User:Estar8806/XfD log

This is a log of all deletion discussion nominations made by this user using Twinkle's XfD module.

If you no longer wish to keep this log, you can turn it off using the preferences panel, and nominate this page for speedy deletion under CSD U1.

February 2023

1. Criminal Minds (season 16); nominated at RM; New name: Criminal Minds: Evolution 16:56, 23 February 2023 (UTC)
   • Reason: WP:COMMONNAME per [1] this iteration has been referred to primarily by its subtitle and not as a sixteenth season of the original show.

March 2023

1. Kings Domain; nominated at RM; New name: Kings Domain, Melbourne 02:15, 15 March 2023 (UTC)
   • Reason: This title doesn't seem WP:PRECISE. "Kings Domain" could be a replacement for "Royal domain", which redirects to Crown land. Simply adding the city would disambiguate. Kings Domain (Melbourne) would also sufficiently accomplish this.
2. Queens Domain; nominated at RM; New name: Queens Domain, Hobart 02:16, 15 March 2023 (UTC)
   • Reason: This title doesn't seem WP:PRECISE. "Queens Domain" could be a replacement for "Royal domain", which redirects to Crown land. Simply adding the city would disambiguate. Queens Domain (Hobart) would also sufficiently accomplish this.
3. Carlota of Mexico; nominated at RM; New name: Charlotte of Belgium 20:42, 15 March 2023 (UTC)
   • Reason: Per WP:CONSORTS, she was born Marie Charlotte of Belgium, generally shortened to Charlotte of Belgium. Charlotte of Belgium has also been slightly more common than Carlota of Mexico as demonstrated by this Ngram: [2].
4. Hamburg Parliament; nominated at RM; New name: Bürgerschaft of Hamburg 02:33, 17 March 2023 (UTC)
   • Reason: Per WP:CONSISTENT. All other titles for the legislatures of German states us e their German name.

April 2023

1. Coronation of George II of Great Britain and Caroline; nominated at RM; New name: Coronation of George II and Caroline 19:44, 23 April 2023 (UTC)
   • Reason: There's no need for the title to be this long (WP:CONCISE). Every other coronation article is titled "Coronation of {Monarch} and {Consort}" ("Consort" where applicable), so WP:CONSISTENT applies here too.
2. Camilla, Queen Consort: nominated at RM; New name: Queen Camilla 21:30, 29 April 2023 (UTC)
   • Reason: I intended to open this RM earlier with the intent that it be closed by the day of the coronation, but I have arrived a little late. Regardless, “Queen Camilla” has become the WP:COMMONNAME of the subject, being used by reliable sources such as CNN [3], People [4], Vogue [5], and ABC [6]. Most importantly, gov.uk has referred to her by said name [7] and she has been referred to as just “The Queen” in the coronation liturgy [8]. And of course, all this supports the long held presumption that she will just be “The Queen” and “Queen Camilla”, post coronation. Less than a week out from that date, I see no reason to not follow the changes sources have made. Cheers!

May 2023

1. Henrietta Maria; nominated at RM; Henrietta Maria of France 00:00, 10 May 2023 (UTC)
   • Reason: Per WP:CONSORTS and the general format "{Name} of {Place}" for deceased queens and empresses consort. "Henrietta Maria of France" also has more page views than the actual target [9].
2. Duke of Marlborough (title); nominated at RM; Duke of Marlborough 01:53, 15 May 2023 (UTC)
   • Reason: The status of the 1st Duke of Marlborough as the WP:PRIMARYTOPIC is weak. The present (12th) Duke frequently ranks above the 1st Duke in pageviews. [10]
3. List of dignitaries at the state funeral of Elizabeth II; nominated at RM; List of guests at the state funeral of Elizabeth II 03:09, 29 May 2023 (UTC)
   • Reason: To be WP:CONSISTENT with other articles of similar nature (namely List of guests at the coronation of Charles III and Camilla). Further, it's sufficient to say that not every person mentioned is a "dignitary" by definition (using the Merriam-Webster definition of one who possesses exalted rank or holds a position of dignity or honor).

