From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
This is an archive of past discussions. Do not edit the contents of this page. If you wish to start a new discussion or revive an old one, please do so on the current main page .
This is a subpage of the assessment department of WikiProject Anime and manga . This department focuses on assessing the quality of Wikipedia's Anime and manga articles. While much of the work is done in conjunction with the WP:1.0 program, the article ratings are also used within the project itself to aid in recognizing excellent contributions and identifying topics in need of further work.
The ratings are done in a distributed fashion through parameters in the {{ WikiProject Anime and manga }} project banner; this causes the articles to be placed in the appropriate sub-categories of Category:Anime and manga articles by quality , which serves as the foundation for an automatically generated worklist . This page provides a list of articles that should be assessed in terms of quality and importance as part of the 2008 assessment drive .
Instructions
For each article:
Check that it's within WikiProject Anime and manga's scope .
Check that the class is correctly assessed.
Add missing workgroup parameters.
Mark articles that require critical cleanup for urgent attention by setting |attention=yes
.
Mark articles that should be followed up for merging by setting |merge=yes
.New! NB: Tag or assess redirects with |class=Redirect
.
Completed ranges
After completing each 10-article range, either strike through the article name (with "<s>" and "</s>") or add "Done, ~~~~" at the foot of the section.
Scope questions
Assessment help
For general assessment help, see general assessment FAQ .
For the formal , and , see the project's assessment guidelines .
For the formal priority criteria, see the project's priority scale .
Set |class=C
if an article is . Set |class=B
if and only if an article meets the majority of the B-Class criteria.
The template accepts B-Class short forms – |B1=y
, |B2=n
etc. Please set add and set these parameters for all C-class and B-class articles.
If all six B-class parameters are not "Yes", the template automatically sets "class=C".
Sample workgroup parameters
Biography workgroup: |biography-work-group=yes
or |bwg=yes
Conventions workgroup: |conventions-work-group=yes
Sample parameter strings
Before tagging and assessing: {{WikiProject Anime and manga |class=start}}
Merger required: {{WikiProject Anime and manga |class=start |importance=Mid |merge=yes}}
Urgent attention required: {{WikiProject Anime and manga |class=start |importance=Mid |attention=yes}}
Not near B-Class: {{WikiProject Anime and manga |class=start |importance=Mid}}
Nearly B-Class: {{WikiProject Anime and manga |class=B |B1=n |B2=y |B3=y |B4=y |B5=y |B6=y |importance=Mid}}
B-Class: {{WikiProject Anime and manga |class=B | | | | | | |importance=Mid}}
Sample edit summary
1
Mafia Community (Hunter × Hunter) (Talk | Low | Start | Update assessment )
Mag Garden (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Magazine Z (Talk | ??? | Stub | Update assessment )
Maggie Mui (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Magic Bus (studio) (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Magic in Negima (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Magic Kaito (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Magic Knight Rayearth (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Magic User's Club (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Magic Woman M (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
2
Magical Angel Creamy Mami (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Magical Angel Sweet Mint (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Magical boy (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Magical Canan (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Magical DoReMi (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Magical Fairy Persia (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha A's (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha Strikers (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha terminology (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha (Talk | Unknown | C | Update assessment )
3
Magical Girl Pretty Sammy (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Magical girl (Talk | Unknown | C | Update assessment )
Magical girlfriend (Talk | Unknown | C | Update assessment )
Magical Idol Pastel Yumi (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Magical Nyan Nyan Taruto (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Magical Play (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Magical Princess Minky Momo (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Magical Project S (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Magical Shopping Arcade Abenobashi (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Magical Star Magical Emi (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
4
Magical Tarurūto-kun (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Magical Twilight (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Magical x Miracle (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Magician's Academy (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Magi-Cu (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Magikano (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Magne Robo Gakeen (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Maguro Fujita (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Mahaha (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Mahiro Maeda (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
5
Mahito Tsujimura (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Mahōjin Guru Guru (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Mahoraba (Talk | Unknown | C | Update assessment )
Mahoromatic (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Mahou no Rouge Lipstick (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Mahou Tsukai Chappy (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Mai Aizawa (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Mai Goto (voice actress) (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Mai Hoshikawa (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Mai Kadowaki (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
6
Mai Nakahara (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Mai Tokiha (Talk | Unknown | C | Update assessment )
Mai, the Psychic Girl (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Maia Sterling (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Maico 2010 (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Maison Ikkoku CD Single Memorial File (Talk | Unknown | C | Update assessment )
Maison Ikkoku (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Majestics (Talk | Low | Start | Update assessment )
Majin Buu (Talk | Unknown | C | Update assessment )
Majin Tantei Nōgami Neuro (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
7
Majokko Megu-chan (Talk | Unknown | C | Update assessment )
Majokko Tickle (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Majokko Tsukune-chan (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Major (manga) (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Makafushigi Adventure! (Talk | Low | Start | Update assessment )
Makai Senki Disgaea (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Makaiju (Talk | Unknown | C | Update assessment )
Maka-Maka (manga) (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Maken X (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Maken-ki! (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
8
Maker Hikōshiki Hatsune Mix (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Maki Kazumi (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Maki Murakami (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Maki Saitō (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Makiko Nagi (Talk | Low | C | Update assessment )
