| Category |
Decision |
Discussion_log
|
| 1208 and 1349 categories |
Rename all per nom |
October 15
|
| Category:14th-century BC women |
Do not rename |
October 8
|
| Category:1989 Tamil Films |
delete |
October 28
|
| Category:2000 AD |
rename. — |
October 21
|
| Category:2010 Winter Olympics ice hockey roster templates |
speedy delete per author request (G7) |
October 8
|
| Category:2nd United States Congress |
WITHDRAWN. |
October 19
|
| Category:3 albums |
Rename |
October 25
|
| Category:3d flight planning |
merge |
October 3
|
| Category:90210 episodes |
Rename |
October 2
|
| Category:? & the Mysterians albums |
rename. — |
October 23
|
| ABC categories |
Rename |
October 15
|
| Category:Abnaki class fleet ocean tugs |
rename |
October 30
|
| Category:Abrocomidae |
rename |
October 20
|
| Category:Acid attack victims |
keep |
October 21
|
| Action on climate change |
Merge: |
October 23
|
| Category:Actors from South Africa |
Merge |
October 8
|
| Category:Actors with dwarfism |
Keep |
October 11
|
| Category:Adult contemporary albums |
 Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2009 November 5#Category:Adult contemporary albums. |
October 27
|
| Category:Afghanistan Online Media |
Rename |
October 3
|
| Category:African American Cemeteries |
Rename |
October 26
|
| Category:African American rappers |
keep. — |
October 25
|
| Category:African shrews |
RENAME |
October 18
|
| Afro Australians |
Upmerge all into Category:Australians of Black African descent |
October 28
|
| Category:Agricultural tractor manufacturers of Greece |
Merge |
October 2
|
| Category:AGV |
Merge Category:AGV to Category:High-speed trains |
October 26
|
| Category:AhleSunnat (Barelwi) |
RENAME. In addition to the comments below, the article is at Barelvi, to which the category name has always been a redirect |
October 16
|
| Category:Airline destinations |
rename |
October 19
|
| Category:Al Wasl Club Pages |
Rename Category:Al Wasl Club Pages to Category:Al Wasl FC |
October 30
|
| Category:Album by David Garett |
Merge to Category:David Garrett albums |
October 2
|
| Category:Albums by Benn Jordan pseudonyms |
Delete |
October 2
|
| Category:Albums by UK |
Rename |
October 2
|
| Category:Albums by Zarif |
Rename |
October 2
|
| Category:Albums produced by Ahmet Ertegün |
Rename Category:Albums produced by Ahmet Ertegün to Category:Albums produced by Ahmet Ertegun |
October 14
|
| Category:Albums produced by Nesuhi Ertegün |
Rename Category:Albums produced by Nesuhi Ertegün to Category:Albums produced by Nesuhi Ertegun |
October 14
|
| Category:Alcazar |
RENAME. |
October 21
|
| Category:Algologists |
Rename all per nom |
October 15
|
| Category:All-electric cars |
MERGE |
October 18
|
| Category:Alleged holocaust perpetrators |
Delete |
October 10
|
| Category:American campaign managers |
NOT MERGED. |
October 20
|
| Category:American radio presenters |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2009 November 4#Category:American radio presenters. |
October 21
|
| Category:Amphibians of Michigan |
Merge Category:Amphibians of Michigan to Category:Amphibians of the United States |
October 11
|
| Category:Ancient Greek comic epics |
Rename to Category:Ancient Greek mock-heroic poems. On-the-fly consensus. |
October 6
|
| Category:Anglican dioceses in Canada |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2009 November 4#Category:Anglican dioceses in Canada. |
October 23
|
| Animals and fauna categories |
Rename all |
October 16
|
| Category:Anti-Armenian Wikipedians |
Delete |
October 10
|
| Category:Antisemitic propaganda |
keep. — |
October 23
|
| Category:Appleseed |
rename. — |
October 21
|
| Category:Aqua |
RENAME. |
October 21
|
| Category:Arachnids of Michigan |
Merge Category:Arachnids of Michigan to Category:Spiders of North America |
October 8
|
| Aris Thessaloniki |
Rename. I also agree these could be sent to speedy under criterion #1. The criterion now states that "This includes grammatical or typographic corrections that have been approved for similar cases in a full CfD." |
October 7
|
| Category:Armada of the Argentine Republic ship names |
rename. — |
October 29
|
| Artery Foundation |
Delete. |
October 22
|
| Category:Articles needing more editors |
Delete |
October 25
|
| Asia |
Rename both |
October 8
|
| Category:Athlete songs |
rename. — |
October 23
|
| Category:Atletico Nacional seasons |
rename |
October 8
|
| Category:ATSF locomotives |
rename. — |
October 24
|
| Category:Barcelona KIA |
merge; category has remained empty and no objections |
October 8
|
| Bashkir |
rename/merge as nominated |
October 24
|
| Category:Basilicas in Armenia |
RENAME |
October 16
|
| Category:Basilisk |
Delete |
October 21
|
| Basketballers |
DELETE/MERGE per nom. |
October 22
|
| Category:Bat genera |
No Consensus |
October 18
|
| Category:Bat species |
MERGE |
October 17
|
| Category:Bay class landing ship dock ships |
Rename Category:Bay class landing ship dock ships to Category:Bay class landing ship docks |
October 26
|
| Category:Beitar/Shimshon Tel Aviv F.C. players |
Rename |
October 20
|
| Category:Bell X1 |
RENAME. |
October 21
|
| Category:Bernini |
rename. — |
October 21
|
| Category:Berserk |
rename. — |
October 21
|
| Category:Big Brother |
rename. — |
October 21
|
| Category:Binational solution |
MERGE. |
October 27
|
| Category:Biota of North Carolina |
Merge Category:Biota of North Carolina to Category:Natural history of North Carolina |
October 14
|
| Category:Birds of Oklahoma |
Merge |
October 11
|
| Category:Birds of Ontario |
Merge Category:Birds of Ontario to Category:Birds of Canada |
October 17
|
| Category:Birds of Sierra Madre Occidental |
Delete |
October 11
|
| Category:Birds of Sierra Madre Oriental |
Delete |
October 13
|
| Category:Birds of the Madrean sky islands |
Delete |
October 11
|
| Category:Black Flag |
rename. — |
October 21
|
| Category:Black Jack |
RENAME; no consensus for deletion, but feel free to relist. |
October 21
|
| Category:Blackpool media |
result. For the UK, this appears to be the most common form, so a rename is not out of order |
October 6
|
| Category:Blazin' Squad |
split as nominated |
October 18
|
| Category:Boston Men's Baseball League |
