User:ThaddeusB/PROD Log
Appearance
This is a log of my proposed deletion activity. It is manually maintained with script assistance. The list is not necessarily 100% accurate, but any errors are unintentional.
Articles I have proposed for deletion
[edit]2008
[edit]Date | Article | My reasoning | Result |
---|---|---|---|
December 15 | Strength and conditioning | article is merely a definition and is unlikely to be expandable in a meaningful way | deleted via PROD |
December 15 | Strength and conditioning coach | article is merely a definition and is unlikely to be expandable in a meaningful way | deleted via PROD |
2009
[edit]Date | Article | My reasoning | Result |
---|---|---|---|
January 13 | MattStyle | Appears to be a non-notable record label | deleted via PROD |
May 11 | Carolina Francessa De Cinca | No assertion of notability give, none found; not mentioned in Francisco Coronado & unreferenced -> possibly untrue/WP:HOAX | deleted via PROD |
May 16 | Cash taxes | little more than a dictionary definition that is unlikely to be expandable in any meaningful way | PROD contested; sent to AfD by me - the result of the discussion was delete (1-5-1) |
May 16 | Colot | pseudo disambiguation page with only 1 non-redlinked entry. | deleted via PROD |
May 17 | Campoy | Very difficult to figure out what is even trying to be said here; no evidence that any of the people mentioned are notable | deleted via PROD |
June 1 | Critical Mass (heavy metal band) | No indication of notability provided, none found - as the article says they only had one (unnamed) album and it was poorly received | deleted via PROD |
June 8 | Meatball Sandwich (single) | Most singles are not notable, and this one was "limited to 100 copies" and received no press coverage that I can find. Since it was a joint project between two bands there is no obvious target for a redirect | deleted via PROD |
June 8 | The World's Greatest Passenger | This is either a student production or a complete hoax, as IMDb doesn't even have a page for it and Google returns no hits of relevance. Either way, it clearly fails WP:NFILMS | deleted via PROD |
June 13 | Croquet whites | Not a widely used term (not mentioned in croquet article, few GHits) & no indication of notability | deleted via PROD |
June 17 | Fake Games | Incriminate list with poorly defined inclusion criteria | speedy deleted under A7 |
Articles which were proposed for deletion that I contested
[edit]April 2009
[edit]Date | Article | My reasoning | Result |
---|---|---|---|
April 23 | Owen Aaronovitch | current length is not valid reason for delete; subject seems minorly notable | source added by me |
April 23 | Darcy Turenne | subject appears to be notable | some cleanup by me; further cleanup by Severo |
April 24 | Nanoscale iron particles | subject appears to be notable | article cleaned up by DMacks; fluff/off-topic info trimmed by me with some rewriting as needed; wikified by me |
April 24 | Victaulic | company appears to be notable (tons of GNews hits for example) | article expanded into a proper stub by me |
April 25 | Hancock County High School | all high schools are considered notable | fixed up by me (originally article had insufficient context) |
April 25 | A+ Pollux | seems notable (for example, both lead actors are notable, studio is notable, etc.) | article de-orphaned by me |
April 25 | Hitman Pro | software is fairly widely used and thus probably notable | |
April 25 | Miss World 2010 | Miss World is clearly notable and the 2010 event has been announced so I see no reason not to have at stub about it | made into proper stub by me; expanded considerably by Tungdoan and others |
April 26 | Raphaël (JavaScript Library) | seems borderline | sent to AfD for further discussion (by me). Result of discussion was no consensus (3-3) |
April 26 | The Backwoodsman Magazine | magazine seems somewhat notable (although I agree the current article is horrible) | article rewritten for tone & wikified by me with two RS reviews of it added |
April 26 | Barbara McGuire | subject appears to be notable (for example has written a lot of books of the subject) | article massively expanded by me, using several reliable sources; text tweaked by others; a fact from it appeared in DYK |
April 26 | Gwyn Cready | author seems minorly notable (her books were mainstream review, for example) | |
April 27 | Selltis | seems to have some notability - see http://news.google.com/archivesearch?um=1&ned=us&hl=en&q=Selltis&cf=all | |
April 27 | Ladye Love Smith | the couple seems notable (for example singing at the super bowl) | moved to Reggie and Ladye Love Smith and overhauled by me with new sources |
May
[edit]Date | Article | My reasoning | Result |
---|---|---|---|
May 10 | Apple (automobile) | I am pretty sure the company is real at least | |
May 10 | Envirofit International | mentioned in the NY times [1] among other RS | Contentious claims trimmed by MalcolmMcDonald; some info restored & edited to verifiable bits by me; a little bit of new info added by me |
May 10 | Charles Fahlen | appears to be notable | none yet - I will attempt to clean up the article ASAP |
May 10 | Hannibal Penney | seems notable enough to at least warrant discussion | |
May 10 | Hare of Inaba | seems to be notable | none yet - I will rewrite article to address the issues ASAP |
May 10 | Medical Law International | appears to be notable | self-promotional bits cut & other clean-up by me |
May 10 | Perth Glory W-League season 2008-09 | article needs improvement (addition of prose), not deletion | article named, intro fixed, and article flagged fro needing more prose by me |
May 10 | Jerry Pritikin | appears to be notable -> has non-trivial coverage in multiple RS | |
