| Category |
Decision |
Discussion_log
|
| 1915 in German South West Africa |
rename and merge as nominated |
August 27
|
| 1915 in German South West Africa |
 Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 27#Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 17 |
August 17
|
| Category:1952 establishments in Cape Verde |
merge |
August 15
|
| Category:1993 establishments in the Palestinian territories |
there is consensus to merge, but not a strong consensus on which way. The balance of opinion favoured a reverse merge to the "Palestinian territories" categories, so that is what will be done. This is without prejudice to a rename proposal to use the "Civil Administration area" and "Israeli Military Governorate" terminology for these categories |
August 22
|
| Category:19th-century Hebrew Christian movement |
rename to option A |
August 23
|
| Category:19th-century Iranian people and previous centuries people |
keep. – |
August 22
|
| Category:2020 AFC U-23 Championship |
no consensus. – |
August 9
|
| Category:21st-century movements |
Rename |
August 5
|
| Category:21st-century Roman Catholicism |
rename by replacing 'Roman Catholicism' with 'Catholicism' |
August 30
|
| Category:Action spy films |
Delete |
August 13
|
| Category:Advocacy groups by continent |
no consensus |
August 15
|
| Category:Advocates of the Fourteen Words |
delete as over-categorisation on the grounds given below. I note that the main article already has a list of advocates, and that the member pages of this category are all otherwise categorised as alt-right etc. – |
August 9
|
| Category:African presidents |
delete |
August 10
|
| Category:Albums produced by Symbolyc One (S1) |
Merge |
August 31
|
| Category:Ambassadors to the Republic of China (Taiwan) |
merge both to Category:Ambassadors to Taiwan. (non-admin closure) |
August 23
|
| Category:American adult animated television programs featuring anthropomorphic characters |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 September 5#Category:American adult animated television programs featuring anthropomorphic characters |
August 28
|
| Category:American communists of the Stalin era |
keep. A rename proposal should be made in a separate nomination |
August 13
|
| Category:American LGBT drama television series |
rename |
August 28
|
| Category:American science fiction conventions |
rename as nominated. The contents are sufficient to retain the national category. A parent category for North America can be added separately. – |
August 13
|
| Category:Americans who grew up in poverty |
Delete |
August 14
|
| Category:Ancient Greeks from Aegean Sea |
rename to Category:Ancient Greeks by island in Greece |
August 19
|
| Category:Androni–Sidermec–Bottecchia |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 September 4#Category:Androni–Sidermec–Bottecchia |
August 24
|
| Anglicanism in French Polynesia |
merge the third to Category:Protestant missionaries in French Polynesia; the sole member of the fourth is already in Category:French Polynesian Protestant missionaries, so that and the otherwise-empty parents can be deleted. – |
August 13
|
| Category:Animals and plants named after David Attenborough |
Delete |
August 22
|
| Category:Animals of Central America |
merge. – |
August 27
|
| Category:Anthropology of education |
speedy move. |
August 12
|
| Category:Antiguan and Barbudan Wikipedians |
rename |
August 7
|
| Apple Cup |
delete (non-admin closure) |
August 1
|
| Category:Artsakhian building and structure stubs |
merge category to Category:Artsakh stubs, Category:Asian building and structure stubs and Category:European building and structure stubs. The church ones are already in Asia and Europe church stub categories |
August 1
|
| Category:Assassination attempt survivors |
delete |
August 18
|
| Category:Assassination attempts |
rename per nomination. There is consensus that it needs to be changed somehow. Making "attempts" the parent of successful assassinations would be counter-intuitive to some readers, and would be contrary to the current hierarchy of Failed crimes as a sub-cat of Crimes, etc. – |
August 9
|
| Category:Austrian military personnel killed in World War II |
keep |
August 7
|
| Category:Austrian military personnel of World War II |
no consensus. It may be worthwhile to pursue a group nomination with the other similarly named categories, but there is insufficient support to rename only this one, hoping that the others follow through in separate discussions |
