Wikipedia:WikiProject Military history/Peer review/United States Naval Special Warfare Command

United States Naval Special Warfare Command[edit]

The United States Naval Special Warfare Command article needs a peer review because it is an "Incorrectly tagged WikiProject Military history article" and for normal improvement. Outdawg (talk) 06:23, 2 January 2008 (UTC)[reply]

Roger Davies[edit]

Firstly, I've had a look at the tagging. The first B-class criterion had been set "yes" in error, so I've changed that to "no", but is otherwise accurate. As the article fails on B1, "start" class looks right to me. Does this help?

Secondly, and you probably won't like this, the glaring omission is the lack of inline citations (two for the whole article). Before any expansion takes place, you should provide citations for all major statements. See WP:V for what to cite and WP:REF for how to cite it. As this may well considerably change the content and structure of the article, it might be better to request a fresh peer-review after the cites are done. If you need a hand, contact me on my talk page :)

Otherwise, it's a promising aticle with great potential ... All the best, --ROGER DAVIES ^talk 11:36, 2 January 2008 (UTC)[reply]