May 10 | Cory Spedding | finishing 2nd in a contest "broadcast in 20 countries and viewed by 100 million people" is probably notable enough for a Wikipedia article | |
May 10 | Str8 Rippin | appears to be notable | has been revised, updated, and corrected by numerous IPs and registered editors |
May 10 | SuperPower | game is well-known and certainly not some "obscure computer game" | |
May 10 | WBUL (AM) | seems notable enough to at least warrant discussion | |
May 11 | Bully Hill Vineyards | appears to have suffient coverage in third party sources to meet our standards (http://news.google.com/archivesearch?um=1&ned=us&hl=en&q=%22Bully+Hill+Vineyards%22&cf=all) | |
May 11 | Karmacoda | band has been reviewed by multiple RS | minor cleanup by me; sourcing concerns not yet addressed |
May 11 | Phi Gamma Delta Epsilon Chapter | article is well done & possibly notable as the 2nd oldest chapter | |
May 12 | The Webstirs | has been reviewed by multiple RS (see http://news.google.com/archivesearch?um=1&ned=us&hl=en&q=%22The+Webstirs%22&cf=all) | none yet - will attempt to fix article issues ASAP |
May 13 | Apple Pie (band) | has been reviewed by multiple RS | tone fixed by Varbas, article still needs expanded |
May 13 | Charlene Dallas | finishing second in Miss America is probably enough | reference, category, and stub tag added by me |
May 13 | Impulse-based turn system | this is not a game guide, but rather an article about a type of gaming system | guide-ish stuff removed by me |
May 13 | 5th Ward Boyz | notable band that easily passes WP:MUSIC, for example, has been reviewed in multiple RS | |
May 13 | Audery Wasilewski | actor is quite notable when spelled correctly :) | article title fixed and made into proper stub by me; factoid added by an IP; further expansion is still needed |
May 13 | Cross Enterprise Document Sharing (XDS) | RS are out there, but a bit hard to find (this is usually called just XDS) | another user asked for sources on talk page, but no expansion yet - will expand ASAP |
May 13 | Jay Wade Edwards | it's a bit silly to call him just "a guy with a job" - he is editor & producer of a popular cartoon and has won two minor awards | none yet - will address sourcing concerns ASAP |
May 14 | Paul B Manning | the company is notable | none yet - will clean up and refractor into an article about the company instead of Manning ASAP |
May 14 | Stone Mountain Arts Center | has coverage in multiple RS | none yet - will clean up article ASAP |
May 14 | Séura | company has received coverage in multiple RS & has won some awards | none yet - will see about expanding it ASAP |
May 14 | Cisco Packet Tracer | product appears to be notable | article renamed, wikified, and cleaned-up by me; headers fixed by User:Michael Hardy; still needs expansion |
May 14 | East Hill Church | appears to be notable -> for example, a sermon was covered by ABCNews: http://abcnews.go.com/GMA/AmericanFamily/story?id=2576894&page=1 | |
May 14 | Free Land | I agree that there isn't much here, but the article is basically brand new & the book does appear to actually be notable, so give it some time to develop | |
May 14 | Rajeev Janardan | subject appears to be notable | article sent to AfD; Result of the discussion was keep (6-2); sources added by Zeborah and Pablomismo; article cleaned up and slightly expanded by Pablomismo. |
May 14 | Referendum 67 | nom's issue that a better article existed eternally was invalid | article renamed to better identify the subject by me; GFDL content copied from ballotpedia.org by me with fixed tenses & other minor changes |
May 15 | Chink Santana | appears to be a notable producer | |
May 15 | Aunt Dolly | surprisingly this minor character has actually been covered by multiple RS (probably b/c it is played by Dolly Parton) | article sent to AfD; Result of the discussion was redirect to List of Hannah Montana characters (0-0-4) |
May 16 | Quahog 5 | this article is primarily a sub-article of List of characters from Family Guy | I suppose it could be merged back, but it doesn't seems necessary |
May 16 | Suspended Animation Dreams | album has been reviewed by Allmusic and other reliable sources | links to reviews add by me |
May 16 | Gasoline (Seether song) | every Seether single has a page [& hit at least #13 on Modern Rock chart]; this one did less well than some, but probably is notable enough anyway | |
May 16 | John Hartung | subject's papers are widely cited (http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=%22John%20Hartung%22&oe=utf-8&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&client=firefox-a&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&hl=en&tab=ws [not all by him]) | none yet - will address article issues ASAP |
May 16 | Supreme Ruler 2010 | game is well-known & has been reviewed by dozens of RS | none yet - will address sourcing concerns ASAP |
May 17 | French & Raven's Five bases of Power | this is actually about a very notable study & is referenced (although only in general form, not with cites) | none yet - I will clean up the article to comply with Wikipedia standards ASAP |
May 17 | Larry Byrd | subject is real & actually pretty notable in & out of the ring | none yet - will expand the article & address sourcing concerns ASAP |
May 17 | Us and Them: The Science of Identity | book has been reviewed by multiple RS including The Guardian, Publishers Weekly, and many others | none yet - will expand article to address the sourcing & other concerns ASAP |
May 17 | Rustic Houses, Forlorn Valleys | album was reviewed by Allmusic, Melody Maker, and other RS | none yet - will expand article to address concerns ASAP |
May 17 | All American (video poker) | reason supplied (WP:DICTDEF does not apply & this does appear to be a notable variety of video poker | none yet - will expand the article ASAP |