August 7
|
| Category:Barony of Veligosti |
merge. – |
August 22
|
| Category:Barony of Vostitsa |
merge. – |
August 22
|
| Category:Basketball at the European Youth Olympic Days |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 September 1#Category:Basketball at the European Youth Olympic Days |
August 21
|
| Category:BFA Senior League navigational boxes |
merge (non-admin closure) |
August 7
|
| Category:Billionaires |
keep |
August 14
|
| Category:Books about economic inequality |
keep |
August 7
|
| Category:Byzantine noble families |
delete (non-admin closure) |
August 19
|
| Category:California Genocide |
rename to Category:California genocide. – |
August 22
|
| Category:Catholic Church Councils by country |
rename as nominated, while leaving the capitalization of "Church" in tact |
August 19
|
| Category:Catholic Psychedelic Synth Folk |
Delete |
August 20
|
| Category:Catholicism |
keep |
August 20
|
| Category:Catholicism |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 20#Category:Catholicism |
August 5
|
| Category:Celticists |
Rename to Category:Celtic studies scholars |
August 18
|
| Category:Cheruthony Dam |
delete (non-admin closure) |
August 21
|
| Category:Christian fraternities and sororities by country |
Merge |
August 24
|
| Category:Christian sororities |
merge |
August 10
|
| Category:Christianity of the Middle Ages |
rename to Category:Christianity in the Middle Ages. This option was backed by rationales, while others mostly were not |
August 8
|
| Category:Church councils accepted by the Roman Catholic Church |
rename |
August 19
|
| Cleanup of Singapore football categories |
Delete |
August 31
|
| Category:Climbs in cycle racing in the United Kingdom |
keep. The option to nominate the entire tree for deletion is available |
August 24
|
| Category:Commercial video games with freely available source code |
'speedy keep. Withdrawn by nominator. (non-admin closure) — |
August 26
|
| Category:Communication degree holders |
Delete |
August 7
|
| Category:Converts to Roman Catholicism (from X) |
Kept |
August 24
|
| Category:Converts to Roman Catholicism from Evangelicalism |
keep. The broader discussion was also closed as keep. (non-admin closure) |
August 15
|
| Category:Converts to Roman Catholicism from Evangelicalism |
rename to Category:Converts to Catholicism from Evangelicalism |
August 5
|
| Cooperative banking by country |
rename and merge as nominated. There is more work to be done within this category tree; additional steps should be made with a new nomination |
August 9
|
| Category:Corporate law by country |
keep |
August 30
|
| Category:CRM software companies in South Africa |
Delete |
August 27
|
| Category:Crown Prince Party |
Delete |
August 23
|
| Category:Cultural depictions of Ancient Israeli and Judean people |
Rename |
August 2
|
| Category:Deaths by jungle justice |
delete |
August 18
|
| Category:Democracy and the United Kingdom |
Delete |
August 30
|
| Category:Destroyed landmarks in Spain demolished during the Francoist Spain period |
merge |
August 18
|
| Category:Documentary films about Roman Catholicism |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 29#Category:Documentary films about Roman Catholicism |
August 19
|
| Category:Donald J. Trump Foundation |
merge to Category:Business career of Donald Trump |
August 25
|
| Category:Doughboys (Canadian band) |
Delete |
August 24
|
| Category:Dry counties in the United States |
delete. There was not enough support to warrant a list. However, if anyone has interest to create one, I copied the category's contents on the talk page |
August 6
|
| Category:Dry counties of Kentucky |
delete. There was not enough support to warrant a list. However, if anyone has interest to create one, I copied the category's contents on the talk page |
August 6
|
| Category:Dutch Frisian people |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 13#Category:Dutch Frisian people |
August 4
|
| Category:Dutch Frisian people |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 September 4#Category:Dutch Frisian people |
August 13
|
| Category:Education enrollment |
no consensus. (non-admin closure) |
August 23
|
| Category:Education enrollment |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 12#Category:Education enrollment |
August 12
|
| Category:Elementary middle schools |
merge (non-admin closure) |
August 12
|
| Category:Eponymous clothing |
delete |
August 12
|
| Category:Eponymous food |
Delete |
August 22
|
