Whole-process people's democracy

For the Marxism–Leninism concept, see People's democracy (Marxism–Leninism).

Whole-process people's democracy (Chinese: 全过程人民民主; pinyin: Quán guòchéng rénmín mínzhǔ), formerly termed whole-process democracy (全过程民主; Quán guòchéng mínzhǔ), is a Chinese Communist Party (CCP) political concept describing the people's participation in, and relationship to, governance under socialism with Chinese characteristics. Whole-process people's democracy differs from liberal democracy in that it is a consequentialist model of political decision-making, aiming to be judged by how well the government is able to improve the socioeconomic lives of citizens, rather than being based on democratic processes.

Development of the term

The term whole-process people's democracy developed in distinct stages. Narratives of a CCP-style "democracy" and democracy in Marxism have evolved in CCP's language since its founding.

First, the term "whole-process democracy" was used to describe existing governance practices such as Chinese experiments with democratic elements in the legislative process and in local government activities. CCP general secretary Xi Jinping first used the term publicly on November 2, 2019, while visiting the Shanghai grassroots consultative center for the National People's Congress (NPC). Xi stated, "China's people's democracy is a type of whole-process democracy" in which legislation is enacted "after going through procedures and democratic deliberations to ensure that decision-making is sound and democratic."

Second, the term "whole process democracy" was incorporated into Chinese law in March 2021. The NPC passed the Decision on Amending the Organic Law of the NPC, which incorporated "adherence to whole process democracy." The NPC viewed whole-process democracy as an area where it could make significant contributions. As a result, the NPC led a national campaign (in which local people's congresses at all levels participated) to promote the principle. The CCP then incorporated the concept into its ideology, promoting it and explaining it as an improved model of socialist democracy suited for the needs of the 21st century.

On July 1, 2021, Xi incorporated the word "people's" into the term during his speech at the 100th Anniversary of the Chinese Communist Party, giving the new name: "whole-process people's democracy." Xi tied the term to "common prosperity." The addition of "people's" to the term emphasizes the Maoist practice of the mass line.

Theory

Xi describes four components of whole-process people's democracy, expressed as paired relationships:

1. Process democracy (过程民主) and achievement democracy (成果民主)
2. Procedural democracy (程序民主) and substantive democracy (实质民主)
3. Direct democracy (直接民主) and indirect democracy (间接民主)
4. People's democracy (人民民主) and the will of the state (国家意志)

According to Xi, this results in "real and effective socialist democracy."

The concept's emphasis on "whole-process" is intended to further distinguish the CCP approach to democracy from the procedural qualities of liberal democracy. It includes primarily consequentialist criteria for evaluating claims of democracy's success. In this view, the most important criterion is whether democracy can "solve the people's real problems," while a system in which "the people are awakened only for voting" is not truly democratic.

Whole-process people's democracy also serves as a political tool to both defend the Chinese government's governance practices and criticize liberal democracy. In the CCP's view, whole-process people's democracy is "more extensive, more genuine and more effective" than American democracy. Under the concept of whole-process people's democracy, whether a country is democratic should not be measured by the electoral process but instead by the results it delivers to the people. By using the improvement of living standards and development as the measure of democratic success, this framing favors China, which has undergone major advances in development and living standards during the last four decades.

The CCP uses the concept of whole-process people's democracy as a means to participate in global discourses on democracy, seeking to deflect criticism and improve its foreign relations. This ties into the government's larger efforts to promote its global leadership.

In that regard, the Chinese government's 2021 white paper China: A Democracy that Works emphasizes the whole-process people's democracy perspective in an effort to demonstrate the country's "institutional self-confidence." Zubeda Anjum Niazi argues that the white paper states that whole-process people's democracy is the impetus behind China's development and growth. In another example of the government's promotion of the whole-process people's democracy concept in an effort to increase its "discourse power," then-Ambassador to the United States Qin Gang gave remarks at a conference organized by U.S. thinktanks the Carter Center and The George H.W. Bush Foundation for US-China Relations, in which he stated, "Isn't it obvious that both China's people-center philosophy and President Lincoln's 'of the people, by the people, for the people' are for the sake of the people? [...] Shall we understand China's socialist whole-process democracy as this: from the people, to the people, with the people, for the people?"

See also

• Democracy in China
• Ideology of the Chinese Communist Party
• People's democracy (Marxism–Leninism)