| Category |
Decision |
Discussion_log
|
| Category:1858 establishments in Kansas |
Snow merge |
July 29
|
| Category:1859 establishments in the Kingdom of Württemberg |
Rename |
July 11
|
| Category:1904 in Namibia |
Rename |
July 10
|
| Category:1926 in Namibia |
Rename. I'm leaving the creation of redirects to others |
July 10
|
| 1928 establishments in Pakistan |
Merge. Depending on the outcome of the RFC having both may be appropriate |
July 8
|
| Category:1932 in Lesotho |
Rename |
July 9
|
| Category:1967 establishments in Tanganyika |
Rename |
July 20
|
| Category:2007 Flemish television series debuts |
Merge |
July 24
|
| Category:2011 Tōhoku earthquake and tsunami relief |
Withdrawn |
July 26
|
| Category:Actor of Red Ranger |
delete |
July 3
|
| Category:Albums recorded in India |
No consensus |
July 10
|
| Category:Alfred I. duPont–Columbia University Award recipients |
delete |
July 28
|
| All Stars Awards winners |
Delete. This seems reasonable given the long track record of award categories. I see the nomination by FL as completing cleanup and this is not a repudiation of the close he did. However given the comments here, the old rename targets need to be reviewed and probably nominated for a review to see if they should be kept |
July 26
|
| Category:Alumni of the University of Cincinnati |
speedy merge as duplicate |
July 29
|
| Category:American child actresses |
Keep. If a rename is to happen it must be from the top of the tree on down |
July 31
|
| Category:American Freemasons with criminal convictions |
Delete |
July 19
|
| Category:American police officers executed for murder |
Upmerge |
July 19
|
| Category:American war films & Category:American war drama films |
Reverse merge |
July 24
|
| Category:Ancient mints |
Delete |
July 1
|
| Category:Anglo-African people |
Merge |
July 11
|
| Category:App stubs |
rename/merge templates |
July 3
|
| Category:AR-10 derivatives |
Discussion closed. Not sure what was expected, but |
July 25
|
| Category:Archaeological terminology |
Keep |
July 31
|
| Category:Archeological terminology |
rename, which has become a de facto merge. Note this should not be considered prejudicial to the fate of the target category |
July 4
|
| Category:Assassinations by country and Category:Assassinated people by nationality |
Keep |
July 25
|
| Category:Association football clubs by capital |
Merge to Category:Association football clubs by city to keep them in the city tree |
July 12
|
| Category:Austrian Holocaust Memorial Award recipients |
Delete |
July 30
|
| Category:Barbary Coast Trail |
Delete |
July 16
|
| Category:Bookstores in The Netherlands |
Rename to Category:Bookstores in the Netherlands |
July 31
|
| Category:Buildings with blue plaques |
Delete |
July 12
|
| Category:Busia District, Kenya |
Rename per nom |
July 20
|
| Category:Carmel Buckingham |
Delete |
July 9
|
| Category:Castles in Achaia |
Rename |
July 1
|
| Category:Catalan classical musicians by instrument |
Delete. Subcategory already in upmerge target |
July 19
|
| Categories: A variety covering people executed by firing squad in Romania |
no consensus |
July 24
|
| Category:Catholic Church organizations |
Keep/withdrawn |
July 6
|
| Category:Cavalry tanks |
No consensus. I will note that the discussion seemed to lead to no objections for a cleanup of Category:Cruiser tanks by moving articles to other categories |
July 13
|
| Category:Chile under Allende |
Rename |
July 24
|
| Category:Christian denominations and unions by century established |
Rename. Since the subcategories were not nominated, they should be processed as speedies |
July 5
|
| Category:Christian worship objects |
Merge |
July 2
|
| Category:Cities in the New York metropolitan area |
Keep. Follow on comment. As I was closing this I noticed that the contents here are not the city articles, but rather the city categories. Someone probably needs to go through this and include the city articles and remove the city categories |
July 6
|
| Category:Cities in Ulster County, New York |
No consensus |
July 20
|
| Category:Clothing of Marilyn Monroe |
merge to Category:Marilyn Monroe |
July 13
|
| Category:Companies that have filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy |
relisted on August 1 |
July 10
|
| Category:Computer mahjong |
merge |
July 27
|
| Category:Constituency of Grenada |
Rename |
July 24
|
| Category:Cultural depictions of Cleopatra VII |
Rename |
July 2
|
| Category:Debit card issuer association |
Rename |
July 24
|
