User talk:Mecheng761/Zishan Engineers

RE: Request for input

I looked the article and recent news related to the awarding of a $800 million Letter of Intent for project management consultancy services of three projects, I think that the company is notable to have its own article. However, I think that before moving it back to its own article page, it still needs some work. As you have not given clear permission to edit this page, I will make just few comments at the talk page here.

The page needs overall cleanup. There are still some promotional tone and lot of background information which may have some relevance, but probably does not belongs here.

References should be improved. Although the total number of references is quite significant, there are large parts of text without providing any sources. Also, among the references there are some dead links and some references does not prove thge information after what they are added. By may understanding improving of references is one of the main tasks here.

Structure. I think that this article needs also a section called 'Operations' or 'Activities'. At the same time, I don't think that 'Upcoming Projects & News' is a proper section title. This information should be included in 'History' and 'Operations' sections. Information about the recent controversy should be expanded and be in separate section called 'Controversies' or having more specific title.

Formatting issues

As the company infobox skeleton used in this article is out of date, I suggest to copy new skeleton from the template's documentation page here. I would also like to note that according to the agreed policy, company infoboxes should not have flag icons included.

For references, I propose to use {{Cite web}}, {{Cite news}} and similar templates. Please try to provide all available information for the references.

Good luck for the editing. Beagel (talk) 16:47, 28 January 2012 (UTC)[reply]

Thanks Beagle,

I would try to address these issues and then put it on the main page. I would try to remove unneccesary links as well. Mecheng761 (talk) 20:48, 28 January 2012 (UTC)[reply]

Zishan Engineers Article

I have tried to access the issues and have moved the article for AFC. I had troubles using the Cite News for the news links. I would appreciate your input on the AFC page so that others reviewing it could have a better insight. Your input would be important since you had initially filed it for Afd. Mecheng761 (talk) 21:19, 28 January 2012 (UTC)[reply]