Delete |
October 18
|
| Category:Botticelli |
RENAME. |
October 21
|
| Category:Bradley Foundation |
Delete |
October 13
|
| Brazilian-Jiu-Jitsu practitioners |
Rename all |
October 12
|
| Category:British-American politicians |
DELETE. |
October 22
|
| Category:Brummie |
Merge into Category:Wikipedians in Birmingham |
October 4
|
| Category:Buildings and structures in Greater St. Louis |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2009 November 5#Category:Buildings and structures in Greater St. Louis. |
October 27
|
| Buildings |
Rename/merge all |
October 18
|
| Category:Business Units |
Delete |
October 18
|
| Category:Calomyscus |
Merge Category:Calomyscus to Category:Mouse-like hamsters |
October 16
|
| Category:Campaign managers |
NOT MERGED. |
October 20
|
| Category:Can |
|
October 20
|
| Category:Canadian diesel locomotives & Category:Diesel locomotives of the USA |
NOT MERGED, but RENAME Category:Diesel locomotives of the USA --> Category:American diesel locomotives, to conform to the standard form in Category:Diesel locomotives by country. Some comments urged renaming all subcategories to "Diesel locomotives of Foo", but none of the other categories were tagged and listed here, so this CFD could not accomplish that. Please start a new one if you want to change the standard for the whole scheme |
October 18
|
| Category:Canadian Isles class trawlers |
rename |
October 13
|
| Category:Capromyidae |
rename |
October 20
|
| Category:Captain Underpants |
Delete |
October 1
|
| Car bombing |
MERGE |
October 16
|
| Category:Car bombings in the Chechen-Russian conflict |
Nominator withdrawal; category deleted as empty; see below |
October 12
|
| Category:Carlo Rossi |
DELETE. |
October 21
|
| Category:Categories in Oregon by county |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2009 November 17#Category:Categories in Oregon by county |
October 24
|
| Category:Category suppression-supporting templates |
Delete |
October 31
|
| Category:Characters in Bhagavatam |
rename |
October 13
|
| Category:Child rearing |
MERGE. |
October 27
|
| China Open |
rename/merge as nominated |
October 26
|
| Category:Chowdhury family |
delete |
October 9
|
| Category:Christian rock albums by artist |
MERGE. |
October 21
|
| Category:Christian video game images |
No Consensus |
October 30
|
| Category:Cinema of Cote d'Ivoire |
Rename |
October 1
|
| Category:CITIC |
rename. — |
October 26
|
| Category:Clubs that have played in the UEFA Champions League group stage |
Delete |
October 5
|
| Category:CNW locomotives |
rename. — |
October 24
|
| Category:Coastal towns in California |
merge. — |
October 27
|
| Category:Coleoptera of Michigan |
Merge |
October 7
|
| Category:Colonial architecture |
Withdrawn by nominator. Category has been retained, but its scope has been changed per discussion |
October 23
|
| Category:Comic book inkers |
rename |
October 21
|
| Common (entertainer) |
RENAME. |
October 22
|
| Category:Common chords |
merge |
October 22
|
| Communities in New York |
Rename all |
October 29
|
| Companies |
Rename all; proper new name for Category:Companies in Trivandrum will be determined based on an other discussion which is still open |
October 22
|
| Confederate States |
rename all to "Confederate States" format (i.e., Category:Military equipment of the Confederate States not being changed). |
October 26
|
| Category:Conglomerates |
Rename to Category:Conglomerates (geology). |
October 22
|
| Congo |
Rename |
October 1
|
| Congolese |
rename as nominated |
October 24
|
| Category:Connie Talbot |
Delete |
October 24
|
| Category:Conservative websites |
Delete |
October 2
|
| Category:Cook Islands rugby league players |
rename. — |
October 26
|
| Category:Cook Islands rugby union footballers |
rename. — |
October 26
|
| Category:Corvettes of Austria |
Rename |
October 2
|
| Category:Country songs by songwriter |
merge |
October 10
|
| Category:Country songs |
Merge |
October 26
|
| Category:Crystal Palace F.C. Player of the Year award winners |
delete |
October 27
|
| Category:Ctenodactylidae |
rename |
October 26
|
| Category:Ctenomys |
rename |
October 20
|
| Category:Cycling at the 2008 Summer Olympics |
Delete |
October 27
|
| Category:Cycling executives |
rename to Category:Cycle racing executives as suggested by |
October 27
|
| Category:Czech stage directors |
Rename |
October 21
|
| Category:Córdoba province |
rename. — |
October 27
|
| Category:Dark Age of Comic Books |
merge |
October 5
|
| Category:Dark Funeral discography |
delete (was empty at close). |
October 10
|
| Category:David Gilmour songs |
keep |
October 20
|
| Category:De La Salle Professional Schools |
merge |
October 30
|
| Category:De La Salle University-Manila alumni |
rename |
October 30
|
| Category:Deaths due to horse attacks |
delete. There's consensus to delete the category but not really with what to do with its one article (Philip of Burgundy, Count of Auvergne). However, the fate of the article does not need to be decided here before we delete the category. |
October 12
|
| Category:Defunct towns in Maryland |
delete. — |
October 27
|
| Category:Democrats for Life of America |
Delete |
October 13
|
| Category:Descent |
rename |
October 28
|
| Category:Deserts of Yukon |
delete all three. The provincial categories were empty at closing and the national category contained only the provincial subcategories. |
October 29
|
| Category:Dictyoptera of Michigan |
Merge Category:Dictyoptera of Michigan to Category:Insects of North America |
October 8
|
| Category:Diesel locomotives of Ireland |
Keep |
October 23
|
| Category:Dimension films |
rename |
October 31
|
| Dinosaur museums by state categories |
Merge all per nom |
October 11
|
| Category:Dio |
RENAME. |
October 20
|
| Category:Dives |
Rename Category:Dives to Category:Dives (bird). |
October 31
|
| Category:Doctors of Music |
do not create category |
October 29
|
| Category:Duffy |
RENAME. |
October 21
|
| Category:Dynasty |
RENAME. |
October 21
|
| Category:Eagle |
Rename |
October 9
|
| Eastern Orthodox Christians from Foo |
Rename all per nom |
October 22
|
| Category:Ecuadorian–Peruvian Conflict |
Rename |
October 3
|
