| Category |
Decision |
Discussion_log
|
| Category:Alumni Munson Institute of American Maritime Studies |
speedied |
January 20
|
| Category:Jeff Dunham |
delete |
January 21
|
| Category:"History of" templates |
no consensus |
January 13
|
| Category:1958 NCAA Division I-A football season |
rename |
January 27
|
| Category:1996 campaign finance scandal |
delete |
January 28
|
| Category:1996 NFL Draft WRs |
delete |
January 17
|
| Category:4A window |
SPEEDY DELETED, misplaced article and spam to boot |
January 18
|
| Category:A-sourced |
delete |
January 9
|
| Category:Academy Awards |
delete all |
January 12
|
| Acronym categories |
upmerge N-letter and recursive into category:Acronyms, no consensus on computing and military. (I could have closed this as no consensus, but there seemed universal consensus to do something, so this is the less damaging course .) |
January 26
|
| Category:Active aircraft carriers of the People's Republic of China |
delete |
January 11
|
| Actors and cast |
rename to Foo cast |
January 11
|
| Category:Actors by series |
gaaah. 116 kb of debate. Well, someone has to make a decision here, and although I suppose anything I say here will be speedily dragged to deletion review, something has to be said. First, I see a strong consensus at least for restricting the categories to the principal cast. I believe that for nearly every show this can be practically decided by looking at who appear in the opening credits. Guest roles do not count, even if they appear more than once. Second, an important argument for the "keep" side is that they find the information useful and do not want it to be lost. However, I wish to reiterate that a list can use sortable tables to actually give more information than a category. For instance, a table could be sortable by name, character name, amount of episodes, date of first appearance, and faction within the series. The key is that we should not delete the category until and unless there is a good list as an alternative. A conversion of information is not a loss of information |
January 25
|
| Actors to Cast Members |
rename all |
January 15
|
| Category:Actors who have played the President of the United States |
delete (it's already listified) |
January 4
|
| Category:Advertising mascot songs |
delete |
January 20
|
| Category:AfD debates (Indiscernable or unclassifiable topic) |
rename |
January 29
|
| Category:Affiliates of Rover's Morning Glory |
delete |
January 10
|
| Category:Afghanistani women |
delete |
January 1
|
| Category:Africa by city |
Speedy Deleted |
January 27
|
| Category:African American criminals |
delete |
January 31
|
| Category:African American Skateboarders |
merge |
January 5
|
| Category:African bishops |
delete |
January 2
|
| Category:African Female rappers |
delete |
January 31
|
| Category:African Lutherans |
delete |
January 26
|
| Category:Afterlife |
merge |
January 27
|
| Category:Agoraphobic celebrities |
delete |
January 15
|
| Category:Air National Guard officers |
rename |
January 24
|
| Category:Air National Guard Units |
delete |
January 23
|
| Category:Airlines of the Middle East |
delete |
January 9
|
| Category:Album stubs/Child list |
moved |
January 30
|
| Category:Albums from Rap-A-Lot Records |
rename |
January 28
|
| Category:All uncategorised pages |
delete |
January 4
|
| Category:Alleged illegal copies of major motor models |
delete |
January 8
|
| Category:Alleged police brutality NYPD |
no consensus to merge; rename to Category:Alleged brutality by the New York City Police Department |
January 6
|
| Category:Alleged puppet states |
delete |
January 27
|
| Category:Allegedly racist restaurant chains |
delete |
January 15
|
| Category:Alpha Phi Omega honorary brothers |
delete |
January 26
|
| Category:Alumni of Eastern New Mexico University |
rename |
January 11
|
| Category:American African Methodist Episcopal bishops |
merge |
January 26
|
| Category:American anti-fascist propaganda films |
delete |
January 5
|
| Category:American conservatives |
delete first, merge the second |
January 21
|
| Category:American films by medium and subcats |
delete |
January 3
|
| American films by year and by decade |
delete |
January 3
|
| Category:American Free Methodist bishops |
'Upmerge to 2 parent cats per nom |
January 18
|
| Category:American liberals |
delete |
January 19
|
| Category:American Methodist writers |
upmerge |
January 5
|
| Category:American missionaries in Angola |
merge |
January 3
|
| Category:American People of the Spanish-American War |
no consensus to merge; rename |
January 2
|
| American physicans by ethnicity |
merge |
January 1
|
| Category:American religious executives |
delete |
January 1
|
| Category:American religious writers |
no consensus |
January 5
|
| Category:American writers by audience |
delete |
January 6
|
| Category:Amusement parks accidents |
speedily deleted per nom |
January 10
|
| Category:Amusement parks in Oceania |
delete |
January 20
|
| Category:Angelina songs |
category already deleted |
January 10
|
| Category:Animal Cell Culture |
SPEEDY DELETED per C1 |
January 5
|
| Category:Animal rights activists |
no consensus to recreate |
January 5
|
| Category:Animation villains |
delete |
January 22
|
| Category:Annoying people who don't seem to do anything except turn up on TV 'lists' programmes spouting off about shite |
SPEEDY DELETED, obvious nonsense |
January 5
|
| Category:Annual activist events |
rename both Category:Annual activist events and Category:Awareness Days to Category:Awareness days |
January 12
|
| Category:Anti-Masonry |
delete |
January 25
|
| Category:ApMasterSite |
already deleted |
January 18
|
| Apple category |
rename to match article i.e. "Apple Inc." |
January 17
|
| Category:Arab fashion designers |
merge |
January 1
|
| Category:ArbCom bumper stickers |
delete |
January 9
|
| Category:Arena Rock Recording Co. discography |
rename |
January 4
|
| Category:Argentine racing drivers |
merge |
January 1
|
| Category:Army groups by nationality |
delete |
January 10
|
| Category:Arrested NFL football players |
delete |
January 23
|
| Category:Arthur episodes |
merge |
January 14
|
| Category:Arthur Loves Plastic |
rename |
January 20
|
| Category:Articles lacking sources from January 09/07 |
Speedy deleted per CSD G6, maintenance |
January 10
|
| Category:Articles lacking sources from January |
Speedy deleted per CSD G6, maintenance |
January 10
|
| Category:Articles with example Euphoria code and others |
delete |
January 5
|
| Category:Articles with example J code and others |
delete |
January 5
|
| Category:Articles with example JavaScript code |
delete |
January 5
|
| Category:Artists on Behind the Music |
delete |
January 15
|
| Category:Artists who played in family values tour |
delete |
January 6
|
| Category:Artists/Bands With Long Song Titles |
delete |
January 1
|
| Category:Assassinated Northern Irish people |
no consensus |
January 29
|
| Category:Associate's degree holders |
delete |
January 13
|
| Astram Line templates |
speedy delete, creator blanking (were blanked on December 30) and category emptiness are both speedy deletion criteria |
January 10
|
| Category:Astronomical images |
rename |
January 25
|
| Category:Atheist scientists |
delete |
January 11
|
| Category:Athletes in music videos |
delete |
January 15
|
| Category:Atlantic Coast Conference Atlantic Division |
merge |
January 24
|
| Category:Atmabodham |
already SPEEDY DELETED |
January 21
|
| Category:Atmabodhodaya Sangham |
SPEEDY DELETED, misplaced article |
January 21
|
| Category:Austin Powers actors |
Delete |
January 19
|
| Australian currency categories |
merge |
January 15
|
| Category:Australian Gaming conventions |
rename |
January 31
|
| Category:Australian immigration |
rename |
January 22
|
| Category:Australian rock drummers |
no consensus |
January 10
|
| Category:Austrian people by city |
rename |
January 15
|
| Category:Automotive related biographies |
rename |
January 24
|
| Aviation accidents and incidents by country |
rename all as "Xish aviation accidents and incidents" |
