Jump to content

Sovfoto: Difference between revisions

Add links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous editNext edit →
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
→Archive: Alsop
→Archive: Hellman script
Line 27: Line 27:
: "The Sovfoto archive is of unquestionable status....Many of the photographs stand out as artistically remarkable and strong images as well as documentation of the human experience... The Sovfoto archive presents a visual depository for rich [[Interdisciplinarity|interdisciplinary studies]], including photography, sociology, psychology and history...The annotations on the back of each photograph further enables the researcher to delve into invaluable historical layers of knowledge that would require a long time to find in other sources...The Sovfoto archive is the only one of its kind in North America."
: "The Sovfoto archive is of unquestionable status....Many of the photographs stand out as artistically remarkable and strong images as well as documentation of the human experience... The Sovfoto archive presents a visual depository for rich [[Interdisciplinarity|interdisciplinary studies]], including photography, sociology, psychology and history...The annotations on the back of each photograph further enables the researcher to delve into invaluable historical layers of knowledge that would require a long time to find in other sources...The Sovfoto archive is the only one of its kind in North America."


The Sovfoto photographs present the state-sanctioned, propagandistic<ref name=":1">{{Cite web|title=How Photos Became a Weapon in Stalin’s Great Purge - HISTORY|url=https://www.history.com/news/josef-stalin-great-purge-photo-retouching|access-date=2020-10-08|website=www.history.com}}</ref><ref>{{Cite web|title=Olexander Wlasenko Curatorial Essay - Broken Promises: Soviet Photography in the Age of Stalin|url=http://www.olexander.ca/brokenpromises.html|access-date=2020-10-08|website=www.olexander.ca}}</ref> promotion of the progress and achievements of communism. In 1950 ''Newsweek'' generated controversy around a Sovfoto picture of 70-year old Prime Minister [[Joseph Stalin|Stalin]] casting his ballot for the March 12 Soviet elections; they showed that a head shot of Stalin from years before had been 'simply pasted' into the news photo.<ref>'Paste-up job seen in Stalin photo,' Chattanooga Daily Times, Friday 24 Mar 1950, p.9</ref> Conversely, in 1956, [[Stewart Alsop]] in ''[[The Courier-Journal]]'' demonstrated how reliable information on Soviet weapons programs could be obtained from Sovfoto images. The magazine ''[[Aviation Week & Space Technology|Aviation Week]]'' was called to [[The Pentagon]] for publishing 'top secret' photographs of flights over Moscow by the new Soviet heavy bomber, the [[Myasishchev M-4|Bison]], the existence of which had been denied as 'fake' by Secretary of Defense [[Charles Edward Wilson (businessman)|Charles E. Wilson]], to which charge the ''Aviation Week'' editor protested that they had simply obtained the pictures from Sovfoto.<ref>Stewart Alsop, 'Intelligence Data Need Not Depend On Fair Spies,' ''The Courier-Journal'' Sat, Apr 14, 1956, p.8</ref>
The Sovfoto photographs present the state-sanctioned, propagandistic<ref name=":1">{{Cite web|title=How Photos Became a Weapon in Stalin’s Great Purge - HISTORY|url=https://www.history.com/news/josef-stalin-great-purge-photo-retouching|access-date=2020-10-08|website=www.history.com}}</ref><ref>{{Cite web|title=Olexander Wlasenko Curatorial Essay - Broken Promises: Soviet Photography in the Age of Stalin|url=http://www.olexander.ca/brokenpromises.html|access-date=2020-10-08|website=www.olexander.ca}}</ref> promotion of the progress and achievements of communism. In 1950 ''Newsweek'' generated controversy around a Sovfoto picture of 70-year old Prime Minister [[Joseph Stalin|Stalin]] casting his ballot for the March 12 Soviet elections; they showed that a head shot of Stalin from years before had been 'simply pasted' into the news photo.<ref>'Paste-up job seen in Stalin photo,' Chattanooga Daily Times, Friday 24 Mar 1950, p.9</ref> Conversely, in 1956, [[Stewart Alsop]] in ''[[The Courier-Journal]]'' demonstrated how reliable information on Soviet weapons programs could be obtained from Sovfoto images. The magazine ''[[Aviation Week & Space Technology|Aviation Week]]'' was called to [[The Pentagon]] for publishing 'top secret' photographs of flights over Moscow by the new Soviet heavy bomber, the [[Myasishchev M-4|Bison]], the existence of which had been denied as 'fake' by Secretary of Defense [[Charles Edward Wilson (businessman)|Charles E. Wilson]], to which charge the ''Aviation Week'' editor protested that they had simply obtained the pictures from Sovfoto.<ref>Stewart Alsop, 'Intelligence Data Need Not Depend On Fair Spies,' ''The Courier-Journal'' Sat, Apr 14, 1956, p.8</ref> When [[Lillian Hellman]] was writing the screenplay for [[The North Star (1943 film)|''The North Star'']] she relied on Sovfoto location pictures for the recreation of Ukrainian cooperative [[Kamianets-Podilskyi|Kamenetz Podolsk]].<ref>[[Erskine Johnson]], ''[[Poughkeepsie Journal]]'' Thursday 04 Mar 1943, p.14</ref>