| Category:Editors who are not getting feedback from their good edits |
delete. – |
October 2
|
| Category:Education academics |
No Consensus |
October 8
|
| Category:Empire of the Sun |
RENAME. |
October 21
|
| Category:Engineering vehicles |
no consensus |
October 31
|
| Category:Engineering vehicles |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2009 October 31#Category:Engineering vehicles. |
October 18
|
| Category:English Nobel laureates |
Merge |
October 25
|
| Category:English people of African-American descent |
Keep. besides the concerns below, one of the problems with the rename is that Category:British people by ethnic or national origin is a parent category to Category:English people by ethnic or national origin. So an upmerge of Category:English people of African-American descent to Category:British people of American descent would be inappropriate unless the whole structure was upmerged |
October 25
|
| Category:Enigma |
rename. — |
October 21
|
| Category:Eozapus |
merge |
October 26
|
| Epics to epic poems |
Rename all. (This time I'll avoid making an unexpected assignment for Debresser to complete.) |
October 6
|
| ER categories |
Rename All. |
October 27
|
| Category:Erie locomotives |
rename. — |
October 24
|
| Category:Ernie Ashworth songs |
rename |
October 20
|
| Category:Ertl |
Rename |
October 8
|
| Category:Eureka |
rename. — |
October 21
|
| Europe categories |
Rename all. |
October 27
|
| Category:Evangelic Mission Supporters |
Merge |
October 2
|
| Category:Existense |
MERGE. |
October 26
|
| Category:Expatriate footballers in Canada |
merge |
October 23
|
| Category:Expatriates from Democratic Republic of the Congo |
merge |
October 22
|
| Category:Fauna of the San Francisco Bay Area |
Merge Category:Fauna of the San Francisco Bay Area to Category:Endemic fauna of California |
October 7
|
| FC Arsenal Kyiv |
Rename |
October 7
|
| Category:Feminist video games |
delete. — |
October 29
|
| Category:Fictional characters with inferiority complex |
Delete |
October 5
|
| Fictional Foos to Fictional Fooian people |
Rename: |
October 14
|
| Category:Fictional planets |
NOT RENAMED |
October 18
|
| Category:Fictional United States Democrats |
rename |
October 22
|
| Category:Fictional United States Republicans |
rename |
October 22
|
| Category:Film production companies of Malaysia |
do not rename |
October 31
|
| Category:Film schools in Philippines |
Rename |
October 1
|
| Category:FireHouse |
RENAME. |
October 21
|
| Category:First ladies that posed nude |
delete. — |
October 26
|
| Fish by ocean |
Rename both |
October 16
|
| Category:Fish of the Great Lakes (US) |
Rename |
October 11
|
| Category:Fishes of Michigan |
Merge Category:Fishes of Michigan to Category:Fish of the United States |
October 15
|
| Category:Fletcher Pratt |
Delete |
October 24
|
| Category:Florida A&M University alumni |
Keep iot match main article |
October 13
|
| Category:Food utensils |
Rename Category:Food utensils to Category:Cooking utensils |
October 20
|
| Fooian members of Eastern Orthodoxy |
Rename all to "Eastern Orthodox Christians from XXX" form |
October 5
|
| Category:Ford |
Rename |
October 8
|
| Category:Foreign relations of Greenland |
MERGE. |
October 22
|
| Former and future Interstate Highway categories |
Split and rename and nominated. |
October 12
|
| Category:Fortune |
Rename |
October 9
|
| Category:Fossorial muroids |
Merge Category:Fossorial muroids to Category:Spalacidae |
October 16
|
| Category:Fosun Group |
RENAME. |
October 26
|
| Category:Franz Ferdinand |
rename. — |
October 21
|
| Category:Free Webhosts |
Rename to Category:Free web hosting services |
October 3
|
| Category:Frogs and toads by U.S. state |
Rename |
October 11
|
| Category:Funeral albums |
rename |
October 11
|
| Category:Furry comics |
merge |
October 12
|
| Category:Gangs in Nevada |
Keep |
October 2
|
| Garbage band subcategories |
rename all. — |
October 28
|
| Category:Garbage |
Rename |
October 21
|
| Category:Gastropods of Michigan |
Upmerge |
October 11
|
| Category:Georg Hegel |
Rename Category:Georg Hegel to Category:Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel iot follow main article |
October 8
|
| Category:Girls albums |
rename. — |
October 23
|
| Category:Goodie MOb albums |
RENAME |
October 17
|
| Category:Goofy: How to... |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2009 November 8. |
October 24
|
| Category:Government in Leeds |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2009 November 16#Category:Government in Leeds. |
October 26
|
| Category:Great Wall |
Delete Category:Great Wall. Rename Category:Great Wall vehicles to Category:Great Wall Motor vehicles |
October 13
|
| Category:Greek-American lawyers |
Double upmerge all |
October 19
|
| Category:Grunge groups |
rename |
October 29
|
| Category:Grunge music |
Keep. |
October 29
|
| Category:Hair physiology |
Delete |
October 14
|
| Category:Handel |
rename. — |
October 23
|
| Category:Hang Lung |
Rename Category:Hang Lung to Category:Hang Lung Group |
October 26
|
| Category:Hardline politicians |
delete |
October 10
|
| Category:Hawke's Bay |
Rename |
October 6
|
| Category:Heavy Metal |
rename. — |
October 21
|
| Category:Hemiptera of Michigan |
Delete |
October 7
|
| Category:Heroes' Days |
NO CONSENSUS. It's always a shame when most people don't like the existing category but can't agree on how to rename it. I suggest discussing it for however long you need to on the category's talk page (or other appropriate venue of your choice) until there is some agreement for a proposed rename, and then come back to CFD. |
October 24
|
| Category:Heroes' Days |
RELISTED at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2009 October 24. No one seems to support the present name, but there is not yet consensus on how to fix that. Good luck in the next round |
October 15
|
| Category:High Court of England and Wales |
Rename to Category:High Court of Justice cases |
October 7
|
| Category:Historic Indiana Businesses |
Merge into Category:Companies based in Indiana or Category:Defunct companies based in Indiana |
October 1
|
| Category:Historical figures of Omaha, Nebraska |
Merge |
October 15
|