May 18 | Walk In Da Park | "not needed" is not a valid reason to delete & album would appear to pass WP:NALBUMS | typos fixed & unreferenced+cleanup tags added by me |
May 18 | Charles C. Campbell | seems notable (has ~50 voice credits to his name, for example); also it wasn't actually tagged as unreferenced since 2006 - the date was faked | sources added by me |
May 18 | Sheldon Richman | he is a well-known author & journalist and thus notable | article sent to AfD; Result of the discussion was No Consensus (2-3); Bibliography added by an IP; references added by MegabyteModem |
May 18 | Obscurity (band) | albums have been reviewed by multiple reliable sources | some cleanup by Martarius; sourcing concerns not yet addressed |
May 19 | Church of the Holy Family, Singapore | this church seems to be notable as it has coverage in multiple RS | infobox greatly expanded by Ariedartin; sourcing concerns have not yet been addressed |
May 19 | Poverello Center | seems sufficiently notable to me | article sent to AfD; Result of the discussion was No Consensus (2-4) |
May 19 | Montezuma's Ferrari | books has received coverage in multiple RS | article copyedited by Md2 943; still needs further expanion & sourcing |
May 19 | Los Claxons | appears to have significant coverage in Spanish language sources | unlink band members & other minor cleanup by me |
May 19 | Coriole | this vineyard has been covered in RS aroudn the globe & won some significant awards | article sent to AfD; Result of the discussion was Keep (8-3-1); article overhauled by BodegasAmbite; additional references add by MichaelQSchmidt; minor expansion by FeydHuxtable |
May 19 | Lene Gammelgard | subject is the author of a notable book & and an accomplished writer | moved to correct spelling (Lene Gammelgaard) by me; some clean by me; reference added by Phil Bridger; expansion still needed |
May 19 | Alchimie Forever | product does appear to actually be notable (significant coverage in multiple RS) | article sent to AfD; Result of the discussion was Keep (3-3); article completely re-written and greatly expanded by me |
May 19 | Lars Fredrik Frøislie | subject appears to meet Wikipedia:Notability (music) criteria #6 since has been a member of 3 notable bands (that is, presumed to be notable since they have Wikipedia pages) | |
May 20 | The Cereal Bowl | company has received substantial 3rd party coverage - for example in the Miami Hearld alone: http://www.miamiherald.com/801/ | none yet - will expand article ASAP |
May 20 | Education for All Global Monitoring Report | report had received coverage in multiple realiable sources | none yet - will see what I can do about sourcing concerns ASAP |
May 20 | Tosca Reno | she is the author of a very notable book & has her own TV show | none yet - will address sourcing concerns+expand article ASAP |
May 20 | Real-time recovery | neologism doesn't apply here & the concept does appear to be a notable one | flagged for needing cleanup & references by me |
May 21 | Session wrestler | topic is notable - needs editing, not deletion | |
May 21 | Colio Estate Wines | appears to be a notable winery | none yet - will address sourcing concerns & re-write article for tone ASAP |
May 21 | Duplin Winery | appears to be a notable winery | none yet - will address sourcing/notability concerns ASAP |
May 21 | Fantesca Estate & Winery | appears to be a notable winery | none yet - will address sourcing/notability concerns ASAP |
May 21 | Fiddlehead Cellars | appears to be a notable winery | none yet - will address sourcing/notability concerns ASAP |
May 21 | Llano Estacado Winery | appears to be a notable winery | none yet - will address sourcing concerns, expand, & re-write article for tone ASAP |
May 21 | Gotham Comedy Club | club definitely appears to be notable | minor cleanup + tagging by me & Wvfunnyman; further cleanup is still needed |
May 21 | Valhalla Vineyards | appears to be a notable winery | some cleanup by Agne27; still needs sourcing |
May 21 | White Owl Winery | appears to be a notable winery | none yet - will address article concerns ASAP |
May 21 | International Review of Financial Analysis | appears to be a notable journal (articles are widely cited for example) | none yet - will see what I can do about expanding this to have some actual content ASAP |
May 22 | Summit Awards | these awards have received significant coverage (http://news.google.com/archivesearch?um=1&ned=us&hl=en&q=%22Summit+Awards%22&cf=allhttp://news.google.com/archivesearch?um=1&ned=us&hl=en&q=%22Summit+Awards%22&cf=all) | none yet - will source ASAP |
May 22 | Modern Materials Handling | magazine has a 60+ year history & is well known in the industry | fluff removed by User:Uncle G; article still needs expansion |
May 22 | Khin | appears to be a notable instrument | wikified, categories & stub tags added by me; will expand & reference ASAP |
May 22 | List of surgeons | seems to be a valid list topic | refractor into a better list by Uncle G |
May 22 | Corbin Billings | subject has non-trivial coverage in multiple realiable sources (ones linked to in article+others) | |
May 23 | Digital Command System | seems pretty well covered within the model train community | article sent to WP:AfD; content was BOLDly merged in Model train control systems by me |
May 23 | Trainmaster Command Control | seems pretty well covered within the model train community | article sent to AfD; Result of the discussion was keep (5-1) |
May 23 | Cut Throat Freak Show | has a good deal of coverage in Pheonix (http://www.phoenixnewtimes.com/search/?keywords=Cut%20Throat%20Freak%20Show) but not much beyond that - TV appearances are probably enough to establish notability | |