| Category:ERP software companies in South Africa |
Delete |
August 27
|
| Category:Esperanto by country |
keep |
August 17
|
| Category:Esperanto movement in Iran |
rename to Category:Esperanto in Iran |
August 5
|
| Category:Esperanto workers movement |
keep. The biographies articles will be purged |
August 20
|
| Category:Esperanto workers movement |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 20#Category:Esperanto workers movement |
August 5
|
| Category:Estonian Science fiction |
delete (currently empty). – |
August 29
|
| Events by decade |
delete |
August 18
|
| Category:F.C. Civics Windhoek |
delete (non-admin closure) |
August 10
|
| Category:Famous foreign Bollywood singers and dancers |
Delete |
August 28
|
| Category:Farhangian University |
delete (non-admin closure) |
August 11
|
| Category:Fashion journalism |
Keep |
August 26
|
| Category:Fashion journalism |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 26#Category:Fashion journalism |
August 11
|
| Category:Female critics of feminism |
keep |
August 26
|
| Fictional hairdressers |
merge Category:Fictional barbers to Category:Fictional hairdressers. No consensus to do the same for Category:Fictional beauticians |
August 23
|
| Category:Films about Roman Catholicism |
relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 September 6#Category:Films about Roman Catholicism. – |
August 29
|
| Category:Films about special forces |
no consensus |
August 23
|
| Category:Films about special forces |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 23#Category:Films about special forces |
August 12
|
| Category:Films critical of Roman Catholicism and Catholics |
rename |
August 19
|
| Category:Final Solution |
Merge |
August 24
|
| Category:Flora of West Africa |
merge |
August 30
|
| Category:Flora of West Africa |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 30#Category:Flora of West Africa |
August 7
|
| Category:Former members of Roman Catholic religious institutes |
Rename |
August 5
|
| Category:Founders of Roman Catholic religious communities |
Rename |
August 5
|
| Category:Frankish warriors |
keep |
August 1
|
| Category:Free Linux distributions |
relisted with alternative at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 September 11#Category:Free Linux distributions. – |
August 27
|
| Category:Free Linux distributions |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 27#Category:Free Linux distributions |
August 17
|
| Georgia (country) user categories |
keep |
August 7
|
| Category:German Resistance |
Rename Option A |
August 31
|
| Category:Grammy Award winners for Album of the Year |
rename |
August 8
|
| Category:Graphs of vertices 32 |
Delete |
August 15
|
| Guam renames |
Rename most, others can be nominated separately immediately if needs be. Most of these are straightforward and the handful of exceptions are best handled without distraction |
August 21
|
| Category:Guests on Dr. Phil (talk show) |
Delete |
August 30
|
| Category:HD 176051 |
merge (non-admin closure) |
August 2
|
| Category:Health organisations in the Netherlands |
Merge |
August 30
|
| Category:Health sciences schools in Malaysia |
merge. (non-admin closure) |
August 25
|
| Category:Healthcare industry in India |
merge. – |
August 29
|
| Category:Healthcare industry in Pakistan |
merge. – |
August 29
|
| Category:Heritage railways in Hong Kong |
no consensus |
August 15
|
| Category:Heritage railways in Japan |
keep |
August 15
|
| Category:Hindi films based on actual events |
rename to Category:Hindi-language films based on actual events |
August 18
|
| Category:Hong Kong Association for Democracy and People's Livelihood |
delete. – |
August 8
|
| Category:Hospitals affiliated with the Roman Catholic Church |
Rename |
August 5
|
| Category:Hospitals formerly affiliated with the Roman Catholic Church |
Rename |
August 5
|
| Category:Housing struggles in Brazil |
merge as nominated |
August 7
|
| Category:Housing struggles in South Africa |
merge |
August 17
|
| Category:Housing struggles |
rename to Category:Housing protests |
August 27
|
| Category:Humane Societies by country |
already renamed as nominated at close, but could be renominated for merging if desired |
August 22
|
| Category:Imperial election |
Rename |
August 15
|
| Category:Instagram connect |
speedily deleted under WP:G2. – |
August 24
|
| Category:Institutes of Roman Catholic religious brothers |
Rename |
August 5
|
| Category:International science fiction conventions |