| Category:Historical or defunct Philippine newspapers |
RENAME |
October 15
|
| Category:Historical outlines of US states |
RENAME per nom. |
October 21
|
| Category:Honorary fellows of the Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland |
Delete - list of Honorary fellows already present in main article |
October 14
|
| Category:Hopewell |
rename. — |
October 26
|
| Category:Horrible Histories |
Keep |
October 11
|
| Category:Horse jumps and obstacles |
speedily deleted as empty |
October 30
|
| Category:HORSE the band albums |
RENAME |
October 17
|
| Category:Hundreds of Yorkshire |
Rename all to Category:Ancient subdivisions of Foo |
October 31
|
| Category:Hunt class MCMVs |
rename |
October 9
|
| Category:HURT albums |
RENAME |
October 16
|
| Category:Hyderabad, Pakistan |
Speedy deleted under CSD G5 |
October 19
|
| Category:Hypercoasters |
withdrawn in favor of the preceding discussion |
October 15
|
| Category:I'm a Celebrity…Get Me out of Here! |
RENAME. |
October 22
|
| Category:Ian Matthews albums |
RENAME |
October 17
|
| Category:Ibuki class cruisers |
rename |
October 8
|
| Category:Ice hockey Farm Team/Affiliates |
originally nominated category was speedily deleted; delete Category:Pittsburgh Penguins Farm Team/Affiliates per previous discussion |
October 23
|
| Category:Icehouse |
RENAME. |
October 21
|
| Category:Icelandic historical figures |
Delete |
October 16
|
| Category:ICMLPO (Unity and Struggle) |
rename |
October 26
|
| Category:Images of military insignia |
DELETE |
October 17
|
| Category:Independent Baseball Players |
Delete |
October 24
|
| Category:Indian Female golfers |
NO CONSENSUS, particularly given the existence of Category:Australian female golfers. If divisions by nationality of Category:Female golfers are not desired, then I suggest nominating both for merging to be discussed together |
October 15
|
| Category:Integral economics |
delete |
October 8
|
| Category:Intercollegiate athletics in the United States, sub-cats |
Rename: |
October 27
|
| Category:Intercollegiate athletics in the United States, sub-cats |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2009 October 27#Category:Intercollegiate athletics in the United States, sub-cats |
October 18
|
| International footballers |
rename |
October 22
|
| Irish international rules players |
Merge all to Category:Irish international rules football players |
October 8
|
| Category:Iron Maiden |
RENAME to Category:Iron Maiden (heavy metal band). Those opposing renaming based only on the name of the article did not address the argument that more precision may be called for in category naming to avoid ambiguity, which is a commonly recognized exception to the general principle that a category should match the precise title of its parent article. |
October 21
|
| Category:Israeli Fascists |
Rename to Category:Fascists of British Palestine. Basically this was a no consensus on keeping or deleting. However I believe there was a consensus that the current name is not correct, hence the rename close. I did look to see if an upmerge was possible, but it seems that all of the people are contained in the subcategories |
October 1
|
| Category:Jamaican sex offenders |
no consensus |
October 29
|
| Category:JLA images |
KEEP. |
October 26
|
| Category:Johan Christian Claussen Dahl |
Rename Category:Johan Christian Claussen Dahl to Category:Johan Christian Dahl paintings |
October 9
|
| Category:Juice Games games |
MERGE. |
October 21
|
| Category:Juiced |
RENAME. |
October 21
|
| Junoon categories |
Rename all. |
October 31
|
| Category:K.D. Lang albums |
RENAME |
October 17
|
| Category:Kashmiri cuisine |
merge to Category:Kashmiri cuisine |
October 26
|
| Category:Kateri Tekakwitha |
delete. — |
October 22
|
| Category:Kazakhstan articles |
WITHDRAWN |
October 3
|
| Category:Keane |
rename. — |
October 21
|
| Category:Kellogg College |
Rename |
October 7
|
| Category:Kerry Group |
withdrawn by nominator |
October 26
|
| Category:Knots/Most useful |
delete. — |
October 28
|
| Kyle who? |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2009 November 4#Kyle who? |
October 21
|
| Kyrgyz people (nationality) |
Rename all per nom |
October 8
|
| Category:Languages with over 100 million speakers |
Delete |
October 5
|
| Category:Law firms of the Philippines |
keep, nomination withdrawn |
October 15
|
| Category:Law-related articles lacking sources |
Withdrawn, pending results of TfD for the template that populates it. – |
October 8
|
| Category:Legião Urbana |
delete |
October 22
|
| Lepidoptera by U.S. state |
Upmerge all |
October 12
|
| Category:Lepidoptera food plant lists |
Rename Category:Lepidoptera food plant lists to Category:Lists of Lepidoptera by food |
October 9
|
| Category:Lesotho politicians |
NOT RENAMED |
October 17
|
| Lewiston Maineiacs |
rename. — |
October 26
|
| Category:Lexington class cruisers |
Rename Category:Lexington class cruisers to Category:Lexington class battlecruisers |
October 1
|
| Category:Lifestyle centers in Quebec |
merge |
October 28
|
| Category:List of Bangladesh Navy Ship |
Delete |
October 2
|
| Category:List of former schools in England |
Rename to Category:Defunct schools in England |
October 2
|
| Category:List of rivers of the United States |
merge |
October 2
|
| Category:List of the star names by constellation |
Rename |
October 3
|
| Category:Living People |
Keep |
October 5
|
| Category:Locomotives of Foo |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2009 November 16#Category:Locomotives of Foo. |
October 24
|
| Category:Locomotives of the Pennsylvania Railroad |
RENAME per nom, to conform these categories to the standard otherwise observed within Category:Locomotives of the United States. In contrast to the renaming discussion below (which deals with locomotives by country, not by railway as here), none of the other subcategories have been listed for renaming, so the standard cannot be changed here for all of those categories. This close should not be considered a bar to such a rename proposal to change that standard, provided that all affected categories are named and tagged. |
October 24
|
| Locomotives of the United States categories |