January 13
|
| Category:Aviation accidents and incidents in Czechosolvakia |
already been deleted |
January 10
|
| Category:Avifauna of Central America |
rename |
January 27
|
| Category:Awards by country |
no consensus to rename/delete, so defaulting to all categories at "Xish awards", which means moving the five or so categories that are already at "awards of X". — |
January 7
|
| Category:Baby Digimon |
rename |
January 8
|
| Category:Babylon Bombs |
delete |
January 21
|
| Category:Bacteria organized by reaction to gram stain |
delete |
January 10
|
| Category:Banburyshire Schools |
merge |
January 18
|
| Category:Bands named after songs |
delete. — |
January 16
|
| Category:Banjo manufacturers |
rename |
January 23
|
| Category:Banned documentaries |
delete |
January 30
|
| Category:Banned films |
Speedy Delete |
January 22
|
| Category:Banned writers |
delete and listify |
January 7
|
| Category:Baptist ministers |
nomination withdrawn |
January 12
|
| Category:Barbadian telecommunications companies |
rename |
January 18
|
| Category:Batman Beyond villains |
Merge |
January 12
|
| Category:BBC regions |
Delete and Merge |
January 24
|
| Category:Best Original Song Golden Globe winners |
merge to Category:Best Original Song Golden Globe winners |
January 10
|
| Category:Bewitched actors |
Delete |
January 19
|
| Category:Bird Health |
already deleted |
January 13
|
| Birds by country |
rename all of them |
January 27
|
| Category:Blade Runner cast and crew |
delete |
January 30
|
| Category:Bones |
rename |
January 16
|
| Category:Books by Conn Iggulden |
rename |
January 16
|
| Category:Books by John Brunner |
keep, and create novels category and put articles about his novels in it |
January 16
|
| Category:Boredoms related groups |
delete, purpose not clear from the name leading to misunderstandings, very unusual categorization for bands, and OC guideline trumps ILIKEIT |
January 20
|
| Category:Boys & Girls Club alumni |
delete |
January 28
|
| Category:Boys Boarding Schools, Virginia |
merge |
January 1
|
| Brady Bunch |
rename using "cast" |
January 4
|
| Category:Braniff Flights |
rename |
January 2
|
| Category:Brewpubs |
delete |
January 10
|
| Category:British air disasters |
rename |
January 3
|
| Category:British Convert Muslim Terrorists |
delete. Loaded phrasing is not good for categories, and it's near-empty anyway |
January 28
|
| British royal consorts |
rename all |
January 9
|
| Category:Broadcast media in Oklahoma City |
merge/delete |
January 30
|
| Category:Broadway actors |
delete |
January 11
|
| Category:Broadway Actors/Actresses |
no consensus to delete; rename |
January 4
|
| Category:Broadway musicals stars |
listify and delete |
January 4
|
| Category:Brooklyn Rappers |
merge |
January 20
|
| Category:Building fire disasters in the United States |
rename |
January 27
|
| Category:Buildings and structures in Worthing |
merge |
January 6
|
| Category:Burials at Forest Lawn Memorial Park Cemetery |
rename |
January 31
|
| Category:Burials at Forest Lawn Memorial Park |
rename |
January 31
|
| Category:Byzantine-Ottoman wars |
keep |
January 5
|
| Category:C.D. Chivas USA |
speedy rename |
January 18
|
| Category:Cadet colleges in Bangladesh |
merge |
January 26
|
| Category:Caldecott Medalists More Than Once |
merge to Category:Caldecott Medal winners |
January 2
|
| Category:Canadian Americans |
no consensus |
January 19
|
| Category:Canadian Halls of Fame |
rename |
January 3
|
| Category:Canadian rock groups |
rename |
January 30
|
| Category:Canadian writers in English |
delete |
January 31
|
| Category:Canadian_Forces |
keep/withdrawn |
January 18
|
| Category:Cancelled TV series |
delete |
January 2
|
| Category:Cantemireşti |
rename all |
January 23
|
| Category:Cape Verde by city |
merge per nom |
January 17
|
| Category:Captain Jack Sparrow |
delete |
January 1
|
| Category:Caribbean lawyers |
no consensus |
January 27
|
| Category:Carmen Rasmusen singles |
rename |
January 21
|
| Category:Categories depicting future products |
delete |
January 14
|
| Category:Categories for deletion |
Keep and create parent Category:Categories for discussion |
January 4
|
| Category:Categories:Wikiproject Oregon participants |
delete. For future reference you can just put {{db-author}} on mistakenly created pages like this |
January 16
|
| Category:Category name |
delete |
January 5
|
| Cateogry:Kaboohoo Network |
speedy delete |
January 2
|
| Category:Catholic families |
delete |
January 10
|
| Category:Catholic theologians |
merge/redirect |
January 1
|
| Category:Cavity wall |
delete (obvious technical misunderstanding). `' |
January 11
|
| Category:Celebrities in music videos |
delete |
January 27
|
| Category:Celebrities who personally authored their official sites |
delete. — |
January 2
|
| Category:Celebrity Fit Club |
delete |
January 10
|
| Category:Cell culture mediums |
rename |
January 4
|
| Category:Central-Asian people |
rename |
January 23
|
| Category:Champions of Pop Music |
delete |
January 21
|
| Category:Chancellors of Washington University in St. Louis |
rename per Otto |
January 30
|
| Category:Characters from McLeod's Daughters |
rename |
January 18
|
| Category:Characters in Patrick Henry's Life |
delete |
January 30
|
| Category:Characters of Fengshen Yanyi |
rename |
January 24
|
| Category:Characters who had their etnicities changed in movie adaptation |
delete |
January 17
|
| Category:Cheng Qiang |
delete |
January 9
|
| Category:Chicago films |
split & rename |
January 6
|
| Category:Child villains |
delete |
January 22
|
| Category:Christian fiction |
lack of consensus; this issue may need clarifying |
January 27
|
| Category:Christian individuals in the United Kingdom |
speedy delete as creator error |
January 30
|
| Category:Christian missionaries in the Middle East |
merge |
January 26
|
| Category:Christmas customs by country |
speedy delete by creator request. × |
January 10
|
| Category:Churches established in 1939 |
merge |
January 9
|
| Category:Churches in Alberta |
keep |
January 21
|
| Category:Cities and towns in Taymyr Autonomous Okrug |
merge |
January 1
|
| Category:Cities named for Kirov |
delete |
January 10
|
| Category:Cities with trolleybus system |
delete |
January 3
|
| Category:Clergy of predominantly African American Christian denominations |
no consensus |
January 18
|
| Category:Climate by state |
speedy delete |
January 10
|
| Category:Close United States presidential elections |
delete |
January 11
|
| CNBC categories |
merge |
January 21
|
| Category:Code generation |
relisting |
January 12
|
| Category:Comic strips errata |
delete |
January 23
|
| Category:Comics protagonists |
delete |
January 26
|
| Category:Commonwealth regiments and corps |
delete |
January 23
|
| Category:Companies based in Eugene, Oregon |
merge |
January 1
|
| Category:Companies based in India |
merge |
January 21
|
| Companies by metropolitan area |
rename |
January 25
|
| Category:Companies listed on the JASDAQ Securities Exchange |
keep |
January 1
|
| Category:Companies of Macao |
speedy deleted |
January 10
|
| Category:Computer and video game censorship and ratings |
rename |
January 20
|
| Category:Computer and video game industry and press |
merge |
January 17
|
| Category:Computer and video game sequels |
keep |
January 3
|
| Category:Computer and video game villains |
delete |
January 23
|
| Category:Computer and video games based on licensed properties |
delete |
January 5
|
| Category:Computer and video games developed in Japan |
no consensus |
January 15
|
| Category:Computer Security |
deleted as empty on 18:46, 23 January 2007 (UTC) |
January 12
|
| Category:Computerization |
delete |
January 31
|
| Category:Conflicts |
do not merge |
January 31
|
| Category:Controversies |
Delete |
January 19
|
| Category:CopyrightByWikimedia |
delete |
January 21
|
| Category:Costin |
delete |
January 10
|
| Category:Country's largest city by population |
delete |
January 22
|
| Category:Crime and law enforcement |
delete |
January 25
|
| Category:Crime Syndicate members |