delete (non-admin closure) |
August 13
|
| Category:Iranian Esperanto Association |
delete with selective upmerge to parents where appropriate. – |
August 13
|
| Isotopes by element |
no consensus, though leaning towards keep |
August 15
|
| Category:Jewish mathematicians who died in the Holocaust |
no consensus |
August 26
|
| Category:Jewish mathematicians who died in the Holocaust |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 26#Category:Jewish mathematicians who died in the Holocaust |
August 11
|
| Category:Jewish Nazi collaboration |
rename |
August 10
|
| Category:Jewish Nazi collaborators |
rename |
August 10
|
| Category:Jewish resistance fighters |
rename to Category:Jewish resistance members during the Holocaust |
August 10
|
| Category:Jews and Judaism in the Byzantine Empire |
reverse merge (option B) |
August 23
|
| Category:Ken Dodd |
delete. – |
August 22
|
| Category:Kwame Nkrumah University |
delete (non-admin closure) |
August 18
|
| Category:LGBT scientists of color |
delete (non-admin closure) |
August 3
|
| Category:Ligurian Republic |
no consensus |
August 23
|
| Category:Lists of comics by Marvel Comics |
no consensus |
August 28
|
| Category:Lists of comics by Marvel Comics |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 28#Category:Lists of comics by Marvel Comics |
August 14
|
| Category:Lists of popes, primates, and patriarchs |
Keep |
August 26
|
| Category:Lists of Roman Catholic popes |
rename to Category:Lists of Catholic popes |
August 26
|
| Local municipalities of South Africa hierarchy |
Rename |
August 29
|
| Loyola Lions football |
rename |
August 18
|
| Category:Male critics of feminism |
keep |
August 26
|
| Category:Mayors of Gowrie, Iowa |
dual merge (non-admin closure) |
August 21
|
| Category:Medical Colleges in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa |
rename to Category:Medical colleges in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. – |
August 13
|
| Category:Medical schools in Pakistan |
Rename |
August 28
|
| Medieval and Early Modern Switzerland |
merge |
August 16
|
| Medieval Germany |
merge and delete |
August 12
|
| Medieval Italy, Venice, Florence, Genoa, Papal States, Naples, Sicily |
Merge |
August 26
|
| Medieval military history by year |
withdrawn |
August 19
|
| Medieval politics |
merge |
August 11
|
| Category:Members of the Department of Applied Mathematics and Theoretical Physics |
rename to Category:Cambridge mathematicians, though admittedly consensus was not strong in this case, though it was strong that some change had to be made. There seems to be support for renaming this to Category:Cambridge University mathematicians. This could be pursued in a follow-up nomination |
August 25
|
| Category:Members of the Department of Pure Mathematics and Mathematical Statistics |
merge as proposed. This result was chosen to match the result of the nomination immediately above |
August 25
|
| Metropolitan boroughs |
rename using "Metropolitan Borough of", see full list at end of discussion. – |
August 21
|
| Metropolitan boroughs |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 21#Metropolitan boroughs |
August 3
|
| Category:Mito branch |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 September 1#Category:Mito branch |
August 21
|
| Category:Mittelbau-Dora |
rename |
August 28
|
| Category:Mont Pelerin Society members |
Delete |
August 7
|
| Category:Monuments in Nepal |
rename and merge |
August 4
|
| Category:Multidisciplinary Digital Publishing Institute academic journals |
rename |
August 3
|
| Category:Musicians from Takatsuki, Osaka |
merge. (non-admin closure) |
August 30
|
| Category:National Heroes of Barbados |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 28#Category:National Heroes of Barbados |
August 14
|
| Category:National Heroes of Barbados |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 September 5#Category:National Heroes of Barbados |
August 28
|
| Category:Nazis accused of war crimes |
delete |
August 4
|
| Category:Nepalese people |
no consensus. Given the weak support for this rename and the opposition in the nomination directly below, I simply cannot see a valid consensus in renaming either. If a separate nomination is sought, I suggest making a batch nomination for better participation |
August 31
|
| Category:Nepalese people |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 31#Category:Nepalese people |
August 7
|
| Category:Nepalese VFX artist |
upmerge (non-admin closure) |
