| Category |
Decision |
Discussion_log
|
| Category:1632 series books |
No Consensus |
September 4
|
| Category:1632 series images pages |
Keep |
September 4
|
| Category:2007 City Elections in Alberta |
delete as empty category |
September 28
|
| Category:2009 Candidate for Manhattan Distract Attorney |
delete |
September 22
|
| Category:20th-century American football running backs, etc |
Delete all six—the categories are empty and nothing needs to be merged |
September 5
|
| Category:21st-century male basketball centers |
merge (category was empty at close). The other similar categories were not included in this nomination |
September 14
|
| Category:A&P |
rename |
September 20
|
| Category:Academics by subject |
Rename to Category:Scholars and academics by subject. I think that an offline discussion to consider Category:Academics and Category:Scholars and how they should be used would be helpful for future debates |
September 29
|
| Category:Acquisitions by Google |
merge Category:Acquisitions by Google to Category:Google acquisitions, with no prejudice for nominating Category:Google acquisitions (and other similarly-named subcategories of Category:Mergers and acquisitions) for renaming to the Acquisitions by Foo or Companies acquired by Foo format. The discussion is basically a "no consensus" concerning the question of what the category title should be, but there is consensus that two categories are not needed. Consolidating them now will make any future nomination to rename less complicated. – |
September 1
|
| Active and retired astronauts |
Delete: |
September 9
|
| Category:Actors to portray superheroes |
delete |
September 21
|
| Category:Administrative divisions of federal subjects of Russia |
Rename Category:Administrative divisions of federal subjects of Russia to Category:Administrative divisions of the federal subjects of Russia |
September 3
|
| Category:Afghan Governor |
Deleted per request. Other users may wish to nominate Category:Afghan governor to pluralise it and to make its meaning clearer. |
September 22
|
| Category:Afghan governor |
Speedy rename to Category:Afghan governors (pluralise; speedy criterion #3) |
September 22
|
| Category:Afghani economists |
Rename |
September 24
|
| AFL |
Rename all |
September 26
|
| Category:African American players of American football |
no consensus |
September 9
|
| Category:African American players of Canadian football |
no consensus |
September 9
|
| Afro-Cuban jazz musicians |
Rename |
September 30
|
| Category:Agosta 90B class submarines |
Rename Category:Agosta 90B class submarines to Category:Agosta class submarines |
September 6
|
| Aircraft carriers by navy |
rename all |
September 25
|
| Category:American influence in post-WWII Europe |
rename to Category:American influence in post-World War II Europe |
September 14
|
| Category:Anarky |
delete |
September 22
|
| Category:Ancient Indian culture |
keep |
September 29
|
| Category:Anime and manga about music |
Rename Category:Anime and manga about music to Category:Music-themed anime and manga |
September 5
|
| Category:Anti-aircraft guns of the Soviet Union |
No Consensus |
September 18
|
| Category:Anti-gay propaganda |
Delete |
September 23
|
| Category:Anzac class destroyers |
Rename Category:Anzac class destroyers to Category:Parker class leaders |
September 6
|
| Category:Arab statesmen |
Merge to Category:Arab politicians |
September 23
|
| Category:Arabia |
Rename |
September 26
|
| Category:Articles lacking sources |
Keep |
September 8
|
| Category:Articles needing additional references |
keep |
September 8
|
| Category:ASIFA international animation film festivals |
delete both |
September 18
|
| Category:ASIFA local animation film festivals |
Rename to Category:International Animated Film Association per revised nomination. |
September 26
|
| Category:Auburn University professors |
Merge Category:Auburn University professors to Category:Auburn University faculty |
September 19
|
| Category:Australian Institute of Management Members |
delete |
September 16
|
| Category:Australian legislation |
Relisted for further comment - Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2009 September 12#Category:Australian legislation |
September 3
|
| Category:Australian legislation |
Rename Category:Australian legislation to Category:Commonwealth of Australia laws |
September 12
|
| Category:Australian Top 40 radio stations |
Rename Category:Australian Top 40 radio stations to Category:Contemporary hit radio stations in Australia |
September 10
|
| Authors |
merge |
September 19
|
| Category:Bachman-Turner Overdrive |
No Consensus in this debate. As and when consensus on this issue is reached elsewhere these categories may be renominated |
September 14
|
| Category:Bahamian directors |
Rename Category:Bahamian directors to Category:Bahamian film directors |
September 7
|
| Category:Ballet redirects |
Upmerge to corresponding content categories where possible, otherwise delete. Straight deletion, though initially proposed, seems to have fallen by the wayside in favour of a selective merger |
September 9
|
| Bamboo and Bamboos |
Rename Category:Bamboos to Category:Bamboo taxa. Keep Category:Bamboo |
September 10
|
| Bands from |
rename |
September 19
|
| Category:Barnstorming teams |
Delete |
September 26
|
| Category:Baroque architecture in the Ukraine |
speedy rename |
September 16
|
| Category:Barracuda class submarines |
Rename to Category:United States Barracuda class submarines (1951) |
September 3
|
| Category:Basketball forwards by century |
Delete. (At close, category only contained two empty subcategories, so nothing is being lost by deletion.) |
September 22
|
| Category:Bastia Umbra |
Delete |
September 5
|
| Category:Batman characters |
No Consensus |
September 22
|
| Batman film subcategories |
Relisted for further comment - Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2009 September 20#Batman film subcategories |
September 11
|
| Batman film subcategories |
Upmerge |
September 20
|
| Category:BCCI Corporate Teams |
Rename |
September 30
|
| Category:Ben Elton |
delete |
September 19
|
| Category:Bettona |
Delete |
September 5
|
| Category:Bevagna |
Delete |
September 5
|
| Category:Big Ten champion seasons |
Delete. There is no real consensus to endorse the new names, but there also isn't any enthusiasm for reversing the out-of-process moves. We'll just delete the nominated categories as empty, but this discussion shouldn't be read as endorsing what was done or the current names that were selected out-of-process, and the newly-named categories may be nominated for renaming at any time. |
September 23
|
| Bilateral relations |
Rename: |
September 5
|
| Category:Biodiesel crops |
Rename Category:Biodiesel crops to Category:Biodiesel feedstock sources |
September 28
|
| Category:Biota of the West Bank |
Delete |
September 6
|
| Category:Bisexual models |
No Consensus |
September 5
|
| Category:Black Albums |
Rename Category:Black Albums to Category:Black (Bangladeshi band) albums |
September 10
|
| Booian Peruvians to Peruvian people of Booian descent |
Rename all |
September 24
|