| Category:Dinocons |
Merge |
July 18
|
| Category:Displaced people |
Delete |
July 11
|
| Category:Double-named places in Australia |
Listify. The ones that were not in the existing list were added to Talk:List of Australian repeated place names to be added to the list |
July 5
|
| Category:Double-named places in New Zealand |
Listify |
July 5
|
| Category:Double-named places |
Listify |
July 5
|
| Category:Drug addiction |
Merge |
July 18
|
| Category:Exotic weaponry & Category:Exotic firearms |
Delete |
July 2
|
| FC Omniworld and Almere City FC |
Merge |
July 30
|
| Category:Fictional elements |
Rename |
July 8
|
| Category:Films in The Lord of the Rings (film series) |
Merge |
July 23
|
| First Nations reserves - Indian reserves |
Rename |
July 19
|
| Category:Foreign Members |
Rename. Whether we need to have this type of categorization at this level should be a new nomination |
July 26
|
| Category:Foreign-language broadcasting in the United States |
Rename. No objection to a follow on nomination if a better name is identified |
July 5
|
| Category:Foster the People |
Delete |
July 18
|
| Category:Freemasons by nationality |
No consensus to keep. My problem is that the discussion did not consider the fact that this is an attempt to support previous discussions like this one or this one and there are others. Add to that the issue with not nominating the entire tree and we have a nomination that is not able to gain consensus. So one option forward is to renominate listing all of the affected categories. Another would be to reorganize based on the comments below, but that does not really address the history of previous discussions. So if deletion is attempted, it should mention all of the previous discussions to frame the discussion and see if in fact there is a change in consensus. Reorganization, may just be time saver for parts of the tree since the underlying support for the entire tree is not clearly established. The deletion review that was involved should also be addressed in future discussions. Also I will note that the category was recreated without discussion of why it should be unsalted so that action, given the previous discussions and the deletion review, are also on the table. Good luck |
July 27
|
| Category:Freemasons with criminal convictions |
Delete |
July 19
|
| Category:Future amusement parks |
Rename |
July 5
|
| Category:Genderqueer actors |
Delete. Yes there was a discussion, but the category only has one member at present and probably only has 3 valid members so, at this time, it is too small. If there are more members in the future, recreation can be considered |
July 17
|
| Category:German materiel of World War I |
Rename |
July 14
|
| Category:German socialists opposed to the Third Reich |
Delete |
July 25
|
| Category:Golden Age of Porn actors |
delete |
July 3
|
| Category:Golden Crown Literary Award winners |
Delete |
July 11
|
| Category:Golshiri Award winners |
Delete |
July 11
|
| Category:Guided missiles by operator |
Delete |
July 6
|
| Category:Gulfs of Mexico |
no consensus to rename |
July 12
|
| Category:Heavy armoured personnel carriers |
Merge note that heavy armour is a redirect and that article does not address a definition for this term in at least the 1st ten hits |
July 13
|
| Category:Herzl Award recipients |
Delete |
July 23
|
| Category:Indian people of Bangladeshi descent |
Delete |
July 8
|
| Category:Inspirational films |
Delete |
July 7
|
| Category:Iowa Chops |
rename/merge all. Long-time consensus is that when a team changes names, the categories do too, with the old name becoming a {{category redirect}} |
July 28
|
| Category:IRB Junior World Championship team navigational boxes |
Delete |
July 31
|
| Category:Isis (band) albums |
Keep |
July 24
|
| Category:Japanese Actor |
Speedy Merge. An obvious typo by a brand new editor |
July 2
|
| Category:Jets |
delete |
July 22
|
| Category:John Rabe Award recipients |
Delete |
July 11
|
| Category:Katzenjammer (band) |
Delete |
July 15
|
| Category:Kenyan football transfer lists |
Delete |
July 26
|
| Lesotho |
Rename |
July 8
|
| Category:Light armored vehicle |
rename |
July 20
|
| Category:List of educational institutions in Vellore |
Delete |
July 22
|
| Category:List of Nadars |
delete |
July 3
|
| Category:Lists of college bowl games |
Rename |
July 26
|
| Category:Lobbyists funded by foreign governments that seek to influence the American government |
delete |
July 20
|
| Category:Luminism |
rename |
July 5
|