August 7
|
| Category:Nepalese Wikipedians |
no consensus. See discussion directly above |
August 31
|
| Category:Nepalese Wikipedians |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 31#Category:Nepalese Wikipedians |
August 7
|
| Category:New areas at state level |
rename to Category:New areas (China). – |
August 9
|
| Category:Northern Pacific Railway stations in Washington (state) |
delete |
August 4
|
| Category:NXT teams and stables |
Rename |
August 29
|
| Category:One-location films |
convert to list. – |
August 15
|
| Category:Orders, decorations, and medals |
do not split |
August 23
|
| Category:Orthodox Christians in the German Resistance |
delete. The two articles are already within both category trees Category:Eastern Orthodox Christians opposed to Nazi Germany and Category:German Resistance members |
August 14
|
| Category:Orthodox Knights of the Holy Sepulchre |
convert to list and delete. The list is initially at Greek_Orthodox_Church_of_Jerusalem#Orthodox_Knights_of_the_Holy_Sepulchre. – |
August 9
|
| Category:Owari branch |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 September 1#Category:Owari branch |
August 21
|
| Palestine |
Rename |
August 11
|
| Category:Pan-European advocacy groups |
rename to Category:Cross-European advocacy groups |
August 15
|
| Category:Peak body organisations |
merge to Category:Advocacy groups in Australia |
August 8
|
| Category:People associated with 3D printing |
rename |
August 25
|
| Category:People associated with Anonymous |
rename, removing only Parmy Olson as the other nine appear to fall within the revised scope. I will move Olson up the parent category as her reporting on the group appears to be defining for her at the moment. – |
August 25
|
| Category:People associated with Archaeological Survey of India |
Rename |
August 26
|
| Category:People associated with Conway Hall Ethical Society |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 September 4#Category:People associated with Conway Hall Ethical Society |
August 13
|
| Category:People associated with Junimea |
rename to Category:Junimists |
August 14
|
| Category:People associated with Pluto |
Delete |
August 27
|
| Category:People associated with the anti-austerity movement |
Delete |
August 25
|
| Category:People associated with the Bengal Renaissance |
delete |
August 23
|
| Category:People excommunicated by the Roman Catholic Church |
rename |
August 5
|
| Category:People from Amorium |
keep for now, as there is no consensus below to do away with the category, although some editors were open to possible mergers. It might be worth re-nominating this after a suitable interval, for possible merger to Category:Amorium and Category:Byzantine Anatolians. For the record, the only current members are Blaise of Amorion and Michael II; Constantine V was removed during the discussion for the reasons stated below. – |
August 27
|
| Category:People from Amorium |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 27#Category:People from Amorium |
August 17
|
| Category:People from Economy, Pennsylvania |
merge (non-admin closure) |
August 4
|
| Category:People from Russellton, Pennsylvania |
merge (non-admin closure) |
August 4
|
| Category:People from Salford (district) |
Rename |
August 29
|
| Category:People from Salford, Greater Manchester |
Rename |
August 29
|
| Category:People from Wilmerding, Pennsylvania |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 September 1#Category:People from Wilmerding, Pennsylvania |
August 21
|
| Category:People whose birthplace is disputed |
delete. – |
August 25
|
| Category:Perceived judicial activism in the United States |
Delete |
August 26
|
| Category:Performing arts companies disestablished in 2017 |
Delete |
August 13
|
| Category:Perso-Indian people |
Delete |
August 23
|
| Category:Places in New Jersey that prohibit the sale of alcohol |
listify and delete |
August 6
|
| Category:Places of the Euromaidan |
delete |
August 14
|
| Category:Plants described in the 1750s |
delete (non-admin closure) |
August 26
|
| Category:Polish resistance fighters of World War II |
rename to Category:Polish resistance members of World War II |
August 14
|
| Category:Polish resistance fighters |
rename |
August 18
|
| Category:Political prisoners in Venezuela |
Merge to Category:Prisoners and detainees of Venezuela |
August 15
|
| Category:Possible cut-and-paste moves |
delete (non-admin closure) |
August 10
|
| Category:Presidents of IEA |