| Botswanan to Botswana |
rename |
September 21
|
| Category:Brainwashing techniques |
merge |
September 29
|
| Category:Breton political parties in France |
merge |
September 27
|
| Category:British Columbia Lions |
Rename: |
September 29
|
| Category:British O class submarines |
rename |
September 15
|
| Category:British S class submarines |
Rename Category:British S class submarines to Category:British S class submarines (1931) |
September 8
|
| Category:Buildings on the Isle of Dogs |
Rename Category:Buildings on the Isle of Dogs to Category:Buildings and structures on the Isle of Dogs |
September 4
|
| Category:Burials at National Register of Historic Places (U.S.A.) |
delete |
September 15
|
| Category:Burmese playwrights |
Rename Category:Burmese playwrights to Category:Burmese dramatists and playwrights |
September 6
|
| Category:Campello sul Clitunno |
Delete |
September 5
|
| Category:Canadian male basketball players |
Merge |
September 22
|
| Category:Cancelled Super NES games |
Rename Category:Cancelled Super NES games to Category:Cancelled Super Nintendo Entertainment System games |
September 8
|
| Category:Cannara |
Delete |
September 5
|
| Category:Canonizations of Pope Pius XII |
Delete |
September 21
|
| Category:Cascia |
Delete |
September 5
|
| Category:Castel Ritaldi |
Delete |
September 5
|
| Category:Castiglione del Lago |
Delete |
September 5
|
| Category:Catholic Centre Party politicians |
merge |
September 28
|
| Category:CFL MOP Award winners |
rename to Category:Canadian Football League Most Outstanding Player Award winners |
September 22
|
| Category:Characters created by Grant Morrison |
Recreate Category:Characters created by Grant Morrison |
September 29
|
| Category:Chicago albums |
Rename Category:Chicago albums to Category:Chicago (band) albums |
September 9
|
| Category:Chicago Maroons players |
Rename Category:Chicago Maroons players to Category:Chicago Maroons soccer players |
September 19
|
| Category:Chicago songs |
Rename Category:Chicago songs to Category:Chicago (band) songs |
September 9
|
| Category:Chilean scholars and academics |
Merge Category:Chilean scholars and academics to Category:Chilean academics |
September 19
|
| Category:Chinese Canadians from Hong Kong |
Keep |
September 29
|
| Category:CHiPs episodes |
Delete |
September 24
|
| Category:Christian Democratic Party politicians |
Rename Category:Christian Democratic Party politicians to Category:Christian Democratic Party (Australia) politicians |
September 19
|
| Category:Christian Education National schools in Australia |
Merge Category:Christian Education National schools in Australia to Category:Christian schools in Australia |
September 9
|
| Category:Christian genre types |
Rename as nominated. Creation of a subcategory for Category:Christian literary genres may be appropriate. |
September 14
|
| Category:Christian rock albums by artist |
No Consensus |
September 16
|
| Category:Christian Schools Australia schools |
Merge Category:Christian Schools Australia schools to Category:Christian schools in Australia |
September 9
|
| Category:Church of God in Christ Christians |
Rename to Category:Members of the Church of God in Christ |
September 26
|
| Civil/Military decorations |
Rename all |
September 27
|
| Category:Clothing-optional events |
merge Category:Clothing optional events to Category:Clothing-optional events, per "Otto" |
September 8
|
| Category:Clovis, California |
Keep |
September 2
|
| Category:Coatbridge Irish |
Merge Category:Coatbridge Irish to Category:People from Coatbridge and Category:Scots of Irish descent |
September 7
|
| Category:College athletics |
Rename all per nom |
September 29
|
| Category:College houses of the University of Chicago |
Delete |
September 7
|
| Category:College soccer players |
merge |
September 19
|
| Category:Communist Party of Russia members |
Rename Category:Communist Party of Russia members to Category:Communist Party of the Russian Federation members |
September 5
|
| Category:Companies of the United States by location |
keep the category but remove articles from it. I have placed Template:Container-cat in the category. Articles should be removed manually or by bot. Their talk pages may be moved into a newly-created WP admin category if desired. (The only reason I will not use a bot to remove the articles is in case someone wants to automate a bot to add the talk pages of these articles to another category. If it's decided we just want to remove these with no further action, we could use a bot to empty out the category.) |
September 16
|
| Category:Computer language stubs |
Move to WP:SFD at Wikipedia:Stub types for deletion/Log/2009/September/1#Category:Computer language stubs |
September 1
|
| Category:Concentration camps |
Keep |
September 29
|
| Category:Constituent countries of the United Kingdom |
Merge Category:Constituent countries of the United Kingdom to Category:United Kingdom |
September 21
|
| Category:Converts to Eastern Orthodox Christianity |
Rename Category:Converts to Eastern Orthodox Christianity to Category:Converts to Eastern Orthodoxy |
September 30
|
| Category:Convicted British child molesters |
Keep |
September 29
|
| Category:Countries located within Austria-Hungary |
Delete |
September 16
|
| Category:Crayola |
KEEP |
September 17
|
| Category:Crimean Wikipedians |
Delete |
September 4
|
| Category:Current events Canada |
No Consensus |
September 10
|
| Category:Danaidae |
Merge Category:Danaidae to Category:Danainae |
September 29
|
| Category:Dance company redirects |
Delete: |
September 8
|
| Category:Danes of Hungarian descent |
Rename Category:Danes of Hungarian descent to Category:Danish people of Hungarian descent |
September 21
|
| Danes to Danish people |
rename all |
September 14
|
| Category:Darlington Borough |
Rename Category:Darlington Borough to Category:Darlington (borough). This area of coverage is fairly muddled. Strongly drawn to using "County Durham" as the disambiguator (as per, for example, Category:People from Durham, County Durham), as suggested by many contributors. However weight of numbers has led me to adopt a form which keeps in sync with the main article |
September 8
|
| Category:Daughters of dukes; Category:Daughters of marquesses; Category:Daughters of earls |
Rename: |
September 29
|
| Deans of Lincoln |
Rename Category:Deans of Lincoln since 1908 to Category:Deans of Lincoln Cathedral |
September 11
|
| Category:Degrees |
merge |
September 19
|
| Category:Descriptive technique |
No consensus. Looks like further discussion is certainly needed, and future deletion/merging should not be ruled out. |
September 15
|
| Category:Destroyer classes of the Netherlands |
Delete |
September 1
|
| Category:Directorial debut films |
'Keep |
September 5
|
| Category:Distillery F.C. players |
Close - the category is already under discussion further down the page and there should not be two concurrent discussions of the same category. Suggestions to merge can be made at the first discussion. Non-admin close |
September 23
|
| Category:Distillery F.C. players |
Merge into Category:Lisburn Distillery F.C. players |
September 23