May 24 | Jack Passion | as silly as I think this is personally, he easily meets WP:GNG with tons of coverage in third party sources - one source calls him the "Michael Jordan of competitive beard growing" | article substantially expanded by Roaringryokan |
May 24 | Arschbombe | this is actually a serious sport in Germany apparently - see German Wikipedia & this article: http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2004/aug/12/sport.lukeharding (there are many more RS on this) | turned into a redirect by NuclearWarfare |
May 24 | EPrompter | has received non-trivial coverage in multiple RS | article sent to AfD; Result of the discussion was keep (4-1); sources added by American Eagle |
May 24 | Agent Ransack | has received non-trivial coverage in multiple RS | article sent to AfD; Result of Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Agent Ransack was delete (0-4, included a delete !vote from me) |
May 24 | Davkawriter | has received non-trivial coverage in multiple RS | article sent to AfD; Result of the discussion was keep (3-2); article still needs expansion and sourcing |
May 24 | Kacey Jones | subject does appear to be notable - see allmusic bio ([2]) for example | article userfied for expansion (not done yet) |
May 24 | Naked Fame | film was reviewed by the NY Times, Hollywood Reporter, LA Time & others | userfied for sourcing; sources added & article expanded by me; moved back to mainspace |
May 24 | Greg Handevidt | subject meets WP:BAND criteria #6 in that he "has been a member of two or more independently notable ensembles" | reference to Wikipedia removed & other minor cleanup by me; article sent to AfD; Result of the discussion was keep (2-1); |
May 24 | City Girls | appears to be a notable group | none yet - will address sourcing concerns ASAP |
May 25 | SVIST | all secondary schools are considered notable | cleaned up by me |
May 25 | Cryx | appears to be a legitimate sub-article of Iron Kingdoms with too much content to merge | |
May 25 | Ron Jones (businessman) | subject has received non-trivial coverage in multiple RS, including making The Guardian's top 100 media people in 2006 | minor cleanup by me; will expand & clean article ASAP |
May 25 | Sam Kantimathi | subject has made significant contributions to the game of Scrabble (and also some minor ones to his professional field) | none yet - will source & expand article ASAP |
May 25 | Pontotoc Warriors | all high schools are considered notable & this one doesn't have a page yet | moved to Pontotoc High School with rewrite/massive cleanup by me; article expanded by Ptownballer2 |
May 26 | FOK! | this is actually a very popular website in the Netherlands | non yet - will see what I can do about sourcing it ASAP |
May 26 | Andrew Harper, Travel Writer | the magazine itself is notable | moved to Andrew Harper's Hideaway Report with rewrite/massive cleanup; original title deleted as improbable redirect; still needs sourcing |
May 26 | Old Skool Love | this single charted pretty decently & won some awards | none yet - will expand article to reflect its notability ASAP |
May 26 | Mary Free Bed Rehabilitation Hospital | organization has a 100+ year history and has received non-trivial coverage in multiple RS on numerous occasions | expanded by Katesc and 209.153.151.50; could use some copy editing for tone |
May 26 | Water ball | seems to be a popular & notable product | made into proper stub by me; expanded by 94.194.221.72 |
May 26 | InterMapper | product has been reviewed by multiple RS | none yet - will expand article ASAP |
May 27 | Allie Ash | subject appears to meet the general notability guidelines as he has been covered by multiple RS | |
May 27 | The green school | all secondary schools are considered notable | moved to proper capitalization & rewrote into a proper stub by me |
May 27 | Qliktech | company has an international scope and has received coverage in multiple RS, additionally the article has survived WP:AfD before | moved by QlikTech International by me |
May 27 | Dr. Web | appears to be a very notable anti-virus software - page needs editing not deleting | minor expansion by Wikiwide and Q0k |
May 28 | Sean malto | subject is a notable skater (for instance see: [3]) | capitalization fixed by me; some minor cleanup by several IPs; still needs proper sourcing
|
May 28 | Lori Borgman | subject is a national syndicated columnist & author of a couple notable books | none yet - will expand article with better sources ASAP |
May 28 | Wave in Head | band has been reviewed by multiple RS | none yet - will address sourcing concerns ASAP |
May 28 | Linux XP | software has been covered by many RS | minor cleanup & sourcing by User:Widefox; article could use some more sources |
May 28 | HDS Retail | this is part of Hachette Distribution Services, a huge international company | moved to Hachette Distribution Services and refocused into proper stub by me |
May 28 | On My Way (deSoL) | this is a studio release by a notable band that has generated a few minor hits | not independently notable terms unlinked by me |
May 28 | Standard of Excellence | company behind the product is notable & doesn't have an article yet | moved to Neil A. Kjos Music Company & rewritten by me; categories & stub tag added by me |
May 29 | List of people on stamps of Batum | there isn't much here, but the problem is that this is a sub-list of the super huge List of people on stamps which is notable | none yet - some of the lists could probably be combined by geographical region or something |
May 29 | List of people on stamps of Burundi | there isn't much here, but the problem is that this is a sub-list of the super huge List of people on stamps which is notable | none yet - some of the lists could probably be combined by geographical region or something |