Merge |
August 5
|
| Category:Protestants in the German Resistance |
keep |
August 29
|
| Category:Protostomes of French Guiana |
Merge |
August 26
|
| Category:Railway schools |
Keep |
August 12
|
| Category:Ramapo Community College alumni |
delete (non-admin closure) |
August 14
|
| Category:Reactors (React media franchise) |
delete |
August 31
|
| Category:Recipients of the clasp to the Iron Cross, 1st class |
no consensus |
August 14
|
| Category:Recipients of the Distinguished Flying Cross (United States) |
no consensus |
August 2
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of the Cross of Liberty, 4th Class |
Delete |
August 13
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of the Cross of Liberty, Medal of Liberty 2nd Class |
no action required (non-admin closure) |
August 14
|
| Renaming establishments by century from "Roman Catholic" to "Catholic" (17 categories) |
Rename |
August 5
|
| Category:Rivers of the Gippsland |
Rename |
August 26
|
| Category:Rocky Mountain Showdown |
delete (non-admin closure) |
August 1
|
| Category:Roman Catholic Apostolic Prefectures |
rename as nominated |
August 14
|
| Category:Roman Catholic cardinals by X |
consensus to rename, but no consensus on which form, so defaulting to not including disambiguated form since other similar categories do not include the disambiguator. A fresh nomination dedicated to this issue could be had |
August 25
|
| Category:Roman Catholic cardinals |
rename to Category:Cardinals (Catholic Church) |
August 5
|
| Category:Roman Catholic church in fiction |
Rename |
August 5
|
| Category:Roman Catholic church in Overseas France |
Rename |
August 5
|
| Category:Roman Catholic church in the Northern Territory |
Rename |
August 5
|
| Category:Roman Catholic Church sex abuse cases in North America |
rename |
August 5
|
| Category:Roman Catholic Church sex abuse scandal in Oceania |
Rename |
August 5
|
| Category:Roman Catholic media |
rename |
August 19
|
| Category:Roman Catholic newspapers and magazines in Italy |
rename |
August 19
|
| Category:Roman Catholic newspapers and magazines in the United States |
rename |
August 19
|
| Category:Roman Catholic novels |
rename. Considerations for deletion can be addressed in a separate nomination |
August 19
|
| Category:Roman Catholic nursing orders |
Rename |
August 5
|
| Category:Roman Catholic personal coat of arms images |
rename |
August 19
|
| Category:Roman Catholic radio programs |
rename |
August 19
|
| Category:Roman Catholic radio |
rename |
August 19
|
| Category:Roman Catholic television channels |
rename |
August 19
|
| Category:Roman Catholic television networks |
rename |
August 19
|
| Category:Roman Catholic television series |
rename |
August 19
|
| Category:Roman Catholic television |
rename |
August 19
|
| Category:S.H.E members |
keep. – |
August 9
|
| Category:Science fiction in Poland |
speedy rename C2C. – |
August 29
|
| Category:Science fiction media conventions |
merge where necessary to Category:Science fiction conventions or subcats by location. PetScan shows that only 5 member pages are not already within Category:Science fiction conventions by location. – |
August 13
|
| Category:Serbs of Bosnia and Herzegovina convicted of genocide |
keep |
August 4
|
| Category:Ships of the State of the Slovenes, Croats and Serbs Navy |
delete. Consensus here is that a ship being part of this short-lived navy is not a defining characteristic |
August 29
|
| Category:Singapore education navigational boxes |
Delete |
August 30
|
| Category:Singaporean Wikipedians |
keep (non-admin closure) |
August 31
|
| Category:Singaporean Wikipedians |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 31#Category:Singaporean Wikipedians |
August 7
|
| Category:Smilodon |
procedural close and repopulate, as it was emptied out of process by the nominator, and the page was never tagged with a link to this discussion. – |
August 13
|
| Category:Social economists |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 31#Category:Social economists |
August 7
|
| Category:Social economists |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 October 1#Category:Social economists |
August 31
|
| Category:Socialist economists |
keep |
August 8
|
| Category:Songs about the Gaels |
delete |
August 17
|
| Category:Songs written by Ant Whiting |
keep without prejudice against starting a broader discussion about Category:Songs by songwriter. (non-admin closure) |
August 22
|
| Category:Songs written by Greeeen |