delete (list already exists) |
January 30
|
| Crufting it up |
rename to Category:Charmed cast etc |
January 12
|
| Category:Cult leaders |
delete |
January 26
|
| Category:Cyber criminals |
rename |
January 4
|
| Category:Cycle |
delete |
January 12
|
| Category:Cylon characters |
rename |
January 6
|
| Dallas |
keep |
January 30
|
| Category:Danish Superliga 2006-07 |
delete |
January 15
|
| Category:Darkwing Duck villains |
upmerge |
January 22
|
| Category:Dave Kelly |
delete |
January 17
|
| Category:Dave Stone novels |
rename |
January 16
|
| Category:Days of our Lives actors |
rename, insufficient consensus for deletion |
January 21
|
| Category:Days of our Lives villains |
merge |
January 8
|
| Category:Deaths due to illness |
rename to Category:Deaths by type of illness |
January 9
|
| Category:Debaters |
delete |
January 28
|
| Category:Deep Democracy |
delete |
January 7
|
| Category:Deep Throat people |
delete |
January 28
|
| Departments of France |
rename |
January 16
|
| Category:Diabetics by nationality |
no consensus |
January 5
|
| Category:Diabetics |
do not rename. Since several people suggested deletion, I'll renominate them for that under today's listing |
January 27
|
| Category:Digimon by type |
delete, including all subcats |
January 9
|
| Category:Disaster movies |
no consensus |
January 13
|
| Category:Disaster movies |
withdrawn |
January 21
|
| Category:Disney Nonsense Word Songs |
upmerge |
January 1
|
| Category:Disney villains |
merge per consistency and precedent of several earlier instances of consensus on this issue |
January 27
|
| Category:Disney |
keep |
January 2
|
| Category:Documentaries about McDonald's |
rename to Documentary films about business |
January 26
|
| Category:Dominican singers |
rename |
January 26
|
| Category:Drafted Frölunda HC players |
merge |
January 21
|
| Category:Dreamgirls actors |
delete |
January 24
|
| Category:DrugsInFearAndLoathing |
delete |
January 24
|
| Category:Dynamo |
delete |
January 27
|
| Category:Early American movie moguls |
merge for now, although another CfD might be needed |
January 11
|
| Category:Eastern Air Lines Flights |
rename |
January 3
|
| Category:Editors of Christian works |
no consensus to upmerge; rename |
January 4
|
| Category:Education in Izmir |
merge, to match article |
January 25
|
| Category:Education in Kuala Lumpur |
keep |
January 1
|
| Category:Electric Utilities in India |
rename |
January 28
|
| Category:Electricity companies of Norway |
merge |
January 28
|
| Category:Electricity companies of the United Kingdom |
rename because it really is the sole exception in the parent cat. I'm sure that most countries have slightly different terms |
January 28
|
| Category:Emory and Henry College |
nomination withdrawn by proposer |
January 4
|
| Category:English laws |
keep separate. Given the comments about clearer naming, I recommend a new listing to find an alternatvie name |
January 10
|
| Category:English laws |
no consensus |
January 17
|
| Category:English people by county |
rename all to People from Foo |
January 17
|
| Category:English people by county |
rename, or it would be if I hadn't done it already :-) |
January 25
|
| Category:English-Spaniards |
delete |
January 7
|
| Category:Environmental organizations based in Vermont |
merge |
January 19
|
| Category:Episodes of Rugrats |
rename |
January 13
|
| Category:Eponymous laws |
delete |
January 18
|
| Category:Erotic magazines |
merge |
January 8
|
| ESA |
rename |
January 24
|
| Category:Ethiopian visual arts |
delete |
January 10
|
| Category:Ethiopian writers by audience |
upmerge |
January 6
|
| Ethnic groups in Romania |
rename |
January 2
|
| Category:European diplomats |
delete |
January 24
|
| Category:Evangelical Converts to Christianity |
delete |
January 2
|
| Category:Events in Salt Lake City, Utah |
merge |
January 29
|
| Category:Executable files |
delete |
January 9
|
| Category:Expeditionary forces |
rename |
January 16
|
| Category:External Link |
speedily deleted per below |
January 8
|
| Category:Extras |
rename, without prejudice towards a new nomination for deletion; it is unclear how many of the "rename" commenters object to deletion |
January 25
|
| Category:Famous Fenerbahçe S.K. fans |
delete |
January 17
|
| Category:Fan Fiction |
merge |
January 3
|
| Category:Far-left Youth Organisations |
merge |
January 31
|
| Category:Faster-than-light communication |
keep |
January 9
|
| Fauna by state subcategories |
merge |
January 31
|
| Category:Fauna of Gujarat |
delete |
January 20
|
| Category:Fauna of Madhya Pradesh |
delete |
January 26
|
| Fauna of the United States by state |
merge the lot of them |
January 31
|
| Category:Female Furies |
delete |
January 29
|
| Category:Female models |
keep |
January 10
|
| Category:Female Sikh warriors |
no consensus |
January 1
|
| Category:Fenerbahçe sporters |
delete |
January 28
|
| Category:Fenerbahce sporters |
delete |
January 28
|
| Category:Fictional American television characters |
delete |
January 23
|
| Category:Fictional antagonists |
delete |
January 4
|
| Category:Fictional Australian television characters |
delete |
January 23
|
| Category:Fictional bald characters |
deleted and salted |
January 18
|
| Category:Fictional bisexuals |
no consensus to delete/merge; no consensus to rename |
January 1
|
| Category:Fictional bullies |
delete |
January 4
|
| Category:Fictional characters by belief and Category:Lists of fictional characters by belief |
delete |
January 4
|
| Category:Fictional characters portrayed by the opposite sex |
Delete |
January 19
|
| Category:Fictional characters who have had abortions |
listify, per creator's comments at the bottom, because the context is needed for this to be meaningful |
January 28
|
| Category:Fictional characters with eating disorders |
Delete |
January 19
|
| Category:Fictional characters with eating disorders |
yes, it's very ironic to give salt to people with eating disorders |
January 31
|
| Category:Fictional characters with the power to generate force fields |
delete |
January 23
|
| Category:Fictional characters with the power to manipulate pure energy |
speedy delete |
January 6
|
| Category:Fictional characters with the power to manipulate radiation |
delete |
January 24
|
| Fictional characters with the power to ressurect themselves |
speedily deleted |
January 24
|
| Category:Fictional comic-relief characters |
delete |
January 23
|
| Category:Fictional extraterrestrials |
keep and sort |
January 16
|
| Category:Fictional frogs |
merge |
January 2
|
| Category:Fictional humanoid extraterrestrial species |
upmerge |
January 16
|
| Fictional inhabitants of the British Isles |
don't merge. — |
January 11
|
| Category:Fictional Irish |
merge |
January 28
|
| Category:Fictional Italian-American mobsters |
delete |
January 9
|
| Category:Fictional llamas |
delete |
January 15
|
| Category:Fictional masochists |
delete |
January 6
|
| Category:Fictional mutates |
no consensus |
January 31
|
| Category:Fictional narcissists |
delete |
January 18
|
| Category:Fictional Northern Irish people |
delete |
January 28
|
| Category:Fictional priests |
merge |
January 27
|
| Category:Fictional protestors |
delete |
January 4
|
| Category:Fictional Scots |
rename |
January 27
|
| Category:Fictional skateboarders |
delete |
January 1
|
| Category:Fictional students |
no consensus |
January 23
|
| Category:Fictional swordfighters |
delete |
January 1
|
| Category:Fictional traitors |
rename to Category:Fictional characters who have committed treason |
January 28
|
| Category:Fictional universes |
rename to "settings" seems to be the best solution |
January 29
|
| Category:Fictional villains |
delete |
January 13
|
| Category:Filipino writers in English |
nomination withdrawn by proposer. (And there wasn't a consensus to merge anyway.) |
January 5
|
| Category:Film villains |
merge to "film characters" as a reasonable compromise, and per ample precedent cited of earlier consensus |
January 27
|
| Category:Films which explore libertarian themes |
delete |
January 6
|