|
| Category:Divisions by country |
Rename: |
September 6
|
| Category:Divisions of the Military of Colombia |
Rename Category:Divisions of the Military of Colombia to Category:Divisions of Colombia as an interim measure, for consistency with parent category, pending cleanup of overall category tree |
September 6
|
| Dominicans |
rename |
September 23
|
| Category:Donkey Kong characters |
Delete |
September 5
|
| Category:Dragon Ball episodes |
Rename Category:Dragon Ball episodes to Category:Dragon Ball episode lists |
September 5
|
| Category:Early campaigners for LGBT rights |
merge |
September 9
|
| Category:Eco-terrorism |
Keep |
September 28
|
| Category:Ecology by country |
Keep |
September 5
|
| Category:Ecology by region |
no consensus |
September 6
|
| Category:Ecology of Africa |
Keep |
September 5
|
| Category:Ecology of the British Isles |
no consensus |
September 6
|
| Category:Ecology of the United States |
Keep |
September 5
|
| Category:Elektra Artists |
Merge |
September 30
|
| Category:Eloise television specials |
Speedy Delete. WP:CSD#G5 - creation of banned user in violation of ban |
September 5
|
| Category:English civil servants |
No Consensus. No point in disposing of this category in isolation from the Scottish and Welsh categories listed above |
September 4
|
| Category:Epics |
Rename to Category:Epic poems; |
September 24
|
| EPs categories |
no consensus |
September 21
|
| Category:Equatorial Guinean musicians |
Endorse |
September 4
|
| Escort carrier categories |
Rename all per nom |
September 30
|
| Category:European Professors |
Delete |
September 19
|
| Category:European Student Organizations |
Delete |
September 30
|
| Category:Extrasolar navboxes |
rename |
September 16
|
| Category:F class submarines |
Rename |
September 24
|
| Category:Families of Connecticut origin |
Rename Category:Families of Connecticut origin to Category:Connecticut families. Advise separate group nomination if editors wish to consider Category:American families by state and subcategories |
September 4
|
| Category:Famous signs |
Rename to Category:Individual signs. While there are different opinions on what this category should be called, there is clearly consensus to rename it from the current name. The original proposed name seems to have the strongest support among the different suggestions |
September 27
|
| Category:Fantasy conventions |
withdrawn. As a result of the cleanup, re purposing and parent changes, there is no longer a need to rename this |
September 15
|
| Category:Fast-food sub restaurants |
Rename to Category:Submarine sandwich restaurants |
September 25
|
| Category:Federal Correctional Institution, Texarkana inmates |
Merge Category:Federal Correctional Institution, Texarkana inmates to Category:Prisoners and detainees of the United States federal government |
September 10
|
| Category:Female basketball players by century |
Merge Category:Female basketball players by century to Category:Basketball players by century |
September 9
|
| Category:Feyenoord Rotterdam |
Rename all per nom |
September 3
|
| Category:Fictional balls |
no consensus. This is a difficult naming issue. It looks like 1) there is no consensus to delete the category, 2) the category should be renamed to clarify its contents, and 3) there is no consensus on what the category should be called. It is unclear whether renaming to Category:Fictional spheres or Category:Fictional balls and spheres would solve the problem, or whether it would be appropriate at all given the current scope of the category. By all means relist the category for renaming if you can come up with a solution |
September 18
|
| Category:Fictional gay men |
Rename Category:Fictional gay men to Category:Fictional gay males |
September 27
|
| Category:Fictional prisoners |
keep |
September 23
|
| Category:Files by User:Bthomeldh |
Delete |
September 4
|
| Category:Film based Batman arcade and video games |
Rename Category:Film based Batman arcade and video games to Category:Arcade and video games based on Batman films |
September 29
|
| Category:Films set in the Vatican |
keep |
September 16
|
| Finns to Finnish people |
Rename all per nom |
September 13
|
| Category:First Mayors of Hamburg |
Rename |
September 23
|
| Category:Fitzpatrick's War |
delete |
September 19
|
| Category:FK Blāzma Rēzekne players |
Rename Category:FK Blāzma Rēzekne players to Category:SK Blāzma players |
September 4
|
| Category:Florida International Panthers baseball coaches |
Rename Category:Florida International Panthers baseball coaches to Category:Florida International Golden Panthers baseball coaches |
September 2
|
| Category:Fly films |
Delete |
September 2
|
| Category:Flying Saucer Masters |
deleted per G8. Empty category whose parent article does not exist, and thus serving no use right now (dependent on a deleted page) |
September 23
|
| Category:Folksonomy |
keep |
September 22
|
| Category:Football in Trinidad and Tobago by club |
Rename Category:Football in Trinidad and Tobago by club to Category:Footballers in Trinidad and Tobago by club |
September 2
|
| Category:Football League of Ireland |
Merge: |
September 20
|
| Category:Ford class aircraft carriers |
Rename |
September 29
|
| Category:Foreign Ministers of the German Democratic Republic |
Rename |
September 30
|
| Category:Formal systems |
Discussion moved to WT:WikiProject Logic |
September 20
|
| Category:Former drama schools |
Rename to Category:Defunct drama schools. |
September 14
|
| Category:Former Government officials of Hong Kong |
Merge Category:Former Government officials of Hong Kong to Category:Government officials of Hong Kong |
September 6
|
| Category:Former landmarks in Montreal |
Delete as empty. Otherwise I would have closed this discussion in favour of a rename to Category:Destroyed landmarks in Montreal. Having said that, there are substantial OR concerns here - described as a landmark by whom? An official body, or just randomly described as such by wikipedia editors? |
September 17
|
| Category:Former members of the Executive Council of Hong Kong |
merge |
September 9
|
| Category:Former members of the Legislative Council of Hong Kong |
Merge Category:Former members of the Legislative Council of Hong Kong to Category:Members of the Legislative Council of Hong Kong |
September 6
|
| French civil utility aircraft 1960-1969 |
Merge Category:French civil utility aircraft 1960-69 to Category:French civil utility aircraft 1960-1969 |
September 2
|
| French Redoutable classes of submarines |
rename |
September 22
|
| Category:Future aircraft carriers |
Merge; re-creation as a subdivision permitted if there is agreement outside of formal CfD or DRV processes to do so. |
September 30
|
| Category:Gardner-Webb Bulldogs football coaches |
Rename Category:Gardner-Webb Bulldogs football coaches to Category:Gardner-Webb Runnin' Bulldogs football coaches |
September 3
|
| Category:Gastronomy-related organizations |
Rename Category:Gastronomy-related organizations to Category:Gastronomical societies |
September 6
|
| Category:George and Victoria Cross Recipients |
Rename all |
September 5
|