May 29 | List of people on stamps of Bushire | there isn't much here, but the problem is that this is a sub-list of the super huge List of people on stamps which is notable | none yet - some of the lists could probably be combined by geographical region or something |
May 29 | List of people on stamps of North Borneo | there isn't much here, but the problem is that this is a sub-list of the super huge List of people on stamps which is notable | none yet - some of the lists could probably be combined by geographical region or something |
May 29 | List of people on stamps of Oman | there isn't much here, but the problem is that this is a sub-list of the super huge List of people on stamps which is notable | none yet - some of the lists could probably be combined by geographical region or something |
May 29 | List of people on stamps of Palau | there isn't much here, but the problem is that this is a sub-list of the super huge List of people on stamps which is notable | none yet - some of the lists could probably be combined by geographical region or something |
May 29 | Stephen Polk | subject appears to meet WP:ENT | some cleanup by me; further cleanup and proper sourcing still needed |
May 30 | Jermaine Andrè | subject has been covered by multiple RS | none yet - will expand ASAP |
May 30 | Celebriducks | company/product has received significant coverage in many reliable sources | article userified for expansion & proper sourcing (not done yet) |
May 30 | Marshall Fritz | subject has non-trivial coverage in multiple RS & was influential to Libertarian though | none yet - will expand article ASAP |
May 30 | Wellspring camps | subject has non-trivial coverage in multiple reliable sources | none yet - will clean up article ASAP |
May 30 | London commuter belt | article doesn't seem that bad & an article of this size and history probably shouldn't be PRODed away | |
May 31 | Sandra P. Grant | appears to be minorly notable per coverage in Soap Central & being nominated for an award | article expanded slightlyby me |
May 31 | Ángel Sanzo | subject is notable per awards mentioned here and the non-trivial coverage found at GNews: http://news.google.com/archivesearch?um=1&ned=us&hl=en&q=%22%C3%81ngel+Sanzo%22&cf=all | none yet - will expand article ASAP |
May 31 | Zoltan Mesko (football) | has had a notable college career (as evidenced by awards noms) & easily meets WP:GNG | complete rewrite for NPOV and tone; still needs proper references |
May 31 | San Andreas: The Original Mixtape | despite the name, this is actually a studio album by an (apparently) notable artist | album cover added by XCore21 |
June
[edit]Date | Article | My reasoning | Result |
---|---|---|---|
June 1 | Service-oriented Software Engineering | concept is notable (for example entire books have been written on the subject) | none yet - will cleanup & expand article ASAP |
June 1 | Bloodhound (novel) | appears to be a notable book & should at least be merged with Tamora Pierce if not kept | some minor cleanup by me; article expanded by several IPs |
June 1 | Last Go Round | facts are easily verified & the books is notable as it has been reviewed by multiple RS | none yet - will expand article ASAP |
June 1 | Kolsimcha - The World Quintet | band has been reviewed by multiple RS (including the LA times) & been on an international tour - see http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22kol+simcha%22+klezmer&btnG=Search&um=1&ned=us&hl=en&scoring=a | categories added by an IP; still needs proper sourcing |
June 1 | Crossroads Plaza (North Carolina) | appears to a notable mall based on its size & the amount of RS coverage (http://news.google.com/archivesearch?um=1&ned=us&hl=en&q=%22Crossroads+Plaza%22+cary&cf=all) | link to official website added by me |
June 1 | Sławek Jaskułke | subject has extensive coverage in RS (see http://news.google.com/archivesearch?um=1&ned=us&hl=en&q=%22S%C5%82awek+Jasku%C5%82ke%22&cf=all) | added {{primary sources}} tag; will address sourcing concerns ASAP |
June 1 | Penarth Times | as the main newspaper of a fairly large town it is probably notable | add category & stub tags added by me; {{unreferenced}} tag add by me; some cleanup by me |
June 1 | The future laboratory | not much content here, but the company is notable | category & stub tag added by me; moved to correct title be me; still needs expansion & sourcing |
June 2 | Commerce Insurance Group | as the tagger said the subject is notable and needing a rewrite is not a reason for deletion | fluff removed & otherwise cleaned up by me; category & stub tags added by me |
June 2 | Neuropsychophysiology | term is widely used outside of the alleged inventor | trimmed to independently verifiable parts by me; some material added by me; external links of marginal value removed by me; categories added by me |
June 2 | Jeff Fischer (actor) | appears to be a notable voice actor | cleaned up and expanded by me with sourcing; could use some additional expansion |
June 2 | Philomena, Duchess of Vendôme | I am pretty sure all nobility are considered notable | sent to AfD, result of the discussion was no consensus (3-3-1); later changed into a redirect per consensus reached by AfD participants |
June 2 | Growthworks | company has received substantial 3rd party coverage & easily meets WP:GNG | categories added by me; could still use expanding |
June 3 | Midsommer (film) | film has been reviewed by multiple RS, won a Robert Award and was nominated for several others (Denmark's highest filming honor) | categories expanded by Lugnuts; still needs expansion & sourcing |
June 3 | Michael Meeks (software) | subject has been covered by multiple RS | minor corrections by several editors; still needs sourcing |