| Category:Films with a Best Cinematographer Academy Award nomination |
delete |
January 31
|
| Category:Flickr-style names |
delete pr nominatr |
January 25
|
| Category:Fooian words |
rename |
January 25
|
| Category:Football clubs in Derry |
keep |
January 20
|
| Category:Football Player |
delete both |
January 30
|
| Category:Former Christian Scientists |
nomination withdrawn by proposer |
January 2
|
| Category:Former Christians |
delete |
January 1
|
| Category:Former French départements |
rename |
January 2
|
| Category:Former Hindus |
delete |
January 1
|
| Category:Former Jehovah's Witnesses |
no consensus |
January 1
|
| Category:Former Muslims |
no consensus |
January 1
|
| Category:Former Scientologists |
keep |
January 1
|
| Category:Former Unitarians |
delete |
January 9
|
| Category:Former watermills on the River Thames |
delete |
January 7
|
| Category:Foundations of Norway |
rename |
January 3
|
| Category:Frayser Boy albums |
keep |
January 1
|
| Category:Free computer and video games software |
rename |
January 6
|
| Category:French phrases |
merge to Category:French words and phrases |
January 4
|
| Category:French words |
merge to Category:French words and phrases |
January 4
|
| Category:Fry's Remixies |
delete |
January 16
|
| Category:Futurama episodes: Season 1 |
merge |
January 8
|
| Category:Games that take place in the future |
delete |
January 24
|
| Category:Games that take place in the the future |
speedy delete. Note, the other cat's cfd is ongoing. × |
January 25
|
| Category:Gaming companies |
rename |
January 11
|
| Category:Gay anthems |
delete |
January 6
|
| Category:Gay mathematicians |
delete |
January 11
|
| Category:General Classifications of Bones |
merge, no new name suggested |
January 24
|
| Category:Genes associated with congenital genetic disorders |
rename |
January 3
|
| Category:Genesee Wesleyan Seminary alumni |
no consensus |
January 9
|
| Genesis |
rename all |
January 7
|
| Category:Genocide deniers |
delete |
January 18
|
| Georgia categories |
rename all; ships to "related ships" pending closure of below category |
January 4
|
| Category:German parties, which reject Agenda 2010 |
delete |
January 30
|
| Category:Gilmore Girls actors |
ditto |
January 21
|
| Category:Glapwell F.C. players |
delete |
January 26
|
| Category:GLBT New Zealand |
rename per nom |
January 5
|
| Category:Godzilla villains |
merge per reasonings above |
January 27
|
| Category:Golden Globe Award nominees |
delete |
January 10
|
| Golden Globe nominees |
delete |
January 10
|
| Category:Grand Slam champions |
delete |
January 15
|
| Category:Guests on Koffee with Anu |
delete |
January 28
|
| Category:Hackers known by pseudonyms |
delete |
January 24
|
| Category:Hairspray actors |
delete |
January 21
|
| Category:Half Man Half Biscuit albums and EPs |
rename |
January 19
|
| Category:Hawaiian religious leaders |
delete |
January 9
|
| Category:Heartbeat (TV series) connections |
rename |
January 27
|
| Category:Helicopter deaths |
speedily deleted per below |
January 7
|
| Category:High school sports associations |
rename |
January 4
|
| Category:High school sports conferences in Maryland |
rename |
January 8
|
| Category:High school sports conferences in Ohio |
rename |
January 8
|
| Category:High school sports conferences |
rename |
January 7
|
| Category:High schools in Orange County, Florida |
merge |
January 31
|
| Category:High Schools in Sutter County, California |
merge |
January 30
|
| Category:High Schools in Yuba County, California |
merge |
January 30
|
| Category:High schools in yuba-sutter area |
merge |
January 30
|
| Category:Hindu Fundamentalism |
delete |
January 13
|
| Category:Historic districts of Ontario |
merge per nom |
January 13
|
| Category:Historic houses in Florida |
merge |
January 24
|
| Category:Historic houses in the United States |
merge |
January 24
|
| Category:History of comic books |
delete |
January 5
|
| Category:Howard Stern Show |
delete |
January 24
|
| Category:Hubble images |
rename |
January 24
|
| Category:Humorously named people |
delete |
January 8
|
| Category:Hybrid music genres |
rename |
January 19
|
| Category:Hyperactive fictional characters |
delete |
January 4
|
| i/ION-related categories |
rename |
January 30
|
| Category:Images of birds |
reverse merge |
January 26
|
| Category:Images to be moved to the Commons |
no consensus |
January 4
|
| Category:Immigrants to America |
nomination withdrawn by proposer |
January 4
|
| Category:Important publication in mathematics |
rename to Category:Mathematics publications |
January 17
|
| Category:Incomplete Sydney suburbs |
delete |
January 20
|
| Category:Incorporated areas in Florida |
Merge |
January 18
|
| Category:Indian flags |
delete |
January 4
|
| Category:Indian Kids Actors |
merge |
January 19
|
| Category:Indigenous Australians - organisations |
rename |
January 24
|
| Category:Influential pre-modern women |
delete |
January 8
|
| Category:Instrumental Bands |
rename |
January 25
|
| Category:Intellectual property law |
merge Category:Intellectual property into Category:Intellectual property law |
January 9
|
| Category:Internet TV Channel |
rename to Category:Internet television channels |
January 11
|
| Category:Iqbaliat |
delete |
January 28
|
| Category:Irish-Scots |
no consensus |
January 16
|
| Category:Islam critical websites |
delete |
January 20
|
| Category:Islands of the Galápagos |
rename |
January 30
|
| Category:Italian air marshal |
merge |
January 31
|
| Category:Italian American boxers |
no consensus |
January 4
|
| Category:Italian national symbols |
merge |
January 29
|
| Category:Italian Writers in French language |
rename |
January 30
|
| Category:JAG cast |
delete |
January 5
|
| Category:Japanese statesmen |
Merge |
January 12
|
| Category:Jersey Pressure Groups |
rename |
January 29
|
| Category:Jewish psychologists |
Delete |
January 19
|
| Category:Jewish Simpsons characters |
merge |
January 28
|
| Category:Jewish Supreme Court justices |
no consensus to delete; rename to Category:Jewish United States Supreme Court justices |
January 1
|
| Category:Jewish-American businesspeople |
delete |
January 10
|
| Category:Jews and Judaism by city |
Keep |
January 17
|
| Category:Jews and Judaism by country |
keep |
January 17
|
| Category:Jews and Judaism in Kurdistan |
keep |
January 11
|
| Category:Jinnah |
rename, without prejudice towards a renomination for deletion; it is unclear how many of the rename-commenters object to deletion |
January 28
|
| Category:Joan of Arcadia actors |
rename to Category:Joan of Arcadia cast |
January 12
|
| Category:John Hobbs Medal recipients |
delete, list already present so no information lost |
January 21
|
| Category:John Peel Discoveries |
merge |
January 6
|
| Category:John Wayne films |
delete |
January 9
|
| Category:Judea and Samaria District |
rename |
January 17
|
| Category:Kazakh culture |
rename |
January 29
|
| Category:Kitchen appliance bands |
delete |
January 6
|
| Category:Kitesurfing locations |
delete |
January 17
|
| Category:Kohary |
rename |
January 13
|
| Category:Korean American poets |
merge per revised nom |
January 6
|
| Category:Korean phrases |
merge |
January 18
|
| Category:Kurdish inhabited regions |
keep |
January 11
|
| Category:Kuznetsov class aircraft carriers |
delete as empty and non-controversial |
January 9
|
| Category:L.A.W. members |
delete |
January 27
|
| Category:Language Colleges in Buckinghamshire |
delete |
January 27
|
| Category:Lars Gyllenhaal |
delete (note: category was empty) |
January 16
|
| Last of the book categories |
rename |
January 19
|
| Category:Law & Order actors |
Rename to Category:Fooian cast |
January 12
|
| Left communism categories |
rename |
January 8
|
| Category:Legend of Zelda |
Speedy delete as recreated material. Category salted to prevent recreation |
January 6
|
| Category:Legendary Toronto Godspell Cast |
delete |
January 27
|
| Category:Library and information science → Category:Library science |
no consensus |
January 20
|
| Category:Linux software |