| Category:Georgia election templates |
Speedily rename per criterion #6. |
September 4
|
| Category:Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets track players |
Rename Category:Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets men's track players to Category:Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets track and field athletes |
September 29
|
| Category:German monarchists in the Gernam Resistance |
speedily renamed |
September 28
|
| Category:Giant Records albums |
Merge per nom |
September 3
|
| Category:Girl albums |
Rename |
September 29
|
| Category:Gladio |
rename |
September 14
|
| Category:Godspeed You Black Emperor albums |
Rename Category:Godspeed You Black Emperor albums to Category:Godspeed You! Black Emperor albums |
September 5
|
| Category:Gotra |
Merge Category:Gotra to Category:Gotras |
September 5
|
| Category:Governors from Delaware |
Administrative close: already deleted. |
September 9
|
| Category:Governors of the Russian Federation |
Rename Category:Governors of the Russian Federation to Category:Heads of the federal subjects of Russia |
September 3
|
| Category:Grade B listed churches in London |
Merge Category:Grade B listed churches in London to Category:Grade II* listed churches in London |
September 5
|
| Category:Graduates of Oxford School of Drama |
Rename Category:Graduates of Oxford School of Drama to Category:Alumni of the Oxford School of Drama |
September 5
|
| Great American God-Out |
Administrative close: misplaced nomination. |
September 30
|
| Category:Great Northern Railway locomotives |
Rename Category:Great Northern Railway locomotives to Category:Great Northern Railway (Great Britain) locomotives |
September 7
|
| Great Northern Railway |
Rename the following: |
September 9
|
| Category:Greeks in Serbia |
Rename Category:Greeks in Serbia to Category:Serbian people of Greek descent |
September 7
|
| Category:Guayaquil (canton seat) |
Rename Category:Guayaquil (canton seat) to Category:Guayaquil |
September 7
|
| Category:Gyulay family |
Delete |
September 22
|
| Category:H anime |
Merge both to Category:Hentai anime and manga, without ruling out the possibility of changing "Hentai" in the future. |
September 16
|
| Category:Half-blind people |
Delete. This was a complicated discussion with good arguments on both sides, so I'll expand a little |
September 22
|
| Category:Hank Williams Sr. albums |
Rename Category:Hank Williams Sr. albums to Category:Hank Williams albums |
September 7
|
| Category:Haumea |
rename |
September 15
|
| Category:Haumeids |
speedily deleted by |
September 14
|
| Category:Healthcare in Brunei |
keep. – |
September 1
|
| Category:Heating devices |
Merge all per nom |
September 29
|
| Category:Hillsong original album covers |
Merge |
September 24
|
| Category:Historic derechos in Canada |
rename to Category:Derechos in Canada |
September 9
|
| Hockey players |
rename |
September 20
|
| Category:Holocaust survivors |
Keep per WP:SNOW |
September 15
|
| Category:Home Improvement |
delete |
September 23
|
| Category:Horse archer civilizations |
merge both into Category:Horse archer civilizations and empires |
September 29
|
| Category:Hotel Barges |
Rename as nominated |
September 28
|
| Category:House of Bourbon du Maine |
Rename Category:House of Bourbon du Maine to Category:House of Bourbon-Maine |
September 10
|
| Category:House of la Marck |
Merge all per nom |
September 29
|
| Category:Hungarian infobox templates |
speedy delete, G7 (sole author's request) |
September 21
|
| Category:Ice Cube CD covers |
Upmerge |
September 18
|
| Category:Illinois Auto Insurance Companies |
delete Category:Illinois Auto Insurance Companies. Since the only member is already in the parent, there is nothing to merge. Considering Category:Insurance companies based in Illinois, Closeapple has raised valid points in favour of keeping (and the situation has changed somewhat since arguments for its upmerging were made), and therefore I don't think there's consensus to merge it. If someone feels strongly about that one, they're free to start a separate CfD for it |
September 17
|
| Category:Image namespace templates |
Rename Category:Image namespace templates to Category:File namespace templates |
September 13
|
| Category:Immigration by continent |
Keep |
September 29
|
| Category:Impact craters by geologic time scale |
Rename Category:Impact craters by geologic time scale to Category:Impact craters on Earth by geologic time scale |
September 17
|
| Category:Impact craters by region |
Rename Category:Impact craters by region to Category:Impact craters on Earth by region |
September 17
|
| Indian Awards |
Rename all per nom |
September 10
|
| Category:Indian commercial capitals |
Delete all |
September 28
|
| Category:Indian Music Developers |
Rename Category:Indian Music Developers to Category:Indian record producers |
September 21
|
| Category:Indigenous inhabitant people in Hong Kong |
Rename Category:Indigenous inhabitant people in Hong Kong to Category:Indigenous inhabitants of the New Territories in Hong Kong |
September 8
|
| Category:Indios de Ciudad Juarez players |
rename |
September 19
|
| Category:Inductees of the Australian Rugby League Hall of Fame |
rename |
September 19
|
| Category:Inductees of the Brazilian Order of Scientific Merit |
rename |
September 19
|
| International rugby union footballers |
Speedy Rename: |
September 5
|
| Category:Invader Zim task force articles |
Delete |
September 17
|
| Category:IQ albums |
Rename Category:IQ albums to Category:IQ (band) albums |
September 10
|
| Category:Iranian Made Submarines |
rename |
September 20
|
| Category:Iraq war crimes |
Merge into Category:War crimes in Iraq |
September 24
|
| Category:Iron mining |
No consensus |
September 13
|
| Category:Islamic science |
Merge Category:Islamic science to Category:Islam and science |
September 10
|
| Category:Island at War |
delete |
September 23
|
| Category:IT Cities of India |
delete |
September 28
|
| Category:IT Industry in Durg district |
Delete |
September 19
|
| Category:IT parks in Kerala |
Merge Category:IT parks in Kerala to Category:Science parks in India |
September 19
|
| Category:IT Software Services companies |
Merge Category:IT Software Services companies to Category:Software companies |
September 19
|
| IT |
Rename: |
September 19
|
| Japanese submarine classes |
Rename all per nom |
September 9
|
| Category:Jazz rock albums |
Rename |
September 29
|
| Category:Jewish Theological Seminary alumni |
Rename |
September 24
|
| Category:Jhelum Cricketers |
Delete |
September 30
|
| Category:John Brogden and sons |
rename |
September 28
|
| Category:John Randolph of Roanoke |
Delete |
September 27
|
| Category:Journalists killed while covering the war in Afghanistan |
Rename Category:Journalists killed while covering the war in Afghanistan to Category:Journalists killed while covering the War in Afghanistan (2001–present)' |
September 7
|
| Category:Journey |
rename along with subcategories |
September 21
|
| Category:Judaism in the Czech Republic |
merge |
September 29
|
| Category:Julie Fowlis |
Rename Category:Julie Fowlis to Category:Julie Fowlis albums |
