Wikipedia talk:Requests for adminship/Jafeluv
Appearance
Editing stats for Jafeluv at 15:59, 1 September 2009 (UTC):
General user info Username: Jafeluv User groups: autoreviewer First edit: Mar 11, 2008 21:26:51 Unique articles edited: 5,486 Average edits per page: 2.02 Total edits (including deleted): 11,062 Deleted edits: 662 Live edits: 10,400 Namespace totals Article 6024 57.92% Talk 1772 17.04% User 647 6.22% User talk 488 4.69% Wikipedia 751 7.22% Wikipedia talk 79 0.76% File 129 1.24% File talk 2 0.02% Template 297 2.86% Template talk 23 0.22% Help 2 0.02% Category 169 1.62% Category talk 9 0.09% Portal 8 0.08% Month counts 2008/03 317 2008/04 198 2008/05 0 2008/06 0 2008/07 0 2008/08 6 2008/09 3 2008/10 30 2008/11 89 2008/12 169 2009/01 294 2009/02 289 2009/03 218 2009/04 596 2009/05 1491 2009/06 1520 2009/07 1947 2009/08 3226 2009/09 7 Logs Pages moved: 340 Pages patrolled: 329 Files uploaded: 85 Top edited articles Article * 246 - List_of_1920s_jazz_standards * 57 - List_of_1930s_jazz_standards * 43 - List_of_pre-1920_jazz_standards * 42 - CMX_(band) * 31 - List_of_jazz_standards * 28 - CMX_discography * 22 - List_of_post-1950_jazz_standards * 21 - A._W._Yrjänä * 21 - Jazz_standard * 16 - Ismo_Alanko Talk * 12 - List_of_countries_by_level_of_military_equipment * 10 - Antonio_Carlos_Jobim * 9 - List_of_1920s_jazz_standards * 8 - Star_Wars_Episode_V:_The_Empire_Strikes_Back * 8 - List_of_pre-1920_jazz_standards * 7 - Mary_Jones_and_her_Bible * 7 - List_of_jazz_standards * 6 - Digital_subscriber_line * 6 - How_Not_To_Live_Your_Life * 6 - Bing User * 596 - Jafeluv/Sandbox * 15 - Jafeluv/monobook.js * 5 - Gareth_E_Kegg/List_of_songs_recorded_by_Ella_Fitzg... * 4 - Jafeluv * 3 - Jafeluv/monobook.css * 2 - JaseKent/sandbox * 2 - Pdfpdf/Jonathan_Bonnitcha * 2 - Cczwirn/Austrian_Technik_Bratislava_ATB * 1 - Sofus_Midtgaard * 1 - Mel_Etitis/Jazz-L_top_100 User talk * 37 - Jafeluv * 16 - Roux/RFA-reform * 11 - Harej * 7 - Scarce * 7 - Mikaey * 7 - Anthony_Appleyard/2009/April-June * 6 - Robertgreer * 6 - Vegaswikian * 6 - Ohms_law * 5 - Shshshsh Wikipedia * 95 - Requested_moves * 90 - Proposed_mergers * 34 - Categories_for_discussion/Speedy * 15 - Categories_for_discussion/Log/2009_August_24 * 12 - Articles_for_deletion/Saaranpaskantamasaari * 12 - Redirects_for_discussion/Log/2009_August_25 * 10 - Featured_list_candidates/List_of_pre-1920_jazz_sta... * 8 - Peer_review/Canadian_heraldry/archive2 * 8 - Categories_for_discussion/Log/2009_August_12 * 7 - Categories_for_discussion/Log/2009_June_25 Wikipedia talk * 17 - Requests_for_adminship * 15 - Requested_moves * 8 - Proposed_mergers * 7 - Criteria_for_speedy_deletion * 6 - WikiProject_International_relations * 5 - WikiProject_Jazz * 3 - Alternative_text_for_images * 2 - Naming_conventions_(common_names) * 2 - WikiProject_Deletion * 2 - WikiProject_Military_history File * 3 - RfA_edit_count_chart.png * 2 - Thelonious_Himself_cover.jpg * 2 - My_Goal's_Beyond_Cover.jpg * 2 - Space_Buddha_–_No_Shields_cover.jpg * 2 - Pop-musiikkia_cover.jpg * 2 - Hei_soturit_Lapset_cover.jpg * 2 - Topgearlogo1996.jpg * 2 - This_Town_Needs_Guns_EP.jpg * 2 - Get_Guilty_cover.jpg * 2 - Softwood_Music_Under_Slow_Pillars_cover.jpg File talk * 1 - Soft_machine-fourth.jpg * 1 - Soft_machine-fourth_and_fifth.jpg Template * 50 - Static_column_begin * 31 - Digit_separator * 28 - Number_of_troops * 19 - Number_of_troops/doc * 15 - Static_column_row * 8 - Static_column_begin/doc * 8 - Jazz_standards * 4 - Static_column_row/doc * 4 - University_of_the_Philippines_Manila * 4 - University_of_the_Philippines_Visayas Template talk * 7 - Did_you_know * 4 - Citation_needed * 2 - Alt_text_missing * 1 - University_of_the_Philippines_Diliman * 1 - University_of_the_Philippines,_Diliman * 1 - Neighborhoods_of_Jerusalem * 1 - Citeneeded * 1 - Alttext_missing * 1 - Alt_text_missing/doc * 1 - Editabuselinks Help * 2 - Sorting Category * 3 - Jazz_standards * 3 - 1950s_jazz_standards * 2 - 1910s_jazz_standards * 2 - 1940s_jazz_standards * 2 - 1970s_jazz_standards * 2 - Jazz_standards_by_decade * 2 - 1920s_jazz_standards * 2 - Instrumentals * 2 - Swedish_Armenians * 2 - Hard-bop_musicians Category talk * 2 - Sailing_films * 2 - Kavango_Region * 1 - Poisson_processes * 1 - Rock_instrumentals * 1 - Jazz_standards * 1 - Ex-gay_organizations * 1 - Joinery Portal * 1 - AC/DC/Topics * 1 - Australia/Anniversaries/July/July_2 * 1 - Jazz/Related_portals * 1 - Jazz/Selected_biography * 1 - Jazz/Quotes * 1 - Jazz/Selected_picture * 1 - Jazz/Selected_article * 1 - Jazz/Did_you_know
Responses to Bearian
[edit]Note: Moved here from the oppose section. Jafeluv (talk) 10:09, 4 September 2009 (UTC)
Oppose - meets some of my standards, but not others. I'd like to know more about the candidate before supporting. Bearian (talk) 19:27, 2 September 2009 (UTC)
- What is this criteria that he doesn't meet? Kevin Rutherford (talk) 19:29, 2 September 2009 (UTC)
- I think it's the very strong desire for "an interesting userpage with useful userboxen" and "barnstars from editors and sysops," neither of which will be met as Jafeluv doesn't have a userpage. ~ Amory (user • talk • contribs) 19:57, 2 September 2009 (UTC)
- No offense, but that is not really criteria, as it seems more like an expectation of something that we don't all achieve. Kevin Rutherford (talk) 21:17, 2 September 2009 (UTC)
- Yea, it's like judging someone by the clothes they wear or the car they have... Airplaneman talk 00:58, 3 September 2009 (UTC)
- To be fair, Bearian did say he wants to know more about Jafeluv before supporting, so lack of a user page doesn't sound like an automatic oppose. To Bearian, what questions would you like answered to reconsider your oppose? The Seeker 4 Talk 12:44, 3 September 2009 (UTC)
- Yea, it's like judging someone by the clothes they wear or the car they have... Airplaneman talk 00:58, 3 September 2009 (UTC)
- No offense, but that is not really criteria, as it seems more like an expectation of something that we don't all achieve. Kevin Rutherford (talk) 21:17, 2 September 2009 (UTC)
- It's brilliant that he has no userpage - it shows he is not here to play myspace, and getting a landslide support without one shows he is here to do the right things. Userboxes are worse than pointless, and for an admin, all they serve to do is give the brainless some ammunition. If you really want to know his interests, check his contribs, or be smart and use What Links Here to see what projects he is signed up to. If he has no barnstars, so what? They are meaningless after all. If he has them and has simply said thanks, but chooses not to display them like they are trophies, or to show the respect of certain editors over others is not important to him, even better. If he chooses not to implement the luxury that is talk page archiving, that is hardly a crime, and it at least means he will get less opportunistic complaints lazily profiling him from the contents of his archives. The only thing a user page should possibly be used for is listing GAs and FAs, but since that process has become a standing joke, that sort of user page cruft is hardly needed anymore either to show you are a good contributor. MickMacNee (talk) 19:55, 3 September 2009 (UTC)
- I think it's the very strong desire for "an interesting userpage with useful userboxen" and "barnstars from editors and sysops," neither of which will be met as Jafeluv doesn't have a userpage. ~ Amory (user • talk • contribs) 19:57, 2 September 2009 (UTC)