User contributions for 98.206.31.187

For 98.206.31.187 talk block log logs filter log
Search for contributionsshowhide
⧼contribs-top⧽
⧼contribs-date⧽

2 February 2024

1 February 2024

30 January 2024

27 January 2024

23 January 2024

22 January 2024

21 January 2024

  • 06:1006:10, 21 January 2024 diff hist +49 Zal Batmanglij→‎Career: Section containing significant non-"Sky is blue" content is marked as needing citations to allow verification, so it no longer violates WP:VERIFY.
  • 06:0306:03, 21 January 2024 diff hist +31 Brit MarlingFormally calling for an update. The citation for the 2023 series ("Murder...") was just added by us. Emphasis of the article (and sources) clusters around the period of 2011-2014. The period during and following the OA (through today) appears lean in comparison.
  • 05:5905:59, 21 January 2024 diff hist +985 Brit MarlingCitation added to support previously unsupported lead sentence. Otherwise, article needs an update based on sources. (Adding content just as editors become personally aware devolves into WP:OR, and violates WP:VERIFY.)
  • 05:4805:48, 21 January 2024 diff hist +398 A Murder at the End of the WorldArticle is generally superbly done, but noting some material in lead is unique, violating WP:INTRO, and same material is therefore unsourced. Also noting that clustering citations 1-4 at end of an internal paragraph is not helpful vis-a-vis WP:VERIFY. Citations should appear with content derived therefrom.

20 January 2024

  • 21:4621:46, 20 January 2024 diff hist +234 Sex at Dawn→‎Scholarly reception: Made clear why the opening paragraph is unsourced, and called for a timestamp to complete the audio blog/interview citation. Reorderd the subsections that follow, because the emphasis of the opening summary is negative, and so the argument flows naturally into the negative reviews to open the article. NOTE: it is possible that the subsection headings might actually be removed. Purported positive reviews are not very much so–rather relatively descriptive, negative.