delete this one, people who want a specialized one are welcome to write it |
January 20
|
| Category:List of Academy Award nominated black performers |
delete |
January 22
|
| Category:Lists of Marvel Comics superhero teams |
no consensus |
January 12
|
| Category:Lists of terrestrial volcanoes |
merge |
January 13
|
| Category:Lists of video game music |
delete per AFD |
January 31
|
| Category:Literature festivals |
rename |
January 18
|
| Category:Literature villains |
delete |
January 22
|
| Category:Living supercentenarians |
merge |
January 5
|
| Category:Lloyd Alexander books |
rename |
January 2
|
| Category:Locales in Andorra |
rename |
January 21
|
| Category:London Subway Stations |
merge |
January 27
|
| London Transport |
rename |
January 21
|
| Category:Long Island rappers |
merge |
January 20
|
| Category:Long route concurrencies |
delete |
January 27
|
| Category:Loyalist murder victims |
rename |
January 29
|
| Category:Lucky ☆ Star |
rename |
January 13
|
| México (state) |
rename |
January 31
|
| Category:Macaulay Institute |
merge |
January 1
|
| Category:Macedonian revolutionaries |
rename |
January 2
|
| Category:Madison Wisconsin based companies |
merge |
January 19
|
| Category:Mafia movies |
rename |
January 13
|
| Category:Major League Baseball Draft Picks |
delete |
January 28
|
| Category:Major League Baseball regular seasons |
merge |
January 24
|
| Malay diaspora |
Delete |
January 19
|
| Category:Manga and anime villains |
merge the lof of them |
January 27
|
| Category:Manifestations of God |
delete |
January 4
|
| Category:Maps of Oklahoma |
merge |
January 10
|
| Category:Maps of Texas |
merge |
January 10
|
| Category:Martial Artist Wikipedians |
looks like UCFD sorted it |
January 9
|
| Category:Marvel Comics - New Universe characters |
rename per nom |
January 13
|
| Category:Marvel team categories |
Delete (except for Heralds of Galactus), which I personally don't understand - if you're going to have articles on comic book superheroes, why the hell not categorize them according to their teams. I don't get it, but whatever. And no, I'm not going to listify these. Undoing the work of the editors who categorized these articles is plenty work enough for me, thank you very much, somebody who knows and cares what the lists should contain can do that |
January 13
|
| Category:Mathematical templates |
rename |
January 19
|
| Category:Mathematicians by religion |
no consensus |
January 12
|
| Category:Mayors of places in Sweden |
rename |
January 31
|
| Category:Media in Scotland |
rename |
January 31
|
| Category:Medical Schools in the District of Columbia |
merge |
January 29
|
| Category:Meditation for Spiritual Unfoldment |
keep |
January 28
|
| Category:Members of Nickel Creek |
rename |
January 21
|
| Category:Members of the Cabinet of Sweden |
als0 als0 rename |
January 31
|
| Category:Members of the Council on Foreign Relations |
delete |
January 27
|
| Category:Members of the Department of Pure Mathematics and Mathematical Statistics |
keep |
January 15
|
| Category:Members of the Trilateral Commission |
delete |
January 26
|
| Category:Members of the University of Cambridge Computer Laboratory |
keep |
January 15
|
| Category:Members of the Welsh Assembly |
rename |
January 21
|
| Memphis rappers |
merge per nom |
January 13
|
| Category:Memphis State University alumni |
rename |
January 22
|
| Category:Men writers |
delete |
January 27
|
| Category:Mental hospitals |
rename |
January 29
|
| Category:Mercenary groups |
rename |
January 16
|
| Category:Mestizos |
delete |
January 21
|
| Category:Methodist missionaries in Africa |
merge |
January 19
|
| Category:Methodist missionaries in Turkey |
merge per nom |
January 5
|
| Category:Methodist missionaries to British North America |
merge |
January 26
|
| Category:Metro Manila Newspapers and Magazines |
rename |
January 28
|
| Category:Mexican American Pro Quarterbacks |
delete |
January 23
|
| Category:Michigan Freemasons |
merge |
January 9
|
| Category:Military brat |
no consensus |
January 1
|
| Category:Military Engineer units and formations |
rename |
January 16
|
| Category:Military theme songs |
rename |
January 20
|
| Category:Military units and formations of South Korea |
reverse merge |
January 13
|
| Category:Military units and formations of the United States National Guard |
rename |
January 24
|
| Category:Mind Games (Mensa) |
rename |
January 16
|
| Category:Ministers of Lithuania |
rename |
January 24
|
| Category:Missionaries by denomination |
rename |
January 18
|
| Category:Missionaries by region of activity |
merge |
January 26
|
| Category:Missionaries in Africa |
merge |
January 5
|
| Category:Missionaries in Asia |
merge per nom |
January 5
|
| Category:Missionaries in China |
Renamed per nom, thank you |
January 20
|
| Category:Missionaries in Japan |
rename |
January 20
|
| Category:Missionaries to California |
rename |
January 18
|
| Category:Missionaries to Cameroon |
rename |
January 19
|
| Category:Missionaries to Hawaii |
rename |
January 18
|
| Category:Missionaries to India |
rename |
January 20
|
| Category:Missionary Bishops of the United Methodist Church |
RENAME to Category:Methodist Missionary Bishops. This category can thus contain anyone who is or was (1) a Methodist of any stripe, flavor, or denomination AND who (2) ever held the title of Missionary Bishop (note capitalization) |
January 7
|
| Category:Mobile Phone Providers in El Salvador |
rename |
January 13
|
| Category:Modern Rock Stations |
merge |
January 12
|
| Category:Money of Lithuania |
rename |
January 26
|
| Category:Mongolian women |
merge |
January 13
|
| Category:Moravian writers |
keep writers, delete poets |
January 6
|
| Category:Moskva class aircraft carriers |
deleted |
January 13
|
| Category:Motorcyclists |
delete (both) |
January 19
|
| Category:Mouse breeds |
no consensus to delete; rename |
January 3
|
| Category:Mouse genus |
Category has already been moved to Category:Genera of mice |
January 5
|
| Category:Music videos filmed in Italy |
delete |
January 27
|
| Category:Music with social content |
delete |
January 13
|
| Category:Musical instrument manufacturers |
do not merge, but rename Category:Musical instrument manufacturers to Category:Musical instrument manufacturing companies and annotate the categories. Per Chicheley and others, the distinction between makers and manufacturers is perfectly clear |
January 11
|
| Category:Mute people |
keep |
January 29
|
| Category:My Name Is Earl actors |
rename, insufficient consensus for deletion |
January 19
|
| Category:Mythomaniacs |
delete |
January 29
|
| Category:Namesakes of streets in New York City |
delete |
January 22
|
| Category:National Guard |
merge |
January 1
|
| Category:National Hockey League All-Star Team Member |
rename |
January 25
|
| Category:National Medal of Arts recipients |
rename to Category:United States National Medal of Arts recipients |
January 22
|
| Category:National parks of Ireland |
speedy deleted per below |
January 1
|
| Category:Native fauna of Texas |
merge |
January 31
|
| Category:Natives of Limburg |
rename to Category:People from Limburg (Netherlands). — |
January 17
|
| Category:Natives of Oslo |
no consensus. Evenly split on a simple vote count. I see this debate has been unclosed for over a month, presumably because it touches on the ongoing dichotomy between supporters of the relative benefits of categories "Natives of Foo" (one was either verifiably born there or not, but need not necessarily be "readily associated with" Foo) and categories "People from Foo" or similar (one may be "readily associated with" Foo, but this association is not always straightforward, although it is sometimes unquestionable). It seems to me that both have benefits and drawbacks; has this ever been discussed centrally? Has anyone suggested that having both schemes might be beneficial? - I think of a comparison between Mozart/Salzburg with Beethoven/Bonn (unquestionably natives of…), Mozart/Vienna and Beethoven/Vienna (unquestionably people associated with…). No arguments put forward here address Oslo as a specific case. I note that the category text incongruously states "natives/residents of Oslo" |