| Lyrics and music categories |
Rename |
July 16
|
| Category:Male wartime nurses |
No consensus |
July 18
|
| Category:Mammals of the United Kingdom |
Merge. Some cleanup may be necessary |
July 4
|
| Category:Mammals parasites |
rename to "Parasites of X" format |
July 28
|
| Category:Medical evacuation vehicles |
Rename |
July 18
|
| Category:Medieval armour |
Split. There is no consensus in the discussion about moving this. However it is clear that something is needed. So feel free to create Category:Plate armour and move all of the articles that belong there and cleanup the rest as would normally be done. Once the cleanup is done, this should be brought back for more discussion if the category still needs renaming. There are some medieval things in there and clearly they probably need to be dealt with as a group. I'm also concerned with Category:Medieval armour stubs and where that would go if the nominated category were to be deleted or renamed |
July 15
|
| Members of the Senate of Northern Ireland |
Rename/split |
July 27
|
| Category:Military equipment by conflict |
Rename |
July 30
|
| Category:Military equipment of the British Empire |
delete |
July 28
|
| Category:Military vehicles of the United States Marine Corps |
delete |
July 3
|
| Category:Modern military equipment of Japan |
Rename |
July 31
|
| Category:Modern surface-to-air missiles |
Merge to Category:Surface-to-air missiles |
July 9
|
| Category:Modern weapons of Germany |
Rename |
July 17
|
| Category:Multinational musical groups |
delete |
July 28
|
| Category:Mutants (Transformers) |
Delete |
July 18
|
| Category:Māori plant common names |
Listify |
July 23
|
| Category:Napoleonic forts in England |
Rename |
July 21
|
| Category:National Games of the People's Republic of China navigational boxes |
No action. This is a collection category for templates and not a category about the event so the logic offered does not appear to apply |
July 24
|
| Category:Navigational meta-templates |
no consensus |
July 11
|
| Category:Neighborhoods in Honolulu, Hawaii |
no consensus |
July 14
|
| Category:New Rochelle Walk of Fame |
Delete |
July 12
|
| Category:Oh Land |
Delete |
July 9
|
| Orange County Blue Star |
Merge |
July 19
|
| category:Original Fellows of the Royal Society |
Closed. Nominated category not tagged and with no discussion, this is the best that can be done. No objection to renomination following a correct listing of the category |
July 26
|
| Category:Pakistani American films |
Rename |
July 30
|
| Category:Paris Saint-Germain Féminines |
Delete |
July 4
|
| Category:Patria Pasi |
Merge |
July 15
|
| Category:Penile erection |
Keep |
July 11
|
| Category:People by capital |
delete |
July 3
|
| Category:People from D'Iberville, Mississippi |
merge |
July 27
|
| Category:People from Fairmont, North Carolina |
merge. The only "objection" is, to be honest, inexplicable |
July 28
|
| Category:People from Mombasa District |
Delete |
July 17
|
| Category:People from Stewartstown, New Hampshire |
Merge |
July 31
|
| Category:People who refused the title of People's Artist of Ukraine |
Delete |
July 4
|
| Category:Place names associated with Jews |
Delete |
July 1
|
| Category:Plants used in traditional Shipibo-Conibo medicine |
Delete |
July 4
|
| Category:Plants vs. Zombies |
Delete |
July 13
|
| Category:Police misconduct in France |
No consensus. Looks like this and the previous discussion need a longer discussion about what is best to do. Take that discussion to a talk page and if there is a consensus bring it back here |
July 19
|
| Category:Police misconduct in Germany |
No consensus. Looks like this and the previous discussion need a longer discussion about what is best to do. Take that discussion to a talk page and if there is a consensus bring it back here |
July 19
|
| Category:Police misconduct in Nazi-occupied Poland |
Delete |
July 19
|
| Category:Policies and views of Hassan Rouhani |
Merge to Category:Hassan Rouhani |
July 4
|
| Category:Political repression in Chile during the military government of Chile (1973–90) |
Rename |
July 24
|
| Category:Populated places in the Siyanda District Municipality |
Rename |
July 19
|
| Pre-statehood establishments in Washington |
Rename. The 1861 category may have different issues and anyone who wants to discuss that one is free to nominate if for a separate discussion |
July 8
|
| Category:Presbyterian clergy by nationality |
Rename |
July 16
|
| Category:Professional soccer teams in Pennsylvania |