Keep - Feel free to renominate for a reverse merge. I'll leave the tags in place |
October 23
|
| Category:Lotion albums |
rename. — |
October 27
|
| Category:Low-carbon transport |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2009 November 16#Category:Low-carbon transport. |
October 26
|
| Category:Madison Dearborn |
rename |
October 9
|
| Category:Malta's Leader of the Opposition |
Rename Category:Malta's Leader of the Opposition to Category:Leaders of the Opposition (Malta) |
October 10
|
| Category:Mammals of Michigan |
Merge into Category:Mammals of the United States |
October 7
|
| Category:Management of dyslexia |
Delete |
October 15
|
| Category:Manifestations of God in the Bahá'í Faith |
Delete |
October 28
|
| Category:Maps of the 1967 Arab–Israeli War |
Rename Category:Maps of the 1967 Arab–Israeli War to Category:Maps of the Six-Day War |
October 9
|
| Category:Masters of the Universe minicomics |
Delete |
October 4
|
| Category:Media organizations in Ukraine |
Merge Category:Media organizations in Ukraine to Category:Ukrainian media |
October 3
|
| Category:Megacoaster roller coasters |
NO CONSENSUS. |
October 24
|
| Category:Megacoaster roller coasters |
RELISTED at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2009 October 24 for further comment |
October 15
|
| Category:Members of the National Academy of Engineering |
merge (in direction set out below) |
October 29
|
| Category:Members of the Senate of France |
delete. — |
October 28
|
| Category:Metal groups |
merge. — |
October 28
|
| Category:Military ranks of the Royal Navy |
No consensus to rename |
October 4
|
| Category:Militias in Australasia |
rename. — |
October 29
|
| Mine warfare vessels by country |
delete as redundant |
October 5
|
| Mine warfare vessels by navy |
Rename |
October 9
|
| Minesweepers, Minelayers, and Minehunters by navy |
Rename/merge all |
October 20
|
| Category:Mizo Wikipedians |
Keep |
October 3
|
| Category:Mohsin Hamid |
Self-close; category was speedily deleted by uninvolved admin. |
October 22
|
| Monogeneric bat families |
Merge all per nom |
October 17
|
| Category:Mossberg |
rename |
October 9
|
| Category:Motor vehicle manufacturers of Arab World |
merge. — |
October 31
|
| Category:MTR Corporation Limited |
rename. — |
October 26
|
| Category:Municipal seats of Region Hovedstaden |
rename |
October 9
|
| Category:Municipalities of Region Hovedstaden |
rename |
October 9
|
| Category:Museums and galleries in Zagreb |
Rename |
October 16
|
| Category:Music released on Blu-ray |
delete. — |
October 29
|
| Category:Musical groups by numbers |
No Consensus, advise smaller, more tightly focused renominations for these categories |
October 26
|
| Category:Myotis |
Merge; no prejudice for which name is correct - current choice is based on currnet location of article |
October 20
|
| Category:Mysore Kingdom |
Rename |
October 13
|
| Category:Nashville Star |
Delete |
October 7
|
| National Express |
merge all. — |
October 28
|
| Category:National liberation movements |
NOT MERGED. |
October 27
|
| Category:National Register of Historic Places in Las Vegas |
Rename |
October 7
|
| Category:Native birds of Canadian Prairies Canada |
Rename to Category:Native birds of the Canadian Prairies. Feel free to renominate to discuss the "larger" questions brought up below. (Or perhaps start a WikiProject discussion somwhere?) |
October 21
|
| Category:Neighbourhoods in Russia |
delete (the category only contains two subcategories, and it's relatively clear that this is an inappropriate term for the country). |
October 28
|
| Category:New England Marching Bands |
delete |
October 10
|
| Category:New religious movement related media |
rename. — |
October 28
|
| New Testament words and phrases by language |
No Consensus |
October 7
|
| Category:New York soccer teams |
Rename Category:New York soccer teams to Category:New York men's soccer teams, repurpose Category:New York soccer teams to be parent of male and female categories |
October 17
|
| Category:New Zealanders of Cook Islands descent |
Rename |
October 26
|
| NHL "Fram" teams |
delete all |
October 12
|
| NHL Trophies |
rename as nominated |
October 22
|
| Category:Noir |
rename. — |
October 21
|
| Non-free music samples by artist categories |
rename |
October 23
|
| Category:Noreaga albums |
RENAME. |
October 21
|
| Category:Norman Foster |
RENAME. No consensus to delete; feel free to relist. |
October 21
|
| Category:Notre Dame High School alumni |
Rename |
October 7
|
| Category:Novels by Dodie Smith |
Keep. |
October 24
|
| Category:Odonata of Michigan |
Merge Category:Odonata of Michigan to Category:Insects of North America |
October 8
|
| Category:Often-populated Wikipedia category redirects |
Delete |
October 9
|
| Category:Olympiacos footballers |
merge. — |
October 27
|
| One-page mammals categories |
Upmerge all |
October 16
|
| Category:Organizations by activity |
Keep |
October 27
|
| Organizations |
RENAME ALL to "Organisations based in..." |
October 22
|
| Category:Orissa |
do not rename for now, pending future developments in official and popular usage |
October 28
|
| Category:Orthoptera of Michigan |
Delete |
October 8
|
| Category:Outlines of territorial evolution of US states |
RENAME per nom. |
October 21
|
| Category:Outlines of US States |
RENAME. |
October 21
|
| Category:Pakistani celebrities |
Merge |
October 18
|
| Category:Paleoconservatives |
Delete |
October 20
|
| Category:Panoz |
rename |
October 9
|
| Papilionidae subfamilies |
Delete all per nom |
October 11
|
| Category:Parliamentary constituencies in the West Midlands |
rename. — |
October 26
|
| Category:Pashtun Taliban leaders |
delete |
October 12
|
| Patrol vessels, Corvettes, and Frigates by navy |
Speedy Rename per nom |
October 24
|
| Category:Paulini albums |
rename |
October 9
|
| Category:Paulini songs |
rename |
October 9
|
| Category:People Associated with James Joyce |
Delete |
October 10
|
| Category:People from Beograd |
merge |
October 13
|
| Category:People from Dumfries |
NOT MERGED. |
October 27
|
| Category:People from Gillingham |
Rename |
October 7
|
| Category:People from Region Hovedstaden |
rename |
October 9
|