January 16
|
| Category:Natives of Transylvania |
rename |
January 15
|
| Category:Natives of Württemberg |
merge |
January 12
|
| Category:Natives of Yerevan |
rename |
January 25
|
| Category:Nebular images |
rename to Category:Images of nebulae |
January 25
|
| Category:New Kind of Science |
delete |
January 26
|
| Category:New York Mets second round draft picks |
merge |
January 31
|
| Category:New York Rap |
Merging. Closing early since the consensus is clear |
January 20
|
| Category:New Zealand Corrections Facilities |
merge per nom |
January 13
|
| Category:New Zealand electricity retailers |
rename |
January 28
|
| New Zealand ethnicity categories |
rename |
January 10
|
| Category:Nicktoon villains |
delete. "It's useful" is not a particularly strong argument, and even some keep-commenters note that this is ambiguous |
January 27
|
| Category:Night Stalker Actors |
delete |
January 21
|
| Category:Nobles of England |
merge |
January 10
|
| Category:Nobles |
speedy delete |
January 27
|
| Category:Norse sagas |
reverse merge, but keep Category:Sagas as parent since there is a list of sagas |
January 10
|
| Category:Norse sagas |
merge |
January 20
|
| Category:North Dakota Fighting Sioux and Clarkson Golden Knights hockey players |
rename |
January 17
|
| Category:Northamptonshire Football Clubs |
delete |
January 15
|
| Category:Northern Ireland architects |
rename |
January 6
|
| Category:Northern Irish terrorists |
rename to paramilitary |
January 29
|
| Category:Notable college football games |
rename |
January 5
|
| Category:Novels of Russell Banks |
rename |
January 9
|
| NRC Regions |
rename for now but note that several supporting changing from the current names are also open to a restructuring of the categorisation. I recommend that this closure should not be taken to prevent any such restructuring being proposed |
January 5
|
| Category:Number-one singles on the Canadian airplay chart |
no consensus |
January 1
|
| Category:Occitan personalities |
no consensus to delete; rename |
January 1
|
| Category:October Birthdays |
SPEEDY DELETED as repost of deleted category |
January 2
|
| Category:October Deaths |
delete |
January 2
|
| Category:October Events |
delete |
January 2
|
| Category:Old Norse poems |
delete |
January 10
|
| Category:Older versions of cartoon characters |
Delete |
January 19
|
| Category:On MST3K DVD |
delete |
January 7
|
| On weither to keep or delete Category:Charmed actors |
closed as ongoing |
January 22
|
| Category:Online lyrics databases |
speedily redirected to Online music and lyrics databases as re-creation |
January 7
|
| Category:Ooccupational organizations |
speedily deleted per below |
January 12
|
| Category:Other Police of The Wire |
merge |
January 24
|
| Category:Otogi Zoshi characters |
category has now been deleted prior to the close of discussion |
January 6
|
| Category:Oxenstierna |
rename |
January 9
|
| Category:Pages referenced by the press |
rename |
January 10
|
| Paintings by year categories |
keep all. — |
January 2
|
| Category:Palestine |
no consensus |
January 1
|
| Palestinian territories |
rename all |
January 9
|
| Passions (Soap Opera) character categories |
delete all. — |
January 2
|
| Pastors by nationality |
merge |
January 3
|
| Category:Patent Medicines |
moved to CfD speedy rename section |
January 18
|
| Category:Patient's organizations |
speedily renamed per below |
January 12
|
| Category:Peel Regional Roads |
merge |
January 6
|
| Category:People by political orientation |
no consensus |
January 26
|
| Category:People form Erzincan |
speedy delete |
January 28
|
| Category:People from Bolton, Massachusetts |
merge |
January 20
|
| Category:People from La Rioja Province (Argentina) |
merge/rename |
January 2
|
| Category:People from Rudrapatna |
merge mainly because there's only one article in there |
January 28
|
| Category:People known by first name only |
delete both |
January 15
|
| Category:People of Buckinghamshire |
merge |
January 8
|
| Category:People with absolute pitch |
delete |
January 27
|
| Category:People with anxiety disorder |
delete |
January 30
|
| Category:People with glossophobia |
delete |
January 15
|
| Category:People with Multiple Personality Disorder |
delete |
January 9
|
| Category:People with social anxiety disorder |
pragmatic delete |
January 15
|
| Perth |
rename all except Category:Members of the Australian House of Representatives for Perth |
January 3
|
| Category:Peruvian Movie Theaters to Category:Cinemas in Peru |
rename to Category:Cinemas in Peru |
January 8
|
| Category:Philanthropic Organizations |
SPEEDY DELETED |
January 21
|
| Category:Pilkington Recs |
delete |
January 21
|
| Category:Piracy computer and video games |
Arrrrr. I mean, RENAME to Category:Computer and video games about pirates. The point is well taken that "pirates" is much clearer than "piracy" due to the latter term have a dual meaning (true, "pirates" technically has the same dual meaning, but it just isn't as likely to be taken as the software-pirate sense - I can't really explain why this is so, but I think most would agree that it is). Anything about "piracy" is also about "pirates" so I think there's little if any loss of meaning in the rename. And if we change "piracy" to "pirates" it has to be Category:Computer and video games about pirates because Category:Pirate computer and video games is obviously a nonstarter |
January 7
|
| Category:Pitch Black and The Chronicles of Riddick |
rename per Otto |
January 30
|
| Category:Pixar directors |
delete |
January 21
|
| Category:Places impacted by urban decay |
delete |
January 26
|
| Category:Planescape: Torment |
delete |
January 2
|
| Category:Political parties in Palestine |
rename |
January 9
|
| Category:Politicians killed during election campaign |
delete |
January 28
|
| Category:Port cities |
reverse merge |
January 17
|
| Category:Portugal-related projects |
delete |
January 10
|
| Category:Postcommunist parties |
Delete —— |
January 16
|
| Category:Predominantly African American Christian denominations |
no consensus |
January 18
|
| Category:Presbyterian actors |
delete |
January 12
|
| Category:Prisoners Confined at the United States Disciplinary Barracks |
delete |
January 1
|
| Category:Prize winners |
merge all into Category:Award winners |
January 9
|
| Category:Prizes |
merge |
January 9
|
| Category:Programs produced by Thirteen/WNET New York |
no consensus |
January 17
|
| Category:Project for the New American Century |
delete |
January 27
|
| Proposed new Category:Long words in English |
do not create |
January 30
|
| Category:Public Accountant Firms → Category:Public accountancy firms |
rename to Category:Accountancy firms |
January 2
|
| Category:Public accounts |
relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2007 February 3#Category:Public accounts |
January 16
|
| Category:Public education in the United States |
no consensus |
January 5
|
| Category:Public Schools in Lee County, Florida |
delete |
January 15
|
| Category:Public utility |
no consensus to merge; rename to Category:Types of public utility |
January 7
|
| Category:Quinn Martin Production |
delete |
January 9
|
| Category:Rakeshsharma/userboxes |
delete |
January 1
|
| Category:Rangoon -2 |
redirect |
January 11
|
| Category:Rangoon |
delete and redirect |
January 10
|
| Category:Rappers from Brooklyn |
merge, though as Pascal points out these could be reasonable categories in future |
January 23
|
| Category:Rat breeds |
no consensus to delete; rename |
January 3
|
| Category:Rat genera |
rename |
January 12
|
| Category:Rat genus |
rename |
January 5
|
| Category:Reality Television Editions |
delete. — |
January 2
|
| Category:Red pandas |
delete |
January 10
|
| Category:Referendum |
Relist |
January 1
|
| Category:Referendum |
Rename to Category:Referendums |
January 18
|
| Category:Religion in Kurdistan |
keep |
January 11
|
| Category:Religious executives |
merge |
January 1