Makiko Ōmoto (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Makimachi Misao (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Makio Inoue (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Mako Hyōdō (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Mako Komao (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
9
MAKO (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Makoto Ishii (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Makoto Isshiki (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Makoto Kobayashi (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Makoto Moriwaki (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Makoto Nakamura (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Makoto Naruse (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Makoto Raiku (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Makoto Shinkai (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Makoto Tateno (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
10
Makoto Tsumura (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Makoto Yukimura (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Makoto-chan (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
MakubeX (Talk | Low | Start | Update assessment )
Mama (InuYasha) (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Mama Loves the Poyopoyo-Saurus (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Mama wa Shōgaku 4 Nensei (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Mami Deguchi (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Mami Horikoshi (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Mami Kingetsu (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
11
Mami Kosuge (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Mami Koyama (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Mami Matsui (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Mamiko Ikeda (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Mamiko Noto (Talk | Low | Start | Update assessment )
Mammothman (Talk | Low | Start | Update assessment )
Mamoru Hosoda (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Mamoru Miyano (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Mamoru Nagano (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Mamoru Oshii (Talk | Mid | C | Update assessment )
12
Mamoru Yokota (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Mamoru-kun ni Megami no Shukufuku o! (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Mamotte! Lollipop (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Man of Many Faces (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
MAN-003 Patulia (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Mana Kuzunoha (Talk | Low | C | Update assessment )
Manami Kusunoki (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Mandarake (Talk | Low | Start | Update assessment )
Manga (magazine) (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Manga Burikko (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
13
Manga cafe (Talk | Mid | Start | Update assessment )
Manga Entertainment (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Manga Force: The Ultimate Collection (Talk | Low | Start | Update assessment )
Manga from The Legend of Zelda series (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Manga iconography (Talk | Mid | Start | Update assessment )
Manga Kenkanryu (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Manga Life (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Manga meat (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Manga Messiah (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Manga outside Japan (Talk | Top | Start | Update assessment )
14
Manga Studio (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Manga Time Kirara Carat (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Manga Time Kirara Forward (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Manga Time Kirara (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Manga! Manga! The World of Japanese Comics (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Manga (Talk | Top | C | Update assessment )
Mangafan (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Mangajin (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Mangaka (Talk | Top | Start | Update assessment )
MangaNEXT (Talk | Low | Start | Update assessment )
15
Manglobe (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Maniac Road (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Maniax (OVA) (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Manifest (convention) (Talk | Low | C | Update assessment )
Manji (Blade of the Immortal) (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Man's Best Friend (manga) (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Manta Oyamada (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Manticore (Boogiepop) (Talk | Unknown | C | Update assessment )
Mao Nome (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Maple Colors (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
16
Maple Town (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
MapleStory (anime) (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Mappa Douji (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Maps (anime) (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
MÄR Omega (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
MÄR (Talk | Unknown | C | Update assessment )
March Comes in Like a Lion (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Marcus Rush (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Margaret (magazine) (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Margaret Burton (Madlax) (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
17
MÄR-Heaven (Talk | Unknown | C | Update assessment )
Mari Iijima (Talk | Low | Start | Update assessment )
Mari Kanō (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Mari Mashiba (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Mari Ozawa (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Maria Graceburt (Talk | Low | Start | Update assessment )
Maria Kawamura (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Maria Noches (Talk | Low | Start | Update assessment )
Maria Yamamoto (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Mariah Wong (Talk | Low | Start | Update assessment )
18
Maria-sama ga Miteru (light novels) (Talk | Unknown | C | Update assessment )
Maria-sama ga Miteru (Talk | Unknown | C | Update assessment )
Mariela Ortiz (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Marika Matsumoto (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Mariko Iwadate (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Mariko Kōda (Talk | Low | Start | Update assessment )
Mariko Konjo (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Mariko Shiga (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Mariko Suzuki (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Marimo Ragawa (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
19
Marimokkori (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Marina Inoue (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Marina Ismail (Talk | Low | Start | Update assessment )
Marina Ōno (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Marine a Go Go (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Marine Boy (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
Maris the Chojo (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Marmalade Boy (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Maromi (Talk | Low | Stub | Update assessment )
Marquis Yanus (Talk | Unknown | Stub | Update assessment )
20
Marriage Royale (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Mars (Kinnikuman) (Talk | Low | Start | Update assessment )
Mars (manga) (Talk | Unknown | C | Update assessment )
Martian Successor Nadesico: The Motion Picture – Prince of Darkness (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Martian Successor Nadesico (Talk | Unknown | C | Update assessment )
Martin DaCosta (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Martin Empire (Talk | Unknown | C | Update assessment )
Maruhage Empire villains (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Maruhage Empire (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )
Marvelous Melmo (Talk | Unknown | Start | Update assessment )