Wikipedia:Peer review/Great power/archive2

Great power

Previous peer review

• A script has been used to generate a semi-automated review of the article for issues relating to grammar and house style; it can be found on the automated peer review page for July 2008.

This peer review discussion has been closed.
I've listed this article for peer review because it used to have Good Article status but it's since been delisted after some upheaval. Since then, a lot has changed and it has stabilized in the last few days. We are looking to reach GA status once again and would appreciate feedback. Thanks!

Thanks, Nirvana888 (talk) 18:20, 21 July 2008 (UTC)

Comments from Emw2012 (talk · contribs)

• Inconsistent capitalization of great and middle power occurs throughout the article (Great power, great power, Middle Power). As neither superpower nor middle power are capitalized in their respective articles, I would remove capitalization from all usages of 'great power' or 'middle power' in this article. If a quote originally capitalized 'Great power' then that should be preserved, but only inside that particular quote. Fixed.

• There should be no spacing between in-line citations and the punctuation they proceed. See citation [7], and there's one more I can't find again right now. Fixed.

• The following sentence from the 'Current great powers' section needs work: "Germany is considered by experts to be an economic power.[26][27], and by chancellor Angela Merkel[28], former president Johannes Rau[29] and leading media of the country[30] as a middle power in Europe." While placing citations close to their subject helps specificity, here it's overwhelming and a distraction. Fixed.
• Also in the 'Current great powers' section, the parenthetical note next to 'United States' -- "(also referred to as a superpower)" -- should be normally sized/formatted. Fixed

• References 16 and 29 should have their formatting fixed.

• ISBN identifiers should be added to the referenced texts. For example, see current reference 26 (Max Otte, Jürgen Greve (2000). A Rising Middle Power?: German Foreign Policy in Transformation, 1989-1999, 324. ISBN 0312226535.).

• Redundant wikilinks in the same section should be removed per WP:OVERLINK. Specific offenders include 'Napoleonic Wars' in History (I'd keep the second wikilinked), and names of various nations throughout the article. Fixed

• Image captions that are full sentences should end in a period; those that are sentence fragments should not. Every graphic except for the first gets this wrong. Fixed. Emw2012 (talk) 21:13, 1 August 2008 (UTC)