September 2
|
| Category:Kelli Dayton albums |
rename |
September 17
|
| Category:Kings of Naples |
no consensus. My impression is that this is the result, but it could also be a "do not merge". Since the practical result is the same I'm not too worried about which it is. It wasn't entirely clear if and to what extent some of those who commented were in agreement/acquiescence to Johnbod's comments made during the discussion. If they agreed with Johnbod, the merge should by consensus not proceed. If they were unconvinced, I didn't see any really good justifications that countered Johnbod's position, hence the "no consensus". |
September 29
|
| Category:Kings of Sicily |
Merge Category:Sicilian kings as nominated; do not merge Category:Kings of Sicily. |
September 29
|
| Kosovar things |
Rename/Merge per nom |
September 11
|
| Category:Kröd Mändoon and the Flaming Sword of Fire |
delete |
September 26
|
| Category:KwaZulu Natal geography stubs |
Speedy close. Relisted in its proper place at Wikipedia:Stub types for deletion |
September 9
|
| Kyrgyzstani |
Keep. Consensus seems to be in favour of 'Kyrgyzstani' as the appropriate adjectival form. Recommend further nomination to bring non-conforming categories into consistency |
September 26
|
| Category:L'Arc~en~Ciel members |
Rename |
September 26
|
| Category:La Monnaie companies |
Delete |
September 4
|
| Category:Languages of Pitcairn |
rename |
September 16
|
| Category:Law Enforcement Insignia |
Rename |
September 27
|
| Lesothan to Lesotho |
rename |
September 21
|
| Category:Liberal politicians |
Delete |
September 12
|
| Category:List of Capital MetroRail stations |
Rename Category:List of Capital MetroRail stations to Category:Capital MetroRail stations |
September 30
|
| Category:Lists of federal subject leaders |
Rename Category:Lists of federal subject leaders to Category:Lists of heads of the federal subjects of Russia |
September 3
|
| Category:Lists of films by technical issue |
Rename Category:Lists of films by technical issue to Category:Lists of films by technology |
September 5
|
| Category:Lists of Russian people |
keep |
September 15
|
| Category:Literary devices playing with meaning |
Merge Category:Literary devices playing with meaning to Category:Literary devices |
September 6
|
| Category:Lithuanian graphics |
Merge Category:Lithuanian graphics to Category:Lithuanian graphic designers |
September 7
|
| Category:Living museums in New York by county |
Speedy Delete. WP:CSD#G7 - At author's request |
September 5
|
| Category:Lois & Clark: The New Adventures of Superman episodes |
Delete |
September 12
|
| Category:Loopholes in Jewish law |
Merge Category:Loopholes in Jewish law to Category:Jewish law. No consensus to retain |
September 9
|
| Category:Lost fictional characters |
Delete |
September 8
|
| Category:Lost writers |
rename to Category:Writers of lost works |
September 9
|
| Category:Lotteries in the United States |
Keep |
September 25
|
| Malayalam-language films |
Keep all. (Potential conflict of interest here as I was responsible for creating these categories per 11 July Cfd. On the other hand, these creations were the result of clearly expressed consensus and I have made no other edits in this area.) Splitting 'films-by-language' categories into 'film-by-decade-by-language' seems, to me at least, to be the logical next step when wp coverage hits a certain critical mass. Perhaps this scheme might with benefit be applied to various other 'films-by-language' categories, but aside from qualms about its isolated application to this language, there seems to be little expressed consensus against it as a general idea |
September 27
|
| Category:Members of the Democratic Party (Romania) |
rename |
September 21
|
| Category:Mertozoro |
Delete |
September 6
|
| Category:Metropolitan Borough of Walsall |
merge |
September 8
|
| Category:Michael Jackson's death |
merge |
September 21
|
| Category:Middle-earth horses |
No Consensus |
September 21
|
| Category:Military personnel killed in action |
No Consensus |
September 7
|
| Category:Military personnel of the Afghanistan War |
Rename all per nom |
September 7
|
| Category:Military supply |
Merge Category:Military supply to Category:Military logistics |
September 29
|
| Category:Millenium |
Delete Category:Millennium and Category:Millennium episode redirects to lists. Rename the other two as nominated. |
September 8
|
| Category:Minor League Teams |
Merge (category was empty at close) |
September 18
|
| Category:Missing submarines of WWII |
rename |
September 8
|
| Mixed martial arts fighters |
Rename all per nom |
September 20
|
| Category:Mobile game companies |
Rename |
September 20
|
| Category:MODO Hockey players |
speedy rename. No need to list here if you've already listed it under speedy |
September 20
|
| Category:Moldejazz |
delete |
September 14
|
| Category:Monk episodes of season 1 |
Merge: |
September 30
|
| More Swedes |
rename/merge as proposed |
September 21
|
| Category:Mountain bike races and events in the United Kingdom |
Rename Category:Mountain bike races and events in the United Kingdom to Category:Mountain biking events in the United Kingdom |
September 7
|
| Category:Mountain bike races and events in the United States |
Rename Category:Mountain bike races and events in the United States to Category:Mountain biking events in the United States |
September 7
|
| Category:Mountain bike trails in Wales |
rename |
September 20
|
| Category:Mountain biking by nation |
rename |
September 21
|
| Category:Mountain biking events at Summer Olympics |
rename to Category:Mountain biking at the Olympics |
September 21
|
| Category:Mountain biking in Australia |
Keep |
September 7
|
| Category:Mountain biking magazines and journalists |
rename |
September 20
|
| Category:Mountain biking races and events |
rename all |
September 20
|
| Category:Mountain biking resorts, venues and trails in the United States |
Rename Category:Mountain biking resorts, venues and trails in the United States to Category:Mountain biking venues in the United States |
September 7
|
| Category:Mountain biking venues in the United Kingdom |
Close per WP:SNOW and the functional withdrawal of the nomination by the nominator. NAC |
September 7
|
| Category:Mountain biking venues |
Close per WP:SNOW and the functional withdrawal of the nomination by the nominator. NAC |
September 7
|
| Category:Museums and galleries in Melbourne |
Rename to Category:Art museums and galleries in Melbourne. Someone will need to cleanup the contents based on this rename |
September 29
|
| Category:Museums in New York County, New York |
Merge Category:Museums in New York County, New York to Category:Museums in Manhattan |
September 6
|
| Myanmar again |
Rename |
September 30
|
| Category:National Lacrosse League Hall of Fame |
Rename Category:National Lacrosse League Hall of Fame to Category:National Lacrosse League Hall of Fame inductees |
September 19
|
| Category:Neighborhoods in New Rochelle, New York |
Merge |
September 29
|
| Category:Neo-Nazis |
