Talk:Disc (magazine)

The Alan Smith article on Disc's Silver(and Gold) records is completely error-strewn

First, the DISC system went into effect as of 1 March, 1959. Only records released on or after 1 March 1959 were eligible. Anything released on or before 28 February 1959 could not receive a DISC Record, as it was not eligible. Smith lists records from BEFORE 1 March 1959 as recipients of Disc's Silver Records. Notably, Side Saddle by Russ Conway as the first ever recipient . However, this never received a DISC Silver Record, as it was released before 1 March 1959.

Smith omits several records that did receive Silver Discs.

Smith omits records that received Gold Discs, including the very first..Living Doll by Cliff Richard.

Smith gets the dates hopelessly wrong, most notably perhaps Only The Lonely by Roy Orbison

Smith lists records getting Silver Records which never did... such as My Old Man's A Dustman by Lonnie Donegan

Smith misunderstands the difference between a DISC Record presentation, and a Silver(or Gold) Record presentation by the artist or group's record company. So, as just one example, on 17 February 1962 Elvis Presley received 2 new silver Discs, ONE was from DISC, the other was an in-house presentation from HIS RECORD COMPANY. Smith lists both as being DISC Silver Records, even though it is explicitly stated that only ONE is a DISC Silver Record. 197.87.135.139 (talk) 08:08, 23 April 2024 (UTC)

[1] Page 10 introduces it. And explains exactly what the Silver Records are, and how they are attained.

[2] Page 8 congratulates the first 5 artists to be awarded. Note the date, and which 5 records they are. Note too that again the "Start Date" fr eligibility(1 March 1959) is repeated, and why one particular quarter-million seller(Side Saddle by Russ Conway) was not able to receive a Silver Record.(It was released in February 1959.)

[3] The one-year anniversary of those first Silver Records being awarded. On Page 10 EVERY DISC Silver Record Award winner for the past year is listed... 38 in all. Compare the ACTUAL 38 DISC Silver Record Award winners to Alan Smith's list of Silver Record winners up to and including 13 August 1960. They barely resemble each other at all.

Then, there are still Alan Smith's post- 13 August 1960 Awards That Never Were...

Smith lists Lonnie Donegan's "My Old Man's A Dustman" getting a Silver Record on 26 November 1960. Problem is [4] as is perfectly clear that's not true. As seen on the front cover(Page 1) Donegan's then-latest single has reached 200 000 sales and is expected to get to 250 000 sales for Silver Record Award. Only, it never did. Worse, the record in question isn't even "My Old Man's A Dustman". It's Lively.

Did DISC Award Silver Records for LPs? According to Smith, they did. Smith's article states that on 7 January 1961 Russ Conway was presented with a DISC Silver Record for 250 000 LP sales. This would be true had Smith simply removed the word "DISC". [5]. On the cover(Page 1) The article states that Conway is receiving the Award from his record company. Nothing at all about it being a DISC Award. The same front cover(Page 1) also states "TWO MORE SILVER DISC WINNERS". On pages 8-9 we find out that those are

"Strawberry Fair" by Anthony Newley and "Poetry In Motion" by Johnny Tillotson. Conway's Award was from his record label, not DISC. Another such award(which Smith doesn't mention) occurred on 26 November 1960. [6]. On page 8 it states that Victor Silvester is about to be awarded with a Silver Record for 250 000 LP sales. Again, this is not a DISC Silver Record.

And then there's Elvis Presley's album G.I. Blues. Smith's article states that this was awarded a Silver Record by DISC. It wasn't.[7]. On pages 8-9 we find that Elvis Presley has just been awarded with two new Silver Records. One is his latest DISC Silver Record for Rock-A-Hula-Baby. The other, for G.I. Blues, was presented to Presley by Decca Records. As with Conway and Silvester's LP Silver Records, this is not a DISC Silver Record. When one counts Presley's DISC Silver Records, G.I. Blues is definitely not included. 197.87.135.139 (talk) 10:13, 24 April 2024 (UTC)

Elvis, and conclusion about Reliability of Alan Smith as a source..

Here are Elvis Presley's first 12 DISC Silver Records:

1.I Need Your Love Tonight [8] 15 August 1959. (Page 8) (Smith says 23 May 1959)

2. Mess Of Blues [9] 10 September 1960 (front cover, Page 1)

3. It's Now Or Never [10] 5 November 1960 (Page 2). (,Smith says 29 October 1960).

4-8 were all presented on the same day. This is because Elvis Presley's label had declined to have his UK sales certified for DISC Silver Record awards for most of the year 1961. However on 30 December 1961 five records that had all previously qualified were awarded DISC Silver Records [11] (Page 12. And Presley is said to now have 8 DISC Silver Records in total.)

9. Rock-A-Hula-Baby [12] 17 February 1962, pages 8-9.

10. Good Luck Charm [13] 9 June 1962. On front cover/page 1 it explicitly states that it's his tenth DISC Silver Record.

11 and 12. She's Not You and Return To Sender. On Page 11 of the December 22 1960 issue [14] we find that this brings Elvis' total number of DISC Silver Records up to this point in time to 12. G.I. Blues never got a DISC Silver Record Award. Smith makes a big deal about G.I. Blues' DISC Silver Record. It never got one.

So, what does that say about Smith as a WP:RS? Here, or about how many copies singles actually sold(eg. Apache, The Carnival Is Over, Sugar Sugar)?197.87.135.139 (talk) 10:44, 24 April 2024 (UTC)