July 2023

1. Frederick Lewis Maitland (Royal Navy officer, born 1730): nominated at RM; New name: Frederick Lewis Maitland (died 1786) 19:14, 22 July 2023
   • Reason: Per WP:NCBIO - For historical figures for whom there is no dominant qualifier (at least no practical one), the descriptor may be omitted in favour of a single use of the date of birth or death. For historical figures, this will often be the date of death, when it is better known, more certain, or is more recognisable than their date of birth. The primary topic for Frederick Lewis Maitland was also a Royal Navy officer, so it's best to disambiguate by birth/death year (convention prefers the latter).
2. Wedding of Princess Elizabeth and Frederick V of the Palatinate: nominated at RM; New name: Wedding of Elizabeth Stuart and Frederick V of the Palatinate 22:57, 25 July 2023 (UTC)
   • Reason: boldly moved this a few days ago but it was moved back so let's go through the motions. First of all, Elizabeth Stuart, Queen of Bohemia was never "Princess Elizabeth" as children of the British sovereign were not known as Prince or Princess until the Hanoverians (with the exception of Prince William, Duke of Gloucester, though that could've been due to the fact he was a male-line descendant of the Danish monarch and thus a Prince of Denmark). In any case, WP:CONSISTENT would tell us to move the page to match with "Elizabeth Stuart".

August 2023

1. Anne Stuart (1637–1640): nominated at RM; New name: Anne Stuart (daughter of Charles I) 14:56, 7 August 2023 (UTC)
   • Reason: Per WP:CONSISTENT with Elizabeth Stuart (daughter of Charles I). Or, the other page should be moved to Elizabeth Stuart (1635–1650).
2. Prince Oscar Bernadotte: nominated at RM; New name: Oscar Bernadotte 04:00, 26 August 2023 (UTC)
   • Reason: Per WP:CONSISTENT and WP:COMMONNAME. On the first point, the other two princes of Sweden who married morganatically (Sigvard and Carl Johan Bernadotte) do not use the prefix "Prince". The three also shared the same two titles (Prince Bernadotte and Count of Wisborg) in the same country (technically, Luxembourg). In terms of COMMONNAME, "Oscar Bernadotte" is slightly preferred to "Prince Oscar Bernadotte" as demonstrated by ngrams [11].

September 2023

1. Charlene, Princess of Monaco: nominated at RM; New name: Princess Charlene of Monaco 18:48, 6 September 2023 (UTC)
   • Reason: First, sources are mixed as to whether Charlene's title is (Her Serene Highness) "Princess Charlene of Monaco" or "The Princess of Monaco". The official website for the princely family calls her "H. S. H. Princess Charlene".[12]. Furthermore, we tend to have the title before the name for living consorts, such as with Queen Silvia of Sweden. This is in line with WP:CONSORTS.
2. Princess Frederica of Prussia (1796–1850): nominated at RM; New name: Princess Frederica of Prussia 11:32, 7 September 2023 (UTC)
   • Reason: She was the only Prussian princess known as just "Frederica". The others were Princess Frederica Charlotte of Prussia and Princess Friederike Luise of Prussia. Any confusion between the three should be resolved by the hatnote to the dab page.
3. Vittorio Emanuele, Prince of Naples: nominated at RM; New name: ? 11:44, 7 September 2023 (UTC)
   • Reason: Almost none of the cited sources refer to him this way. A quick look through this article's references shows us he is called simply "Vittorio Emmanuele", "Vittorio Emmanuele di Savoia", and "Prince Victor Emmanuel". However, I'm unsure of which of these this should be moved to (if any).
4. Mary Peters (athlete): nominated at RM; New name: Lady Mary Peters 02:41, 10 September 2023 (UTC)
   • Reason: WP:NATURAL rather than parenthetical disambiguation. See related discussion at Talk:Elish Angiolini#Requested move 9 September 2023.
5. Prince Aimone, Duke of Aosta (born 1967): nominated at RM; New name: Prince Aimone, 6th Duke of Aosta 13:19, 10 September 2023
   • Reason: WP:NATURAL disambiguation. See similar discussions at Talk:Prince Amedeo, Duke of Aosta (1943–2021)#Requested move 10 September 2023 and Talk:Prince Emanuele Filiberto, Duke of Aosta (1869–1931)#Requested move 10 September 2023.
6. Marie Thérèse Louise of Savoy, Princesse de Lamballe: nominated at RM; New name: Marie Thérèse Louise of Savoy 28 September 2023 (UTC)
   • Reason: Present title is unnecessarily long, in violation of WP:CONCISE. The proposed title is also more WP:CONSISTENT under the guideline of WP:NCROY as most deceased royal women have article titles using their birth name. The proposed title is also a primary redirect, so there’s no ambiguity here.
7. Sophie of France (1734–1782): nominated at RM; New name: ? 28 September 2023 (UTC)
   • Reason: The present parenthetical disambiguation is unnecessary, particularly when there are several other viable options using WP:NATURAL disambiguation. I'm unsure which of these should be used: Madame Sophie would be consistent with one of her sisters, Madame Adélaïde (though personally I think that should be moved to Adélaïde of France, but we'll see what happens here first); Sophie of France, Duchess of Louvois or just Sophie, Duchess of Louvois (she held the title suo jure so it would be within WP:NCROY to use it).
     There's also the possibility of moving this to just Sophie of France with a hatnote for Sophie d'Artois and the redirect Sophie of France (1786-1787).