SPEEDY CLOSE. Two days later and this category has still not been tagged, nor has its subcategories been addressed. Add to that the WP:POINT issue and there is no reason for this to continue |
September 17
|
| Category:Neo-Stalinism |
keep |
September 15
|
| Category:Neo-Stalinists |
keep |
September 15
|
| Category:New York Giants (baseball) players |
Rename Category:New York Giants (baseball) players to Category:New York Giants (NL) players |
September 3
|
| Category:New Zealand albums by artist |
Merge Category:New Zealand albums by artist to Category:New Zealand albums |
September 28
|
| Category:Newspaper business |
Merge Category:Newspaper business to Category:Newspaper publishing |
September 3
|
| Category:Newspapering by year |
Rename Category:Newspapering by year to Category:Newspaper endorsements |
September 3
|
| Category:NKT Lamas |
rename |
September 20
|
| Category:Non-free Wikipedia files |
Keep |
September 12
|
| Category:Nonwar armed confrontations |
Delete |
September 7
|
| Category:Nordic folklore |
No Consensus |
September 26
|
| Category:North American Science Fiction Conventions |
rename to Category:North American Science Fiction Convention |
September 15
|
| Category:NPSL Seasons |
Rename |
September 30
|
| Category:NZ Art Guild Artists |
Delete |
September 30
|
| Category:Object-based programming languages |
Withdrawn by nominator |
September 29
|
| Ogg files by Wikipedians |
Delete |
September 17
|
| Ohio State University Buckeyes |
rename |
September 20
|
| Category:OKW |
Rename Category:OKW to Category:Alumni of King William's College - unless, that is, there is more to the alumni of King William's College than meets the eye |
September 21
|
| Category:Old Testament Hebrew words and phrases |
Renaming |
September 10
|
| Category:Olympic villages |
Rename Category:Olympic villages to Category:Olympic Villages |
September 6
|
| Category:One songs |
Rename |
September 26
|
| Category:Operas set in America |
Rename Category:Operas set in America to Category:Operas set in North America |
September 13
|
| Category:Organized crime groups |
Merge: |
September 29
|
| Paralympic medalists for Ukraine |
speedy merge/rename |
September 16
|
| Category:Paris Saint-Germain FC |
Rename all |
September 23
|
| Category:Parish Churches in Hertfordshire |
Administrative close since category has already been deleted under G7 |
September 30
|
| Parkour |
Rename/merge as nominated |
September 30
|
| Category:Parthenon Sculptures Reunification Organizations |
delete (in closing, will merge to Category:Art and cultural repatriation as suggested). |
September 30
|
| Category:Patinodromes |
rename to Category:Inline speed skating venues |
September 19
|
| Category:Patriots of Latvia |
Delete |
September 4
|
| Category:PDL Seasons |
Rename |
September 30
|
| Category:Pending deletions |
delete |
September 16
|
| Pendulum categories |
rename all |
September 12
|
| Category:People by high school in the United States |
Keep |
September 30
|
| Category:People from Bishop, California |
keep |
September 24
|
| Category:People from Kirkland, Montreal |
Rename Category:People from Kirkland, Montreal to Category:People from Kirkland, Quebec |
September 11
|
| Category:People repressed for educating African Americans |
Delete |
September 30
|
| Persian Gulf |
Merge Category:Persian Gulf states and Category:Arab states of the Persian Gulf into Category:Persian Gulf countries |
September 26
|
| Category:Philippine political scandals |
Rename Category:Philippine political scandals to Category:Political scandals in the Philippines |
September 5
|
| Category:Philosophical traditions |
No Consensus |
September 27
|
| Category:Phineas Taylor Barnum |
delete |
September 23
|
| Category:Physical property |
Merge Category:Physical property to Category:Physical quantities |
September 29
|
| Category:Places formerly in Lancashire |
delete |
September 8
|
| Category:Places historically in Berkshire |
Listify. It is clear that this information is in fact encyclopedic and should exist in a way to aid article navigation. Categories are not the solution due to the complexity of presenting this information in a way that educates. While a list exists, it does not come close to covering all of the articles included in the category. So these need to be added to the list |
September 30
|
| Category:Plays for one performer |
Withdrawn by nominator. NAC |
September 24
|
| Playwrights |
Merge: |
September 19
|
| Category:Poland–Czech Republic relations |
Merge: |
September 5
|
| Category:Poles from Zaolzie |
Rename Category:Poles from Zaolzie to Category:Polish people from Zaolzie |
September 7
|
| Category:Policy against illegal drugs |
Merge Category:Policy against illegal drugs to Category:Drug policy |
September 12
|
| Category:Polish doctors |
Merge |
September 27
|
| Polish political parties |
Rename: |
September 16
|
| Category:Polish refugees and Category:Polish emigrants |
Keep |
September 27
|
| Category:Political positions of vice presidents of the United States |
Rename Category:Political positions of vice presidents of the United States to Category:Political positions of Vice Presidents of the United States |
September 6
|
| Category:Political treaties |
No Consensus |
September 1
|
| Category:Pop rap albums |
Delete. If the concept cannot satisfy WP:OR as an article then the presumption must overwhelmingly be against its separate retention as a category |
September 11
|
| Category:Pope Pius XII authors |
Delete |
September 8
|
| Category:Pornographic sub-genres |
Merge |
September 29
|
| Category:Possible impact craters |
Rename Category:Possible impact craters to Category:Possible impact craters on Earth |
September 1
|
| Category:Presidential museums in Arkansas |
Upmerge and delete |
September 18
|
| Category:Prisoners at Lewisburg Federal Penitentiary |
merge |
September 23
|
| Category:Private Meteorological companies |
rename |
September 9
|
| Professors |
Merge: |
September 19
|
| Protestant Christianity to Protestantism |
Rename all |
September 22
|
| Category:Protests in the People's Republic of China |
RESOLVED and WITHDRAWN |
September 29
|
| Category:Publications by interest |
No Consensus |
September 29
|
| Category:Puerto Rican murderers |
Keep as part of existing category tree. Though no examples were presented here, unconvicted criminals should emophatically not be categorised in this tree, nor in any other 'criminals-by-nationality'. cf Wikipedia:Categories_for_discussion/Log/2009_July_29#Criminal_categories_implying_POV |
September 27
|
| Category:Pure Reason Revolution |
Rename |
September 29
|
| Category:Quebecois patriotic songs |
no consensus |
September 14
|
| Category:Québécois websites |
rename to Category:Quebec websites |
September 14
|
| Category:Railway stations in Baghelkhand Region |
Delete all |
September 29
|
| Category:Railway stations in Indore |
delete |
September 28
|
| Category:Ram Sampath |
delete |
September 18
|
| Category:Reboot films |
keep |
September 23
|
| Category:Redcar and Cleveland Borough |
Rename Category:Redcar and Cleveland Borough to Category:Redcar and Cleveland |
September 8
|
| Category:Redirects from alternative but more complete names |