|
| Category:Religious supremacists |
delete |
January 12
|
| Category:Rep. Keith Ellison (D-MN) |
delete |
January 23
|
| Category:Republican Judges |
DELETE. First of all, unless renamed, this category cannot use who the person was appointed by as shorthand for his political party. Believe it or not, in the Good Old Days Democratic presidents and governors used to sometimes appoint Republican judges and vice versa. So as named it can only stand for (1) the person's private political partly affiliation on their voter registrations or (2) their party affiliation when they stood for election. But (1) is not an obtainable public record, and (2) is problematic because many judges never stand for election or, if they do, do not run under a party affiliation |
January 7
|
| Category:Republican murder victims |
delete as empty |
January 29
|
| Category:Reservoirs of Greece |
speedy delete |
January 10
|
| Category:Rhythm & Blues |
merge |
January 19
|
| Category:Rhythmic Top 40 acts |
speedy delete per below |
January 12
|
| Category:Rip-offs of Gimmick! |
delete |
January 21
|
| Category:Rivers named for women |
delete |
January 31
|
| Category:Rivers of Styria |
merge |
January 28
|
| Roads in Durham Region |
upmerge |
January 8
|
| Category:Roads in Orillia |
delete |
January 4
|
| Roads in Peel Region |
upmerge |
January 8
|
| Roads in Simcoe County |
upmerge |
January 8
|
| Roads in York Region |
upmerge |
January 8
|
| Category:Roman Catholic dioceses of Canada |
rename |
January 9
|
| Category:Roman Catholic dioceses of the United States |
rename |
January 12
|
| Category:Roman Catholic mobsters |
SPEEDY DELETED, as repost of previously deleted category |
January 5
|
| Category:Roman Catholic musicians |
Relist |
January 19
|
| Category:Roman Catholic scientists |
delete |
January 4
|
| Category:Roman Catholics musicians |
delete the nominated category i.e. Category:Roman Catholics musicians. Please read the nomination and comments when !voting |
January 18
|
| Category:Roman era Christian martyrs |
rename |
January 7
|
| Category:Roman helmets |
merge |
January 22
|
| Category:Royal Family of Cambodia |
rename |
January 13
|
| Category:São Toméan culture |
rename |
January 5
|
| Category:Sagas of Iceland |
delete |
January 21
|
| Category:Sailors who committed suicide |
merge |
January 19
|
| Category:Saskatchewan Huskies ice hockey players |
Keep |
January 26
|
| Category:Saskatechewan Roughriders players |
delete |
January 29
|
| Category:Scary Movie characters |
merge |
January 19
|
| Category:Schools in Boone County, Kentucky |
delete |
January 13
|
| Category:Science fiction short story collections |
keep/withdrawn |
January 30
|
| Category:Scientists by religion |
delete all |
January 12
|
| Category:Scooby-Doo actors |
delete |
January 4
|
| Category:Secret Six members |
delete |
January 20
|
| Category:Seether singles |
rename |
January 21
|
| Category:Selectively mute people |
delete |
January 29
|
| Category:Separate Companies of the United States Army |
rename |
January 14
|
| Category:Series broadcast by Animax |
delete |
January 19
|
| Category:Series of children's books |
merge into Category:Series of children's books |
January 11
|
| Category:Series of fantasy books |
merge |
January 6
|
| Category:Series of fantasy novels |
merge |
January 6
|
| Category:Series-specific villains |
merge, per all the above |
January 27
|
| Category:Serious games |
oppose to this rename. Given the feelings that a clearer name is needed, I recommend a relisting, with category to be determined by consensus |
January 5
|
| Category:Serious games |
delete |
January 12
|
| Category:Sermon writers |
no consensus |
January 1
|
| Category:Settlements by region |
keep |
January 18
|
| Category:Settlements in Oklahoma |
keep |
January 15
|
| Short stories & collections |
rename |
January 17
|
| Category:Short stories by type |
rename |
January 16
|
| Category:Shows on Turner Classic Movies |
rename to Category:Turner Classic Movies shows. It seems the majority of related categories use "shows" and also avoids "programs"/"programmes" arguments |
January 18
|
| Category:Silver Buffalo awardees |
delete. Most keep-comments are procedural or based on personal preference, rather than guidelines, or on the assumption that a list of awardees would be 'cruft'. It's not a problem if something was also discussed here three months ago |
January 28
|
| Silver medals, Gold medals, Civilian cross decorations |
delete |
January 3
|
| Category:Singers by religion |
delete. This is pretty borderline but considering that a no consensus result wouldn't please anyone, I've gone with the majority opinion |
January 18
|
| Category:Slavic tribes |
merge |
January 30
|
| Category:Smoking cessation |
merge/redirect |
January 9
|
| Category:Soap Stars |
delete and redirect |
January 6
|
| Category:Songs Performed on "Make Your Own Kind Of Music" |
Delete |
January 19
|
| Category:Songs with different titles |
delete |
January 20
|
| Category:Sons of Confederate Veterans |
nomination withdrawn by proposer |
January 3
|
| Category:Sony Playstation 2 games |
merge |
January 21
|
| Category:South Africa by province |
Speedy Merged |
January 27
|
| Category:South Park children |
Delete |
January 19
|
| Category:Space NGO |
rename |
January 12
|
| Category:Space visionaries |
delete |
January 30
|
| Category:Spanish Americans |
merge & redirect |
January 15
|
| Category:Spanish-English people |
delete |
January 7
|
| Category:Spinto Tenor |
merge |
January 7
|
| Category:Sport in Antrim |
merge and redirect |
January 14
|
| Category:Sport in Armagh |
merge and redirect |
January 14
|
| Category:Sporty museums |
deleted |
January 21
|
| Category:Sree Narayana Guru |
rename, lack of consensus for deletion |
January 25
|
| Category:St Bartholomew School of Nursing & Midwifery |
delete |
January 18
|
| Category:Stalinists |
delete and salt |
January 15
|
| Category:Star Trek Simulation Forum |
'delete |
January 25
|
| Category:Star Wars articles |
merge per nom |
January 13
|
| Category:Starfleet personnel |
Delete |
January 19
|
| State ship-related categories |
rename as Will Beback's suggestion i.e |
January 4
|
| Category:State University of New York at Purchase famous alumni producers |
merge |
January 25
|
| Category:Stateless peoples |
delete |
January 4
|
| Category:Straths and glens |
rename to Category:Glens of Scotland |
January 18
|
| Category:Streetcars in Manhattan |
merge |
January 4
|
| Streetcars in New York City |
rename |
January 11
|
| Subcategories of Actors by religion |
delete all |
January 12
|
| Subcategories of Category:Aviation accidents and incidents by country |
no rename for main nom, and rename others for consistency |
January 23
|
| Subcats of Category:People by Former Religion |
delete |
January 1
|
| Subdivisions of France |
rename |
January 3
|
| Category:Subversive artists |
delete |
January 8
|
| Category:Sudbury, Vermont |
merge |
January 24
|
| Category:Super Bowl champions |
delete |
January 31
|
| Category:Supermodels |
SPEEDY DELETED, recreation of deleted category |
January 19
|
| Category:Supervillains by adversary |
delete |
January 30
|
| Category:Swedish County Governors |
als0 rename |
January 31
|
| Category:Swedish Governors-General |
rename |
January 31
|
| Category:Swedish Privy Councillors |
rename |
January 31
|
| Category:Swedish regents |
rename |
January 31
|
| Category:Syndicated television series |
delete |
January 7
|
| Category:Tahirids |
rename |
January 18
|
| Category:Taiwanese baseball |
rename |
January 31
|
| Category:Tamil filmmakers |
rename |
January 21
|
| Category:TAU Cerámica basketball players |
rename |
January 15
|
| Category:Television miniseries |
no merge. We can keep it as it is; for miniseries from the countries with subcategories, the articles can go in those subcategories, otherwise they can go in the parent category. — |
January 7
|
| Category:Television protagonists |
delete |
January 18
|
| Category:Television villains |
delete |
January 16
|
| Template categories |
rename first, keep second |