June 3 | Anna Demidova (dancer) | winning a spot on Dancing with the Stars almost certainly is enough by itself & her other achievements also indicate notability | some minor copy editing by Decltype; still needs referencing |
June 3 | MineWolf | company is notable & doesn't have an article yet so I will move this there & change the scope | moved to MineWolf Systems and refocus to be about the company rather than one product by me; expanded slightly by me; stub tag & categories added by me; still needs proper referencing and could use some expansion |
June 3 | Esnatech | company has non-trivial coverage in multiple RS | article cleaned up, referenced, and expanded by Ucommunicate; further expansion by 987mark; minor fixes by several users |
June 3 | California Farm Water Coalition | organization has received a lot of 3rd party coverage (a lot is trivial, but certainly not all) | minor corrections by several users; still need sourcing & expansion |
June 4 | Furman Stewart Baldwin | article is accurate & the subject is notable | none yet - will address sourcing concerns ASAP |
June 4 | Anugama | subject has been covered by multiple RS | link add to allmusic.com bio by me; some copyrighted material removed by Jfire; some minor expansion by Estrauch; still needs expansion |
June 5 | Jacob Appelbaum | subject has non-trivial coverage in multiple realiable sources (he is known more for his "citizen journalism" than hacking, but I have confirmed the two are the same person) | article sent to AfD; result of the discussion was no consensus (6-4); some minor improvements by several users; could use some expansion |
June 5 | Dichoptic presentation | a book search reveals that there is adequate sourcing available to expand on this topic (it is not surprising that there isn't much on the web about it since it is a specilized scientific term) | stub tag & category added by me |
June 5 | John Santerineross | actually the subject has received quite a bit of genre-specific coverage, which is sufficient to pass WP:GNG | article sent to AfD; result of the discussion was keep (5-1); broken references fixed by me; expansion POV cleanup & copy editing by me; wikified by me; a large portion of the content removed by Bigdaddy1981 (who started the AfD) as "unsourced"; content should be re-added with proper sources |
June 5 | Pantech PG-C300 | product has been covered/reviewed by multiple RS (for example, this CNET review: http://reviews.cnet.com/cell-phones/pantech-c300-at-t/4505-6454_7-31884398.html) | none yet - will source and expand ASAP |
June 6 | Mission Impossible (JTQ album) | album meets inclusion creteria because it has been reviewed by multiple RS | none yet - will expand/add reviews ASAP |
June 6 | The Money Spyder | album meets inclusion creteria because it has been reviewed by multiple RS | none yet - will expand/add reviews ASAP |
June 6 | Lisa Pin-Up | subject has received significant coverage in RS (see http://news.google.com/archivesearch?um=1&ned=us&hl=en&q=%22Lisa+Pin-Up%22&cf=all) | categories added by Nick Cooper; still needs expansion & proper references |
June 7 | Jeff Chan | subject has received coverage in multiple RS. For example, Allmusic states "Jeff Chan has played a prominent role in what has been described as the Asian-American Creative Music Movement" | none yet - will cleanup/edit for tone ASAP |
June 7 | Mark Thompson (Author and Venture Investor) | subject is a notable author (book has been reviewed by multiple RS) | none yet - will cleanup/edit for tone ASAP |
June 7 | Yuuguu | company has received coverage in multiple RS | none yet - will expand article ASAP |
June 7 | Cheeseburger (band) | band has been reviewed by multiple RS | sourced with minor cleanup by me; category added by Malcolma, still needs expanding |
June 7 | Warwick Panthers | most college sports teams are notable & I see no reaon why this one wouldn't be | |
June 7 | Orangutang | ban has been reviewed by multiple RS, including the Washington Post | content from album pages merged into main article by me; tagged as unsourced by me; still need sourcing |
June 7 | Timothy Prager | subject appears to have sufficient TV writing credits for inclusion | link to IMDb page added by me; article copy edited and cleaned up by WFinch; still could use some better sourcing |
June 7 | Bask Om | this character and others from the series should probably be merged together, but outright deletion is not the best option | article expanded by 71.58.224.104 |
June 7 | Adam Hicks | subject meets WP:ENT as he has had significant roles in multiple notable movies/TV shows | expanded slightly to demonstrate notability by me; image added by Nehrams2020; cleaned up by 198.96.34.35; minor expansion by ShuffleStop; minor changes by many editors |
June 7 | Humor Times | subject has received coverage in multiple RS | some preliminary cleanup by me; could still use some more cleanup & better sourcing |
June 7 | J. Robinson West | as the founder of a major company he is almost certainly notable | most of the article was a copyright violation and was removed by me; needs to be re-expanded with original material and sourced |
June 7 | Heed (cat) | this cat has received coverage in multiple RS for being the world's smallest | advertisement removed and other minor cleanup by me; article still needs better sourcing and expansion |
March 2012
[edit]Date | Article | My reasoning | Result |
---|---|---|---|
March 2 | Averkey | a news search shows notability exists, so problems should be solved through editing not deletion | |
March 2 | FXdirekt Bank | a news search shows clear notability | tone should be solved through editing, not deletion |
March 2 | McGee (video game series) | news searches for "McGee at the Fun Fair" and "Katie's Farm" show that the products are notable | |