speedy delete G8 (category populated by a retargeted template) |
September 28
|
| Category:Registered Historic Districts |
Rename all |
September 12
|
| Religious converts clean-up |
Rename all per nom (using Evangelicalism) |
September 10
|
| Remainder religious converts |
merge. There is clearly consensus here that categories by these names should not exist, and no consensus to rename them. Further creation of subcategories can be done after the merger if needed. The point about whether conversion should equate to "former" is out of the scope of this discussion; the point applies to everything in Category:People by former religion, so I suggest raising the issue there |
September 10
|
| Revisit - Category:Fictional characters by origin |
Keep all |
September 3
|
| Category:Rhythmic AC stations |
Rename Category:Rhythmic AC stations to Category:Rhythmic adult contemporary radio stations |
September 10
|
| Category:Roman toponymy |
Merge Category:Roman toponymy to Category:Latin place-names |
September 29
|
| Category:Ruling clans of India |
Rename Category:Ruling clans of India to Category:Dynasties of India |
September 1
|
| Category:Russia–Senegal relations |
Merge Category:Russia–Senegal relations to Category:Bilateral relations of Russia and Category:Bilateral relations of Senegal |
September 14
|
| Scenographs |
Rename all per nom |
September 7
|
| Scholars and academics |
Merge: |
September 19
|
| Category:Science fiction series navigational boxes |
Rename Category:Science fiction series navigational boxes to Category:Science fiction series templates |
September 29
|
| Scots to Scottish people |
rename all |
September 28
|
| Category:Scottish civil servants |
keep |
September 4
|
| Category:Second Boer War killed in action |
Rename Category:Second Boer War killed in action to Category:Military personnel killed in the Second Boer War |
September 6
|
| Category:Second-party video game developers |
Delete |
September 14
|
| Category:Sega Genesis game covers |
Merge Category:Sega Genesis game covers to Category:Mega Drive game covers |
September 29
|
| Category:Self constructs |
Merge Category:Self constructs to Category:Conceptions of self |
September 29
|
| Category:Semi-Prequel films |
merge |
September 16
|
| Category:Serbian alternative rock bands |
Rename |
September 24
|
| Ships of South Korea |
Rename per nom |
September 2
|
| Category:Shipwrecks of NSW |
Rename |
September 29
|
| Category:Shopping centers by year of establishment |
rename |
September 20
|
| Category:Shōhō class aircraft carriers |
Rename |
September 26
|
| Category:Simferopol Wikipedians |
Delete. Descent is much less useful information than either place of residence or nationality/ethnicity |
September 4
|
| Category:Sindhi |
Merge; after-close clean-up will be appropriate |
September 30
|
| Category:Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence |
Delete |
September 8
|
| Category:Sociological Research Companies of Ukraine |
No Consensus |
September 19
|
| Category:Software performance optimization |
rename to Category:Software optimization. While it is outside the scope of this nomination, it may be worth considering renaming the main article itself to Software optimization (currently a redirect to Program optimization). – |
September 1
|
| Category:Songs written by Ben Hayslip |
Delete; I also considered the comments in the related CfD below. This seems to be in line with past precedent for artists and producers of music |
September 25
|
| Category:Songs written by Cory Batten |
Delete |
September 25
|
| Category:Songs written by Giorgio Moroder |
Keep |
September 29
|
| Category:Southwest Indian cyclone seasons |
Rename to Category:Southwest Indian Ocean cyclone seasons. I see a consensus to add "Ocean", but I see no consensus on adding "-ern" or on making it "South-West". |
September 15
|
| Category:Southwest Indian cyclones |
Rename, except for the last one. I'm going to rename all but the last one as nominated, largely for the sake of consistency with the previous CfD on this issue and so we can get the issue of adding "Ocean" out of the way, since there is consensus that that at least needs to be done. However, I think |
September 22
|
| Spaniards to Spanish people |
rename all |
September 16
|
| Category:Speed skating venues |
keep |
September 19
|
| Category:Spin City |
Delete |
September 23
|
| Category:Sports scandals |
Merge Category:Sports scandals to Category:Sports controversies |
September 17
|
| Category:Sports teams by origin of their name |
delete |
September 21
|
| Category:St. John's University |
Rename |
September 16
|
| Category:Sub Urbs in Bhopal City |
delete |
September 28
|
| Subcats of Category:Racecar drivers by century |
Delete/Merge per nom |
September 11
|
| Submarines by navy |
Rename all. |
September 24
|
| Category:Suburban Noize Records Compilation Albums |
Merge Category:Suburban Noize Records Compilation Albums to Category:Suburban Noize Records albums |
September 13
|
| Category:Summer Set albums |
Rename Category:Summer Set albums to Category:The Summer Set albums |
September 26
|
| Category:Super NES-only games |
Rename Category:Super NES-only games to Category:Super Nintendo Entertainment System-only games |
September 8
|
| Category:Supervalu |
rename |
September 20
|
| Category:Surface transit in the Baltimore Metropolitan Area |
Merge Category:Surface transit in the Baltimore Metropolitan Area to Category:Maryland Transit Administration |
September 29
|
| Category:Survivors (aircraft) |
rename as nominated |
September 14
|
| Swedes to Swedish |
Rename all per nom |
September 5
|
| Category:Swiss authors |
Merge |
September 18
|
| Swiss people |
Rename: |
September 7
|
| Category:Syriac people |
no consensus |
September 29
|
| Category:Systems of formal logic |
No Consensus |
September 18
|
| Category:Tamil Community Organizations |
Merge both to Category:Tamil organisations |
September 30
|
| Category:Tech Chinization |
delete |
September 19
|
| Category:Technical University of Madrid |
Rename |
September 23
|
| Category:Television by topic |
Rename Category:Television by topic to Category:Television programming by topic |
September 28
|
| Category:Television reboot |
delete |
September 22
|
| Category:Thames-Coromandel |
rename |
September 20
|
| Category:The Cleveland Show |
Delete. (Category:The Cleveland Show episodes: Season 1 also deleted as an empty category.) |
September 28
|
| Category:The Davis Sisters songs |
Rename Category:The Davis Sisters songs to Category:The Davis Sisters (country band) songs |
September 12
|
| Category:The Unforgettable Fire |
Delete |
September 26
|
| Category:The Wild Wild West |
Delete |
September 11
|
| Category:The Worm Ouroboros characters |
Delete |
September 8
|
| Category:Theatre redirects |
Delete |
September 5
|
| Category:Trainboy12 |
Delete |
September 6
|
| Transgender people and behavior |
Merge |
September 26
|
| Category:Treaties involving territorial changes |
Self-withdrawal; I agree with Otto's point and am willing to work on implementing this distinction manually. |
September 1
|
| Category:Trevi |
Delete |
September 5
|
| Category:Trilateral |