| Category:People from Region Midtjylland |
rename |
October 9
|
| Category:People from Region Nordjylland |
rename |
October 9
|
| Category:People from Region Sjælland |
rename |
October 9
|
| Category:People from Region Syddanmark |
rename |
October 9
|
| Category:People from Stamford |
RENAME |
October 17
|
| Category:People of Afro-Asian descent |
DELETE |
October 15
|
| Category:People of the First Anglo-Chinese War |
Rename |
October 1
|
| Category:People's Army of Vietnam Navy |
Rename Category:People's Army of Vietnam Navy to Category:Vietnamese People's Navy |
October 25
|
| Category:Philosophical articles |
merge |
October 23
|
| Pitbull categories |
Rename |
October 6
|
| Category:Places formerly in Oxfordshire |
Listify & Delete per precedent and practice |
October 3
|
| Category:Planetary systems |
No Consensus |
October 26
|
| Category:Planned aircraft carriers |
rename |
October 1
|
| Category:Planned airlines of New Zealand |
Merge Category:Planned airlines of New Zealand to Category:Planned airlines |
October 9
|
| Category:Plays by John Pickering |
Keep |
October 30
|
| Category:Police history |
Rename Category:Police history to Category:Law enforcement history |
October 13
|
| Category:Potential hoaxes |
delete |
October 23
|
| Category:Prehistoric Cingulates |
Rename - could have been speedy under criterion 2 |
October 26
|
| Category:Primus |
Rename |
October 21
|
| Prince categories |
Rename all. |
October 23
|
| Category:Prison wardens |
Rename |
October 2
|
| Category:Project-Class Project articles |
Deleted per CSD#G7 by MSGJ. Non-admin closure |
October 2
|
| Category:Protected by Symantec |
Delete |
October 20
|
| PSMS Medan |
delete/rename/merge etc. Everything to Category:PSMS Medan players, as Debresser said. |
October 27
|
| Category:Puccini |
rename. — |
October 23
|
| Puebla F.C. |
Rename all per nom |
October 1
|
| Category:Punjwood |
Rename Category:Punjwood to Category:Punjabi cinema |
October 8
|
| Category:Punk-pop singers |
Rename |
October 28
|
| Category:Quasi-public entities |
Rename. If it needs to be re-created in the future as a multi-national container category, that is fine. |
October 9
|
| Category:Racecar drivers by century |
KEEP, particularly given that its two subcategories were not listed for deletion or merger, and this category is merely the way in which those are grouped within Category:Sportspeople by century. The reasons given for deletion here seem to be actually aimed at the two subcategories, which should themselves be listed for deletion or merger if that is the intent (and this close should not be viewed as precluding such a CFD). |
October 28
|
| Category:Rachel Stamp singles |
rename |
October 12
|
| Category:Radio Caracas Televisión RCTV, C.A. |
Merge Category:Radio Caracas Televisión RCTV, C.A. to Category:Empresas 1BC subsidiaries |
October 24
|
| Category:Rancid |
Rename |
October 21
|
| Category:Redirects from Korean words/names |
Rename Category:Redirects from Korean words/names to Category:Redirects from Korean language terms |
October 23
|
| Redirects from X words/names |
Rename all per nom |
October 28
|
| Category:Reggae musicians \Kruxial Selecta |
Speedy deleted per C1 as an empty category for more than 4 days |
October 27
|
| Category:Region Hovedstaden |
rename |
October 9
|
| Category:Region Midtjylland |
rename |
October 9
|
| Category:Region Nordjylland |
rename |
October 9
|
| Category:Region Sjælland |
rename |
October 9
|
| Category:Region Syddanmark |
rename |
October 9
|
| Regions in Denmark |
rename all |
October 10
|
| Relisting of U2 categories |
Delete: |
October 13
|
| Category:Reptiles of Michigan |
Merge Category:Reptiles of Michigan to Category:Reptiles of the United States |
October 26
|
| Republic of Texas ships |
rename |
October 12
|
| Category:Restaurants in Rutland, Vermont |
SPEEDY DELETED, G7 |
October 24
|
| Category:Reviewed non-free images |
Rename |
October 22
|
| Category:Rhapsody albums |
rename |
October 9
|
| Category:Rhythm and blues music discographies |
Rename Category:Rhythm and blues music discographies to Category:Rhythm and blues discographies |
October 11
|
| Category:Rhône |
RENAME. I simply kept everything in the category that was there; if anything doesn't belong, as Johnbod notes below may be the case, feel free to change it |
October 15
|
| Category:Rides at The Great Escape & Splashwater Kingdom |
Rename |
October 6
|
| Category:Rio Tinto Subsidiaries |
rename |
October 26
|
| River categories: matching to article names |
Rename: |
October 15
|
| Category:Robin Hood episodes |
Rename: |
October 25
|
| Category:Roller coasters in Las Vegas |
rename |
October 8
|
| Category:Roller coasters in Los Angeles, California |
|
October 6
|
| Category:Roman Magister Equitums |
no consensus, except that it needs to be renamed to something. There is no consensus on what that should be. Can be renominated at any point |
October 30
|
| Rot-Weiss |
rename. — |
October 29
|
| Category:Royal Netherlands Navy minesweepers |
rename |
October 9
|
| Category:Royworld |
delete/rename as nominated |
October 22
|
| Rulers in Europe by century |
NOT MERGED. While there is a clear consensus against merging the rulers categories to the monarchs categories, the discussion did not evince a clear consensus against reverse merging, so feel free to propose that in a future CFD. |
October 20
|
| Category:Rusyns |
merge. — |
October 27
|
| Category:Salanoia |
Merge |
October 6
|
| Category:Savage songs |
RENAME. |
October 21
|
| Category:Scaffolding contractors of the united kingdom |
merge |
October 28
|
| School ships of the United States Navy |
Merge: |
October 25
|
| Category:Seattle Sounders (1994 – 2008) players |
Delete, category empty at close |
October 11
|
| Category:Seattle, Washington soccer clubs |
No Consensus |
October 11
|
| Category:Secessionist organizations |
Keep |
October 27
|
| Category:Security and Automation Businesses |
upmerge as nominated |
October 28
|
| Segunda División B seasons |
rename |
October 9
|
| Category:Serbian cembalists |
RENAME |
October 18
|
| Category:Serjeants-at-Arms in the United Kingdom |
Rename |
October 6
|
| Category:Settlements in Russia |
rename (not opposed) |