March 2 | Murrays Run | all human settlements are considered notable | problems with the article shoudl be solved via editing, not deletion |
March 2 | The Overmuch Box | Google news shows some possible sources of notability | at worst it should be redirected to band's page (plausible search term) |
March 2 | Raindale Mill | the fact that the mill was important enough to be put in a museum shows notability | a news search confirms that it meets the GNG |
March 2 | Wiggins in Storyland | a news search shows notability exists | |
March 2 | Wildwind | contest should be merged (in summary form) to Pine Valley (All My Children) rather than deleted if not independently notable | |
March 2 | Devious Maids | show has already received sufficient reliabl source coverage to meet the GNG | |
March 2 | Costa Cons | should probably by merged to List of Bad Girls characters or similar, but outright deletion is not the best option | |
March 2 | Friendship cup | subject is verifiable & indeed notable (try searching for "Coppa dell’amicizia", for example) | add reference |
March 2 | La Compagnia della Forca | a news search shows notability exists | article could be expanded by translating Italian version of it |
March 2 | Bruce Leddy | subject has directed many notable programs and a news search reveals many posisbel sources | will look into improving the article |
March 2 | Organizations of Alias | this and all similar articles should be trimmed & merged into one "organziations of Alias", however outright deletion is not the best option | |
March 2 | Authorized Personnel Only | this and all similar articles should be trimmed & merged into one "organziations of Alias", however outright deletion is not the best option | |
March 2 | Covenant (Alias) | this and all similar articles should be trimmed & merged into one "organziations of Alias", however outright deletion is not the best option | |
March 2 | Prophet Five | this and all similar articles should be trimmed & merged into one "organziations of Alias", however outright deletion is not the best option | |
March 3 | Hanhart | a quick news search reveals that the company is clearly notable | cleanup & wikify article |
March 3 | ISSOW | a news search reveals that the term is used by many companies | clean up article |
March 3 | Meridian Systems | a new search seems to indicate independent notability | at worst the aricle should be merged with the Trimble one |
March 3 | Saul Mitchell | a news search backs up the Muay Thai champion claim, which is enough to at least warrant discussion | it total he appears in about 2 dozen news articles |
March 3 | Mporia | a news search shows clear notability | minor cleanup |
March 3 | Nader Tehrani | a news search reveals notability for Tehrani/Office dA | restore previous version of page the better indicates notability (but is poorly sourced) |
March 3 | The University Register | could probably be merged with University of Minnesota Morris page, but unright deletion is not the best option | |
March 4 | Alive (magazine) | a primarily news search provided evidence of notability (although it is a bit difficult to find due to generic name of magazine) | I'll try to work on improving it soon & will keep an eye out for problem edits |
March 4 | Sydney Pride Centre | subject has been covered in multiple reliable sources, which makes it at least worthy of discussion before deletion, and is probably notable | |
March 4 | French Week | subject was covered in multiple reliable sources (try searching for "French Week"+newspaper on GoogleNews) | cleanup |
March 4 | J. J. Milan | a news search shows that the subject meets the GNG which is sufficient for notability even w/o meeting WP:ATH | |
March 4 | Speakeasy Mag | subject is unlikely to be independently notable, but content can be trimmed & merged with university's article or related page & thus deletion is not the best option |
April
[edit]Date | Article | My reasoning | Result |
---|---|---|---|
Apr 10 | Codrin Arsene | sufficent coverage to at least warrant discussion before deletion | article sent to AfD; Result of the discussion was no concensus (1-2) |
Apr 11 | Revolutionary movement | although the current article is lacking, the topic is very likely to be notable and thus should not be deleted | stub expanded into a decent article by User:Piotrus |
May
[edit]Date | Article | My reasoning | Result |
---|---|---|---|
May 10 | Mporia | a news search shows clear notability for the subject, so issues should be solved via editing not deletion | article sent to AfD; Result of the discussion was no concensus (2-2) without a !vote by me |
Proposed deletions that I changed into redirects (and possibly merged)
[edit]April 2009
[edit]Date | Article | Result/reasoning |
---|---|---|
April 25 | Simone Bent | redirected to blurb in Troy Garity; moved useful content there |
April 25 | Dapose | redirected to band page |
April 25 | Building Homes from What We've Known | changed to redirect; merged track listing into main article |
April 25 | MarkMail | redirected to developer; merged useful info to there |
April 25 | Ophelia Learns to Swim | changed to redirect; merged useful info into main article |
April 25 | Son for Sail | changed to redirect; merged useful info into main article |
April 25 | Pay Your Rent, Beethoven | changed to redirect; merged useful info into main article |
April 25 | Ralph Nader Crashes the Two Parties | changed to redirect; merged useful info into main article |
April 26 | Srce Na Pauzi | redirected to artist page; useful content merged there |
April 26 | Window and the Watcher | redirected to album page (plausible search term); useful content merged there |
April 26 | Wroughten Films | changed to redirect; merged useful info into main article |
April 27 | Hotelopia | redirected to parent company article |