delete |
September 9
|
| Category:Type XVIIB U-boats |
merge |
September 22
|
| Category:Types of degrees offered in the United States |
Rename Category:Types of degrees offered in the United States to Category:Academic degrees of the United States iot conform with category tree - any proposed changes to naming should properly apply to the whole tree and form the basis of a separate nomination |
September 19
|
| U-boats by conflict |
Merge: |
September 11
|
| Category:U.S. state halls of fame |
Rename Category:U.S. state halls of fame to Category:State halls of fame in the United States |
September 26
|
| Category:UEFA Cup 1993-94 |
Rename all per nom |
September 29
|
| Category:Ultra Nate albums |
rename |
September 15
|
| Category:United Kingdom city councils |
delete |
September 24
|
| Category:Universities and colleges in NOIDA |
Rename Category:Universities and colleges in NOIDA to Category:Universities and colleges in Noida |
September 21
|
| Category:Universities and Higher Education in Brazil |
Delete |
September 9
|
| Category:University at Buffalo |
Rename Category:University at Buffalo to Category:University at Buffalo, The State University of New York |
September 1
|
| Category:University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee |
merge |
September 16
|
| Category:Université de Moncton alumni |
Reverse merge to Category:Université de Moncton alumni. The only argument for merging to the "non-Frenchified" name is so that it will match the main article. The Frenchified name is certainly the university's legal name and the one that is used most commonly, at least within New Brunswick and the rest of Canada. If in process of time the proposed move of the main article is rejected, then I think it could be entirely appropriate to re-nominate this category for naming back to the non-Frenchified version. We could have held this in abeyance to await the result of the article move discussion, but that is not to be preferred since currently we have two different categories for one concept. Better to get this resolved one way or the other, even if it's only temporary. Anyway, the parent category Category:Université de Moncton and the sibling category Category:Université de Moncton faculty both use the Frenchified version, so this is at least bringing some consistency within the category system. I'm also willing to go out on a limb and say that I'm relatively confident the article will be moved. Probably. If I turn out to be wrong, you can all force me to drink motor oil. Again. |
September 29
|
| Category:Unsolved problems in philosophy |
merge to Category:Philosophical problems |
September 22
|
| Category:US Army All-American football players |
Rename Category:US Army All-American football players to Category:U.S. Army All-American football players |
September 1
|
| Category:USAF Organizations in Korea |
 Relisted at 2009 OCT 19 CfD. |
September 30
|
| Category:User Music Macro Language-0 |
Delete |
September 4
|
| Category:User Music Macro Language-N |
Delete |
September 4
|
| Category:Users who can't stand rap music |
Delete |
September 4
|
| Category:Users who likes The X-Files |
Merge Category:Users who likes The X-Files to Category:Wikipedians who like The X-Files |
September 4
|
| Category:V class destroyers |
rename to Category:Greek V class destroyers. – |
September 1
|
| Category:Venerable people |
Merge to Category:Venerated Catholics; further nominations likely needed to resolve the situation |
September 22
|
| Category:Victims of Communist repressions in China |
delete |
September 14
|
| Category:Video game reboots |
Delete |
September 21
|
| Category:Vietnam War aircraft carriers of Australia |
Delete |
September 28
|
| Category:Washington & Jefferson football coaches |
merge |
September 17
|
| Category:Watchmovement manufacturers |
rename Category:Watchmovement manufacturers to Category:Watch movement manufacturers |
September 17
|
| Category:Watch_RTE_outside_Ireland |
Speedy Delete. WP:CSD#G11 - Advertising or promotion |
September 6
|
| Category:We Will Rock You (musical) |
merge |
September 17
|
| Category:Welsh civil servants |
keep |
September 4
|
| Western (genre) films |
Rename. The question that really needs to be answered in the discussion is wether or not Western films is ambiguous. While Western is ambiguous, it has not been established in the discussion that Western films is ambiguous. In fact I think that the case it made that this is in fact not ambiguous. Whatever case might be made for this being ambiguous needs to be considered with this being the WP:PRIMARYTOPIC. No case has been made that Western films is ambiguous or not the primary topic. If you look at the main articles associated with this area, Western (genre), Western fiction, Westerns on television, disambiguation is only used when no other term is included to clarify the purpose of the article. I believe that principal applies here as well. Given that the lead in Western (genre) is consistant in using Western over western I believe that the categories should follow that in the naming. I'll also add that over on commons they use Category:Westerns |
September 29
|
| Category:Western short stories |
Rename |
September 18
|
| Category:WFAN |
delete |
September 16
|
| Category:White African footballers |
Keep |
September 9
|
| [[:Category:White Muslims ==== ]] |
Delete |
[[Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2009 September 4#Category:White Muslims ==== |September 4]]
|
| Category:Wikipedia bus watchers |
Delete |
September 4
|
| Category:Wikipedia sockpuppets of Alan Davie Bob Botha |
Merge Category:Wikipedia sockpuppets of Alan Davie Bob Botha to Category:Wikipedia sockpuppets of Elspeth Monro |
September 17
|
| Category:Wikipedia users with Gaia online accounts |
Delete |
September 4
|
| Category:Wikipedian singer-songwriters |
Delete |
September 16
|
| Wikipedians from Nelson |
Delete |
September 4
|
| Category:Wikipedians in Ozolnieki municipality |
Merge Category:Wikipedians in Ozolnieki municipality to Category:Wikipedians in Latvia |
September 9
|
| Category:Wikipedians in Russell, Ontario |
delete |
September 15
|
| Category:Wikipedians interested in Apocalyptica |
Delete |
September 4
|
| Category:Wikipedians who likes Millennium |
Delete |
September 4
|
| Wikipedians who use AlltheWeb |
Delete |
September 4
|
| Category:WikiProject Final Fantasy members |
Delete |
September 3
|
| Category:Wild Beast class destroyers |
rename. – |
September 1
|
| Winners of All-Ireland medals by count (football) |
delete, with subcategories |
September 19
|
| Category:Wolf albums |
Rename |
September 18
|
| Category:World War II escort carriers of the United Kingdom |
withdrawn to open broader discussion. — |
September 28
|
| Category:Worldcon Guests of Honor |
keep |
September 14
|
| Category:WPSL Seasons |
Rename |
September 30
|
| Category:Yadkin Valley Wineries |
merge into Category:North Carolina wineries |
September 22
|
| Category:YOURCODENAMEIS:MILO albums |
rename |
September 22
|
| Category:ZEDEPHIAN |
speedy deleted by Orangemike per G11 |
September 10
|
| Category:Ásatrú |
Merge |
September 26
|