October 28
|
| Category:SGI |
Keep |
October 8
|
| Ship classes by navy, country |
delete |
October 21
|
| Ships of the Dutch Republic |
rename. — |
October 26
|
| Category:Shopping malls in Las Vegas |
Rename |
October 6
|
| Category:Sierra games |
Rename |
October 2
|
| Singles |
rename/merge as nominated |
October 22
|
| Category:Singular albums |
Merge Category:Singular albums to Category:Debut albums |
October 9
|
| Category:Sir Matt Busby Players of the Year |
Delete |
October 3
|
| Category:Skateboarder Wikipedians |
RENAME |
October 16
|
| Category:Ski areas and resorts in Georgia, Alabama, and Tennessee |
RENAME |
October 18
|
| Category:Skid Row |
rename. — |
October 21
|
| Category:Skip games |
Rename |
October 2
|
| Category:Slam Dunk |
rename. — |
October 21
|
| Category:Slipknot |
rename. — |
October 21
|
| Category:Slovenian newspapers |
Rename; anyone can also create Category:Slovene-language newspapers if desired. |
October 6
|
| Category:Small Business Innovation Research Program |
merge |
October 28
|
| Category:Snakes of the United States by state |
rename |
October 9
|
| Category:Special elections to the 111th Congress |
rename |
October 23
|
| Category:Specials albums |
Rename |
October 8
|
| Category:Spinal Tap |
rename. — |
October 28
|
| Category:Spindle |
RENAME. |
October 21
|
| Category:Sport teams that have filed for bankruptcy |
Delete |
October 5
|
| Category:Sports in Las Vegas, Nevada |
RENAME |
October 15
|
| Category:Stage actors from Northern Ireland |
Rename Category:Stage actors from Northern Ireland to Category:Northern Ireland stage actors |
October 9
|
| Category:Stars that has eight planets |
DELETE (already deleted prior to this closing) |
October 18
|
| Category:Stars that has four planets |
Merge: |
October 14
|
| Category:State Colleges and Universities in the Philippines |
Merge Category:State Colleges and Universities in the Philippines to Category:State universities and colleges in the Philippines |
October 15
|
| Strawberry Shortcake |
No consensus - Noting also that the nominator's premise (that there is "a grand total of three pages between them") is apparently no longer valid. And also that the article is at Strawberry Shortcake, so there doesn't seem to be a need for further disambiguation |
October 21
|
| Category:Styx |
rename. — |
October 21
|
| Subcategories of Category:Endemic birds of the Western United States |
Merge/Delete per nom |
October 13
|
| Category:Sublime |
rename. — |
October 21
|
| Category:Suicide bombing in the Chechen-Russian conflict |
Rename Category:Suicide bombing in the Chechen-Russian conflict to Category:Suicide bombing in the Chechen wars |
October 31
|
| Category:Suicide bombing in the Chechen-Russian conflict |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for_discussion/Log/2009 October 31#Category:Suicide bombing in the Chechen-Russian conflict. |
October 19
|
| Category:Super Star |
rename to Category:Super Star (Arabic television show) |
October 27
|
| Category:Super Star |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2009 October 27 |
October 18
|
| Category:Superintendents |
Rename Category:Superintendents to Category:American school superintendents |
October 23
|
| Category:Surrogate albums |
rename. Author created new category Category:Surrogate (band) albums and requested deletion of Category:Surrogate albums (non-admin closure). — |
October 26
|
| Category:Survivor |
rename. — |
October 21
|
| Category:Syd Barrett songs |
Keep |
October 20
|
| Tadpole(s) categories |
rename |
October 31
|
| Category:Taiwanese rock music groups |
WITHDRAWN |
October 4
|
| Category:Take 6 |
delete. — |
October 28
|
| Category:Taranaki |
Rename |
October 6
|
| Category:Tartarstan/Gepard class frigates |
rename. — |
October 29
|
| Category:Telugu scientists |
Administrative closure: deleted per request. |
October 1
|
| Category:Templates for deletion templates |
Withdrawn by nominator, see |
October 14
|
| Category:Terminator |
rename. — |
October 21
|
| Category:Tethered helium balloon |
Rename Category:Tethered helium balloon to Category:Images of balloons |
October 17
|
| Category:Texas political scandals |
rename. — |
October 26
|
| Category:The Banana Wars ships |
Rename Category:The Banana Wars ships to Category:Banana Wars ships |
October 25
|
| Category:The Beatles songs in surround |
delete |
October 6
|
| Category:The Charlatans |
RENAME. |
October 21
|
| Category:The Commodores albums |
rename |
October 22
|
| Category:The Deer and the Cauldron |
delete |
October 24
|
| Category:The Fugees albums |
rename |
October 11
|
| Category:The Fugees songs |
rename |
October 11
|
| Category:The Haunted |
RENAME. No consensus as to deletion; relist if you choose. |
October 21
|
| Category:The Mole |
rename. — |
October 21
|
| Category:The Real World (MTV) |
Keep |
October 14
|
| Category:The Shells albums |
Withdrawn by nominator. |
October 3
|
| Category:Theatres in the United States |
No Consensus. I'll add that given the history of nominations, it is likely that this will continue to come up |
October 25
|
| Category:TheAudition albums |
rename |
October 12
|
| Category:Therion |
rename. — |
October 21
|
| Category:Third Lanark AC |
RENAME |
October 16
|
| Category:Tokio albums |
rename |
October 31
|
| Category:Tollywood |
Merge |
October 4
|
| Category:Too $hort albums |
Rename Category:Too $hort albums to Category:Too Short albums |
October 24
|
| Category:Tool |
rename. — |
October 21
|
| Category:Towns and villages in Chiniot District |
rename |
October 21
|
| Category:Towns in Hawaii |
rename |
October 27
|
| Category:Towns in Iowa |
delete. — |
October 27
|
| Category:Toy museums in New York |
SPEEDY DELETED at request of only author |
October 7
|
| Category:Transportation in Volusia County |
RENAME |
October 15
|
| Category:Triana |
rename. — |
October 21
|
| Category:Triffids albums |
rename |
October 11
|
| Category:Triffids songs |
rename |
October 11
|
| Category:Trivandrum |
rename |
October 26
|
| Category:Turkish people of Bosnian descent |
Rename Category:Turkish people of Bosnian descent to Category:Turkish people of Bosnia and Herzegovina descent |
October 14
|
| Turks to Turkish people |