January 19
|
| Template category disambiguation |
rename |
January 19
|
| Category:Territories under military occupation |
keep |
January 7
|
| Category:The 4400 actors, Category:Andromeda (TV series) actors, Category:Battlestar Galactica (1978) actors, Category:Battlestar Galactica (2004) actors, Category:Heroes (TV series) actors, Category:Roswell actors and Category:Torchwood actors |
rename to "cast" |
January 4
|
| Category:The Art of Noise |
rename |
January 10
|
| Category:The Big O characters |
delete |
January 15
|
| Category:The Facts of Life characters |
delete |
January 28
|
| Category:The Goodies connection |
rename |
January 26
|
| Category:The Lockharts |
delete |
January 7
|
| The Return of Books by author |
rename all and commend Her Pegship for taking on the nomination |
January 17
|
| Category:The Twelfth Man |
rename |
January 20
|
| Category:Theodore Roosevelt Award recipients |
delete |
January 26
|
| Category:Things Related to the Dominican Republic |
merge |
January 26
|
| Category:Tomboys |
delete |
January 16
|
| Category:Top 40 songs |
delete |
January 4
|
| Category:Towns in Belarus |
rename |
January 3
|
| Category:Towns in California |
merge |
January 13
|
| Category:Towns in Crimea |
rename |
January 15
|
| Category:Towns in France |
upmerge to Category:Cities, towns and villages in France for now |
January 7
|
| Towns in the Netherlands |
rename |
January 28
|
| Category:Trademark Law |
speedy merge. × |
January 17
|
| Category:Translators by source material |
delete |
January 13
|
| Category:Translators of hymns |
delete. Although some contributors have said that Category:Translators by source material should also be deleted, no notice has been placed there and a separate CFD is best for this |
January 5
|
| Transport in Africa |
rename |
January 27
|
| Transport in Asia |
rename |
January 30
|
| Category:Treaties involving territorial changes |
no consensus |
January 9
|
| Category:Tree of life |
no consensus, and Category:Organisms has been created now anyway. Further discussion at Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Tree of Life |
January 10
|
| Category:Treehouse of Horror episodes |
DELETE |
January 19
|
| Category:Triple Crown champions |
delete |
January 15
|
| Category:Triple J Hottest 100 Winners |
delete |
January 30
|
| Category:Truten lovers |
delete |
January 30
|
| Category:Turkish fascists |
delete |
January 7
|
| Category:Turkish Olympic medalists |
delete |
January 27
|
| Category:TV shows that use Descriptive Video Service |
listify |
January 28
|
| Category:Two Joysticks, no buttons |
delete and send to WP:DAFT. For the record, the category contained one-player computer and video games that require two joysticks, but no "fire" button |
January 6
|
| Category:Types of forces |
rename to Category:Types of military forces |
January 16
|
| Category:Types of museum |
no consensus |
January 13
|
| Category:Ugly Betty actors |
rename |
January 19
|
| Category:UK Anime conventions |
rename |
January 15
|
| UK MPs |
"no" to en-dashes; no consensus on Grutness' rename proposal. In the light of BrownHairedGirl's statement that these categories were created for the convenience of cross-checking by contributors to the subject area, may I suggest that consideration be given to whether these categories should be treated as maintenance categories? They should perhaps be placed on the articles' talk pages, and not on the articles themselves? All the articles perhaps belong in Category:Members of the United Kingdom Parliament |
January 10
|
| Category:Ukrainian people in the United States |
rename |
January 4
|
| Category:United Kingdom Choirs |
rename to Category:British choirs |
January 6
|
| Category:United Methodist bishops of the Florida Area |
upmerge |
January 6
|
| United Methodist bishops |
merge |
January 1
|
| United Methodist bishops |
merge |
January 2
|
| Category:United Methodist college and university presidents |
upmerge to Category:American university presidents |
January 7
|
| Category:United States Department of Labor appointees |
rename |
January 26
|
| Category:United States National Guard bases |
rename |
January 16
|
| Category:United States National Guard soldiers |
rename |
January 18
|
| Universities and colleges II |
rename all. |
January 26
|
| Category:Unleavened breads |
a virtual tie between merging one way, merging the other way and keeping the two separate. So no discernible consensus |
January 3
|
| Category:Urban Decay and Riots |
listify |
January 2
|
| Category:Urban decay |
no consensus |
January 2
|
| Category:User en |
User category so moved to Wikipedia:User categories for discussion#Category:User en |
January 4
|
| Category:User pages requesting assistance |
User category so moved to Wikipedia:User categories for discussion#Category:User pages requesting assistance |
January 4
|
| Category:User_en-cñ |
delete |
January 4
|
| Category:UTC |
delete all |
January 25
|
| Category:UTC+3 |
delete |
January 28
|
| Category:UTC-5 |
delete |
January 29
|
| Category:Utilities of the United Kingdom |
nomination withdrawn with apologies to British English |
January 7
|
| Category:Uttaranchal |
{{category redirect}}. If there is no objection, I will also {{category redirect}} the subcategories too as suggested by Recury |
January 8
|
| Category:Victory songs |
delete |
January 20
|
| Category:Video Game consoles |
speedy delete |
January 8
|
| Category:Video Games based on Movies |
delete |
January 3
|
| Category:Villages in Silesia |
delete |
January 21
|
| Category:Villain groups |
delete |
January 22
|
| Category:Villain races |
delete |
January 4
|
| Category:Virgin hilltowns |
delete |
January 28
|
| Category:Wards of Seoul |
DELETE. We have a duplicate category - Category:Wards of Seoul amd Category:Gu of Seoul. We can't have both. The question is, should the single category that is left be called "Wards", "Gu", or "Administrative divisons"? There's lively argument here, and no consensus. I'm pretty much going to have to make a judgement call here, judging the arguments, and I hope I get it right and don't get too many people mad - or, at least, leave everyone equally mad |
January 7
|
| Warfare by era |
rename |
January 6
|
| Category:Warrior women |
delete |
January 12
|
| Category:Washington D.C. record labels |
merge/delete |
January 24
|
| Category:Wet chemistry |
delete |
January 11
|
| Category:Wiki parodies |
delete |
January 9
|
| Category:Wikipedia subject-specific style guidelines |
upmerge |
January 3
|
| Category:Wikipedian military |
merge |
January 3
|
| Category:Wikipedians by interest |
withdrawn |
January 9
|
| Category:Wikipedians who like The Pussycat Dolls |
sd |
January 7
|
| Category:Wikipedians who use MusicianDictionary.com |
move discussion to WP:UCFD |
January 23
|
| Category:WikiProject Computer and video games selected articles |
delete |
January 2
|
| Category:WikiProject New York City Subway |
rename |
January 4
|
| Category:Will & Grace actors |
ditto |
January 21
|
| Category:Windows security |
delete |
January 4
|
| Category:Windsurfing locations |
delete |
January 23
|
| Category:Winnipeg companies |
rename |
January 25
|
| Category:Wireless Consultant |
Speedy delete |
January 4
|
| Category:Wizards of the Coast novels |
delete |
January 1
|
| Category:Women writers |
delete |
January 27
|
| Category:Woodstock |
delete all (Category:Woodstock only contained the two performers categories listed here and the Woodstock Festival article.) |
January 15
|
| Category:Works of Art: Artcars |
delete |
January 26
|
| Category:World War II army corps |
rename |
January 7
|
| Category:Writers by audience and nationality |
delete |
January 6
|
| Category:Writers by audience |
delete |
January 6
|
| Category:Writing systems without Word Boundaries |
speedy rename |
January 20
|
| Category:WWE Champions |
delete |
January 15
|
| Category:WWE World Heavyweight Champions |
delete |
January 15
|
| Yes |
rename all |
January 7
|
| Category:Zionism in Somalia |
delete |
January 3
|
| Category:Zombina and the Skeletones |
rename |
January 26
|