Delete |
August 26
|
| Category:Songs written by Greeeen |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 26#Category:Songs written by Greeeen |
August 11
|
| Category:Southern jaguars |
delete by merger to Category:Jaguars for the single remaining page. @SilverTiger12: please do not empty categories out-of-process again, nor blank the category pages, but use CFD and wait for the discussion to close. Disclosure: I am closing this discussion to put it out of its misery; although I commented, I consider myself not WP:INVOLVED in this one. – |
August 25
|
| Category:Steel Mills in Karachi |
merge |
August 7
|
| Category:Sugar substitutes |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 September 1#Category:Sugar substitutes |
August 21
|
| Category:Survivors in the United States |
delete |
August 18
|
| Category:Syarif Hidayatullah State Islamic University Jakarta |
Delete |
August 23
|
| Taiwan user categories |
keep. (non-admin closure) |
August 31
|
| Taiwan user categories |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 31#Taiwan user categories |
August 7
|
| Category:TCU Horned Frogs tennis |
Rename |
August 2
|
| Category:Teachers colleges |
no consensus |
August 26
|
| Category:Teachers colleges |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 26#Category:Teachers colleges |
August 11
|
| Category:Territorial prelatures of the Roman Catholic Church |
rename to Category:Territorial prelatures |
August 5
|
| Category:Towns in the Gippsland |
Rename |
August 26
|
| Category:Ultra high-net-worth individuals |
Delete |
August 14
|
| Category:United Nations non-governmental organizations |
rename to Category:Non-governmental organizations with consultative status at the United Nations (option C below, non-abbreviated form of option E which also had support). – |
August 18
|
| Category:Urban sprawl |
merge to Category:Urbanization |
August 16
|
| Category:Vandalized works of art in Washington (state) |
merge to Category:Vandalized works of art in the United States |
August 7
|
| Category:Voting lobby groups |
rename to Category:Electoral reform groups |
August 8
|
| Category:WEF YGL honorees |
delete |
August 10
|
| Category:Whaling jobs |
merge. As noted in the discussion, there is not a sufficient amount of content here to justify the category at this moment, and there is no loss of categorization within the job articles |
August 1
|
| Category:Wikipedia articles with style issues |
repurpose Category:Wikipedia articles with style issues as parent of Category:Wikipedia articles with style issues by issue and rename Category:Wikipedia articles needing style editing to Category:Wikipedia articles with style issues by month, and its contents likewise. – |
August 18
|
| Category:Wikipedia articles with style issues |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 18#Category:Wikipedia articles with style issues |
August 1
|
| Category:Wikipedia images of Roman Catholic coat of arms |
rename |
August 19
|
| Category:Wikipedian document markup users |
rename to Category:Wikipedians by markup language and purge articles held directly in the category. – |
August 25
|
| Category:Wikipedian feeling discouraged |
Rename |
August 21
|
| Category:Wikipedians who consider themselves participants in all wikiprojects |
delete |
August 26
|
| Category:Wikipedians who consider themselves participants in all wikiprojects |
Relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 26#Category:Wikipedians who consider themselves participants in all wikiprojects |
August 11
|
| Category:WikiProject Philippines members |
keep (non-admin closure) |
August 7
|
| Category:Wildlife of Shetland |
Rename |
August 12
|
| Category:Wildlife of Sumatra |
Rename |
August 24
|
| Category:Wildlife of Yunnan |
Rename |
August 24
|
| Category:Women by association |
split to Category:Women and Category:Women by organization |
August 25
|
| Category:World Day of Prayer |
Delete |
August 24
|
| Category:WOW air |
no consensus |
August 13
|
| Category:Zamenhof-Esperanto objects |
delete. Headcount has this discussion split down the middle. However, the weight of the arguments ultimately tipped the discussion to delete per WP:SHAREDNAME. Categories are meant to group pages together by shared characteristics that are defining of their subjects; a share name simply does not suffice to satisfy this aspect of categorization. The content is allowed to be listed elsewhere on Wikipedia, simply not through a category |
August 6
|