April 27 | Jesse Kriz | redirected to only notable band he's been a part of; merged useful content there |
May
[edit]Date | Article | Result/reasoning |
---|---|---|
May 10 | SX984 Avro Lincoln | redirected to squadron article; content was merged there |
May 10 | Yenlac | redirected to existing article (spelling variation/misspelling) |
May 11 | Gold Country Casino | Redirected to Oroville, California; merged useful info there |
May 12 | Joseph T St Lawrence Center | redirected to city page |
May 12 | Utrillo Kushner | redirected to band page; useful content was merged there |
May 13 | Daredevils of Niagara Falls | redirected to relevant section in Niagara Falls article |
May 13 | Captain dickhead | redirected to main name for the drinking game (plausible search term) |
May 14 | Antimatter (Star Trek novel) | redirected to author |
May 14 | The Big Game (Star Trek) | redirected to author |
May 14 | Bloodletter | redirected to author |
May 14 | Freshmen Adjustment 3 | redirected to discography |
May 14 | Lance Finnie | redirected to band page |
May 14 | Nueva Generacion | redirected to artist page |
May 15 | Warchild (Star Trek) | redirected to author |
May 15 | The Heart of the Warrior | redirected to author |
May 15 | Warped (Star Trek) | redirected to author |
May 15 | Objective: Bajor | redirected to author |
May 16 | Revenge of the Little Shits | redirected to band page |
May 16 | Rise and Run | redirected to artist page |
May 16 | Station Rage | redirected to author |
May 16 | King's Affair | redirected to relevant section in Kings College article |
May 18 | Mobfinance | redirected to company page; product is possibly notable, but there is no actual content on this page so redirect is the best option |
May 18 | Treasure Chest Casino | redirected to city page where it is mentioned |
May 19 | Southern Company Services | redirected to parent company article |
May 23 | John Midwinter | redirected to article about the juke box itself where he is mentioned |
May 23 | Selectrix | merged into Model train control systems |
May 23 | Meet Me at the Roxy | redirected to album page (plausible search term) |
May 23 | Michael Stopp | redirected to game he created |
May 26 | Deadliner | redirected to album page (plausible search term) |
May 26 | This Prison Moon | redirected to album page (plausible search term) |
May 27 | Frederick V. Johnson | redirected to notable program he is a major of part of |
May 27 | Lado District | redirected to existing article on the same subject (alternate name/plausible search term) |
May 27 | Moon white | redirected to author |
May 28 | Eretz Hakodesh | redirected to band page; useful content merged there |
May 28 | Lewis Linford | redirected to the one notable character he has played |
May 28 | Jonathan Glatzer | redirected to notable film he directed |
May 28 | Musica Animalia | redirected to author; merged useful content there |
May 29 | Jonathan Payne | redirected to notable software he created |
May 30 | Pieces of Nothing | redirected to relevant section of discography; merged useful content there |
May 30 | Believe E.P. | redirected to artist page; merged useful content there |
May 30 | Whitesand Bay Battery | redirected to Whitsand Bay & merge content there |
May 30 | Psychology of Selves | redirected to the people who creating the theory; merged the content there |
May 30 | Voice Dialogue | redirected to creator's article where it is mentioned briefly |
May 30 | Cobblestone Elementary School | redirected to school district article; useful content will be merged there |
May 30 | Hemel Sprot | redirected to book; merged useful content there |
May 31 | Drowning Pool (album) | redirected to discography (content will be merged and redirect is necessary to preserve edit history) |
May 31 | Endvisioned | redirected to album page (plausible search term) |
May 31 | Perl::Critic | redirected to relevant section in Automated code review - useful content will be merged there |
May 31 | New Forms² | redirected to related album; content will be merged there |
May 31 | New Junk Aesthetic | redirected to band page |
May 31 | Put It On | redirected to album page (plausible search term) |
March 2012
[edit]Date | Article | Result/reasoning |
---|---|---|
March 2 | Alias soundtrack releases | merged & redirecting to relevant section of main article rather than deleting |
March 2 | The Animated Alias: Tribunal | merged relevant content to episode list rather than deleting |
March 2 | Ghostfreak | merged to character article rather than deleting |
March 3 | Moose Lake Airport | redirected to town article |
March 3 | Thinlet | merge & redirect to related article |
March 4 | Standing Together to Organize a Revolutionary Movement | redirected to article where it is covered |
Others items which were proposed for deletion where I removed the PROD tag
[edit]Date | Article | My reasoning | Result |
---|---|---|---|
April 23, 2009 | User:Cumbrowski/Frank Fiore | removed PROD tag - PROD is for article space only | |
May 18, 2009 | James H. Wear | article previous survived AfD (Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James H. Wear) and thus isn't eligible for PROD | none yet - I will see what I can do about sourcing ASAP |
March 2, 2012 | Alias DVD releases | I suggest merging "season one" DVD info to Alias (season 1), "season two" DVD info to Alias (season 2), etc.; will try to do so sometime soon | |
March 3, 2012 | Paid Programming (TV pilot) | Notability is marginable at best, but due to high quality of the article I feel a deletion discussion is warranted if deletion is desired | |
March 3, 2012 | John Tarrant (Zen Buddhist) | DGG appears to have intended to dispute it, additionally my search indicated very borderline notability, so its not a clear cut PROD case |