Rename all per nom |
October 14
|
| U.S. case law |
Rename. Per |
October 27
|
| Category:Unattached football (soccer) players |
speedy delete G4; re-creation of previously discussed and deleted material. |
October 26
|
| Category:Underworld |
RENAME. No consensus to delete; feel free to relist. |
October 21
|
| Category:United Arab Emirates racecar drivers |
Rename |
October 2
|
| Category:United States Congresses - general |
delete |
October 19
|
| Category:United States Congresses - state detail |
delete |
October 19
|
| Category:United States Congresses - summary |
delete |
October 19
|
| Category:United States Naval Submarine Bases |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2009 November 10#Category:United States Naval Submarine Bases. |
October 29
|
| Category:United States naval vessels named after foreign nationals |
rename |
October 31
|
| Category:United States Navy patrol craft sweepers |
delete |
October 22
|
| Category:United States Presidents from Michigan |
Delete |
October 15
|
| Category:United States rolling stock |
SUPERSEDED by the comprehensive discussion at Wikipedia:Categories\ for discussion/Log/2009 November 11#Subcategories of Category:Rolling stock by country. |
October 30
|
| Category:United Uniting churches |
Rename |
October 15
|
| Category:University of California, Berkeley alumni |
Keep. |
October 22
|
| Category:University of Pittsburgh needing cleanup |
delete; category has remained empty |
October 8
|
| Category:Uriah Heep |
rename. — |
October 21
|
| Category:USAF Organizations in Korea |
no consensus. When I relisted this I was hoping for comments from editors who hadn't previously commented, but no matter. I'm going to do something that no one mentioned and rename the category to Category:United States Air Force organizations in Korea. I realise there is also "no consensus" for these changes, but one (the capitalization) is speediable and I think the other (expanding the abbreviation) would be uncontroversial (though I'm sure it's possible someone will prove me wrong) |
October 19
|
| USCG, NOAA, and predecessors' ships |
Rename |
October 25
|
| Category:User bat-smg-0 |
Delete |
October 12
|
| Category:User prog |
Speedy delete as substantially similar recreation (WP:CSD#G4) of Category:Wikipedian programmers, which was renamed to Category:Wikipedians by programming language (and depopulated of individual users, so a merge here would be innapropriate} per this discussion. If this conclusion of what to do with the category no longer represents consensus, DRV would be the appropriate venue |
October 16
|
| Category:Users who are fans of The Prodigy |
delete |
October 12
|
| Category:Verdi |
rename. — |
October 23
|
| Category:Verizon |
Rename |
October 6
|
| Category:Vernacular geography |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2009 November 4#Category:Vernacular geography. |
October 21
|
| Category:Vespertilionidae |
MERGE |
October 17
|
| Category:Vietnam War Coast Guard ships of the United States |
merge |
October 7
|
| Category:Vietnam War ships of the Republic of Vietnam |
Rename Category:Vietnam War ships of the Republic of Vietnam to Category:Vietnam War ships of South Vietnam |
October 7
|
| Category:Villages in Nevada |
delete. — |
October 27
|
| Category:Visitor attractions in Trivandrum |
Rename |
October 19
|
| Category:VJ softwares |
MERGE |
October 16
|
| Vogue categories |
rename/merge as nominated |
October 9
|
| Category:Wang Chung |
RENAME |
October 21
|
| Category:War members |
Rename |
October 25
|
| Category:Wars involving Asanteman |
Rename |
October 13
|
| Category:Washington State Cougars basketball venues |
Delete |
October 29
|
| Category:Washington State Cougars basketball veues |
SPEEDY DELETED; misspelled name, already emptied and replaced by Category:Washington State Cougars basketball venues. |
October 29
|
| Category:Welsh self-government |
rename |
October 12
|
| Category:West Midlands |
rename. — |
October 26
|
| Category:Wikipedia articles needing moustaches |
Delete. |
October 31
|
| Category:Wikipedia categories that should contain only sub-categories |
Merge per nom. While there has been some discussion about a better name for the target, that suggestion seems to hide the need to combine these two like categories from the consensus in the discussion. So once merged, Category:Parent categories may need to be nominated so that a possible better name can be discussed |
October 30
|
| Category:Wikipedia disabled volunteers |
Rename Category:Wikipedia disabled volunteers to Category:Wikipedians who are disabled |
October 12
|
| Category:Wikipedia media requiring renaming |
rename, using "file" in place of "media". |
October 9
|
| Category:Wikipedians committed to ascetic editing |
Speedy deleted by original author per G7 |
October 12
|
| Category:Wikipedians of Breton ancestry |
KEEP. |
October 20
|
| Category:Wikipedians supporting Taiwan Independence |
Delete |
October 5
|
| Category:Wikipedians who don't live with their parents |
Delete. |
October 31
|
| Category:Wikipedians who edit whilst drunk |
Delete |
October 5
|
| Category:Wikipedians who say CfD is broken |
Delete |
October 12
|
| Category:Wikipedians who use Custom Signatures |
delete |
October 5
|
| Category:WikiProject Chicago content categories |
No consensus. Though it does seem that some good discussions regarding this have occurred below. I would suggest that the Chicago WikiProject look around at the WikiProject categories' structure for other WikiProjects to see if it's possible to bring their categorisation scheme in line with others (for ease of navigation, if nothing else.) Otherwise, there's a decent possibility that we'll be seeing this back at CfD in a month or so |
October 22
|
| Category:Winger |
rename. — |
October 21
|
| Category:Wings |
RENAME. |
October 21
|
| Category:World Music Awards winners |
Keep |
October 25
|
| Category:World War II British minesweepers |
rename |
October 9
|
| World War II frigates and destroyer escorts of the United States |
rename/merge |
October 5
|
| Category:Zoos in Palestine |
Merge Category:Zoos in Palestine to Category:Zoos in the Palestinian territories |
October 12
|