October 2023

1. Dan Goldman (politician): nominated at RM; New name: Dan Goldman 20:49, 5 October 2023 (UTC)
   • Reason: Clear WP:PRIMARYTOPIC by pageviews [13]. Fairly obvious long-term significance as a member of the US Congress and an actor in the impeachment proceedings against Donald Trump.
2. Jack Reed (Rhode Island politician): nominated at RM; New name: Jack Reed (politician) 00:50, 6 October 2023 (UTC)
   • Reason: Per WP:MISPLACED. Also could see an argument for treating the senators as the WP:PTOPIC given pageviews [[14]]
3. Death of Elijah McClain: nominated at RM; New name: Killing of Elijah McClain 17:47, 13 October 2023 (UTC)
   • Reason: Per WP:NCDEATHS as one officer has been convicted of "criminally negligent homicide" in his death [15].
4. NSW Liberal Party: nominated at RM; New name: New South Wales Liberal Party 02:54, 19 October 2023 (UTC)
   • Reason: For consistency with New South Wales Labor Party and New South Wales National Party. Also per WP:RECOGNIZABILITY.

November 2023

1. New Romantics (song): nominated at RM; New name: New Romantics 23:31, 11 November 2023 (UTC)
   • Reason: Per WP:DIFFPLURAL. New Romantic is a distinct topic. Ambiguity can be solved by a WP:HATNOTE.
2. Thomas Suozzi: nominated at RM; New name: Tom Suozzi 01:55, 28 November 2023 (UTC)
   • Reason: WP:COMMONNAME. About 174 sources in Google News use "Thomas Suozzi", while about 300 use "Tom Suozzi". [16][17]

January 2024

1. Christian, Crown Prince of Denmark (disambiguation): nominated at AfD; notified Wellington Bay (talk · contribs) 13:23, 14 January 2024 (UTC)
   • Reason: Unnecessary disambiguation page as WP:ONEOTHER.
2. Talk:Isabella II of Spain: nominated at RM; New name: Isabella II 22:33, 26 January 2024 (UTC)
   • Reason: Consistent with all of her successors (save for Amadeo I) and her predecessors Ferdinands VI and VII. Already a WP:PRIMARYTOPIC. Isabella II of Jerusalem is linked via hatnote.

February 2024

1. Sofía of Spain: nominated at RfD; Target: Queen Sofía of Spain (notified); notified SNIyer12 (talk · contribs) 22:54, 2 February 2024 (UTC)
   • Reason: Dabify - WP:NOPRIMARY. We should consider both pageviews and long-term significance. I would agree that Queen Sofía undoubtedly wins the latter factor, but she does not have consistently more pageviews than her granddaughter [18].
2. Emanuele Filiberto of Savoy, Prince of Venice: nominated at RM; New name: Emanuele Filiberto di Savoia (born 1972) 22:53, 3 February 2024 (UTC)
   • Reason: Or alternatively without the disambiguator. First off the proposed name (just "Emanuele Filiberto di Savoia") is the WP:COMMONNAME [19][20]. Second, WP:ABOUTSELF applies as the subject uses the proposed name [21]. Third, I fear that using titles in pretense for this branch of the House of Savoy and using surname format for the other claimants to the headship of the house (Aimone di Savoia Aosta (born 1967)) could appear as favoring the claim of this branch (possibly a NPOV issue).