merge to Category:Pennsylvania soccer teams |
July 28
|
| Category:Pseudophilosophy |
delete |
July 3
|
| Category:Qayaas |
Delete |
July 9
|
| Category:Randolph Township, New Jersey and category:Margate City, New Jersey |
Rename Margate. Randolph is a no consensus call |
July 26
|
| Category:Real C.D. España |
Keep |
July 25
|
| Category:Recipients of Campaign Finance from Monsanto |
Delete |
July 22
|
| Category:Reportedly haunted locations in the Philippines |
Merge |
July 1
|
| Category:Retro video games |
Delete |
July 31
|
| Category:Roman-era pagans |
Rename. There was no consensus to delete. There was consensus to do something other then delete. The suggestion to rename to Category:Byzantine-era pagans appears to address some of the concerns about the current name. I have no objection to a follow on nomination after the rename and cleanup if there are still issues or a better idea |
July 21
|
| Category:Royal Navy courts martial |
Delete |
July 31
|
| Category:Russian people of World War II |
not merged. Whether these should, as a whole, use "Russian" instead of "Soviet" is a box to be opened another time |
July 26
|
| Category:Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting |
Delete |
July 2
|
| Category:Sassanid Empire |
Rename |
July 18
|
| Category:Sci Fi Channel |
speedy merge WP:C2D. – |
July 11
|
| Category:Scotswood |
Keep |
July 10
|
Section header on discussion page United States Navy Kentucky-related ships |
Delete |
July 19
|
| Category:Secular Jewish culture |
Keep. The nomination and the close do not address the issues of content raised in the discussion. So if some of the articles need to be moved to a different, possibly new, category, that is acceptable with this close |
July 29
|
| Category:Segunda División Peruana |
Rename |
July 24
|
| Category:Self-propelled anti-aircraft weapons |
No consensus |
July 14
|
| Category:Ships abandoned by their captain |
Delete. Bottom line, this is about the captain and not the ship |
July 19
|
| Category:Skeuomorphism |
Merge |
July 9
|
| Category:Snooker venues |
Delete |
July 25
|
| Category:Song recordings produced by Daft Punk |
Delete |
July 10
|
| Songs by decade and genre |
Delete. I checked a handful of articles and they are in in the pop song tree through other categories. If any do fall out they can manually be fixed |
July 23
|
| Category:Songs written by Daisuke Suzuki |
Rename to Category:Songs written by Ami Suzuki. No objection to someone adding the second category if that is appropriate |
July 25
|
| Category:Songs written by David M. Bellamy |
result |
July 22
|
| Category:Spanish colonial infrastructures in the Philippines |
Rename |
July 14
|
| Category:Spanish–American War weapons |
delete |
July 28
|
| Category:SPIE journals |
Rename |
July 7
|
| Category:Sports Park |
delete. – |
July 8
|
| Category:Sri Lankan knights |
Rename. The parent categories were considered in making the decision and clearly they supported the proposal |
July 14
|
| Category:Star Trek Q episodes |
Delete. Would have potentailly been a listify, but the list is already at Q (Star Trek)#List of all appearances |
July 31
|
| Category:Summer camps in novels |
Delete |
July 18
|
| Category:Texas Brahmas players |
Rename |
July 15
|
| Category:The Simpsons characters featured on DVD and Blu-Ray |
Delete |
July 15
|
| Category:Theatrical tours |
Rename |
July 20
|
| Category:TMG - Truck Mounted Gun |
Delete |
July 13
|
| Category:Town Managers of Saugus, Massachusetts |
Keep |
July 26
|
| Category:Tracked armoured recovery vehicles by country |
Merge/delete. All of the article were already in Category:Tracked armoured recovery vehicles |
July 13
|
| Category:Traditional Chinese objects |
Delete |
July 9
|
| Category:United Kingdom employment law |
Rename |
July 25
|
| USC Upstate athletics categories |
Rename |
July 13
|
| Virginia Beach Mariners |
merge |
July 20
|
| Category:Virtuti Militari |
Delete |
July 5
|
| Category:Volunteer Postmortem Eye Donation |
Merge |
July 7
|
| Category:Voynich manuscript |
Delete |
July 16
|
| Category:Weep (band) |
Delete |
July 15
|
| Category:Wikipedia requested photographs in Atlanta |
No action Nomination was not complete on the category page |
July 7
|
| Category:WikiProject Herschend Family Entertainment |
Rename. If templates need updating can someone please take care of that? |
July 7
|
| Category:World War I armoured fighting vehicles of Italy |
withdrawn by nominator. – |
July 14
|
| Category:Zerilli-Marimò Prize winners |
Delete |
July 11
|