Nevertheless, they also constitute historical record. At the outbreak of World War II, many Soviet photographers became [[war correspondent]]s, incorporating the photographic invention of the [[Russian Revolution|revolutionary]] [[avant-garde]] in documenting the lives and deaths of Russian troops, conflict, destruction and German [[German war crimes|atrocities]]. During the [[Korean War]], Eastfoto images of American [[Prisoner of war|POW]]'s distributed by Sovfoto led to the identification of at least two of the US combatants pictured.<ref>'Mother recognizes son in N. Korean POW photo,' Fort Worth Star-Telegram, Friday 22 Sep 1950, p.2</ref>
Nevertheless, they also constitute historical record. At the outbreak of World War II, many Soviet photographers became [[war correspondent]]s, incorporating the photographic invention of the [[Russian Revolution|revolutionary]] [[avant-garde]] in documenting the lives and deaths of Russian troops, conflict, destruction and German [[German war crimes|atrocities]]. During the [[Korean War]], Eastfoto images of American [[Prisoner of war|POW]]'s distributed by Sovfoto led to the identification of at least two of the US combatants pictured.<ref>'Mother recognizes son in N. Korean POW photo,' Fort Worth Star-Telegram, Friday 22 Sep 1950, p.2</ref>

Revision as of 01:14, 9 October 2020

Sovfoto was established in 1932 as the only agency to represent Soviet photojournalism in America.[1][2] It continues today as a commercial entity Sovfoto/Eastfoto. Collections from its archive are held also at MacLaren Art Centre in Barrie, Canada which in 2001 was donated 23,116 vintage gelatin silver prints dating from 1936 to 1957,[3][4] while Amhurst University holds the Tass Sovfoto Photograph Collection, 1919–1963, the majority being from 1943–1963.[5]

Establishment

Sovfoto agency was originally established by the USSR in New York in the early 1930s to distribute Soviet press photography throughout North America.[4] After 1941 Sovfoto received photographs, on consignment, from the Sovinformburo (Совинформбюро), culled from TASS.

Clientele

All were printed, and often retouched,[6] in the USSR with English captions as they were intended for a North American audience.[7][8] Associated Press and International New Services and other major wire agencies paid a subscription fee to license the material, and offered it to illustrated magazines like Life, Time and Newsweek and Look, to newspapers,[9] and also to communist-aligned and communist-sympathetic publications, as well as selling to the State Department and various branches of the Armed Forces as the only source of regular visual reportage on the Soviet Union.[4]

Three Sovfoto pictures appeared (credited to the agency) in MoMA's 1955 exhibition curated by Edward Steichen, The Family of Man. Sponsored by America's own propaganda unit the United States Information Agency, it toured the world and was attended by 9 million visitors. It was included in the Moscow trade fair at Sokolniki Park, the scene of Soviet Premier Nikita Khrushchev and United States Vice President Richard Nixon's 'Kitchen Debate' over the relative merits of communism and capitalism.[10][11]

New York office

After World War II, Sovfoto continued, adding imagery from Eastern European countries of the Communist bloc as well as China. The agency started doing business as Sovfoto/Eastfoto in the late 1940s, moving offices several times under a series of American owners, including Helen Black (at 11 West Forty-second Street, New York City 18, then 15 West 44th Street) up to 1952, Edwin S. Smith to 1964 (at 24 West 45th Street), then Liuba Solov at 25 West 43rd Street. Solov managed the business until 1974 when Leah Siegel took ownership, moving in 1987 to 225 West 34th Street Suite 1505, and employing Victoria Edwards who bought the company in the early 1990s. Edwards’ son Vanya took over upon her retirement and is the current owner/manager.

McCarthy-era suspicions

As a Communist bloc agency, Sovfoto came under suspicion during the McCarthy era. When Sovfoto released photographs of purported biological warfare committed by the Americans, the then-owner Edwin Smith was brought before the House Un-American Activities Committee to testify on his role in their publication.[12] At the time of his ownership as ‘Foreign Principal’, the Report of the Attorney General to the Congress of the United States on the Administration of the Foreign Agents Registration Act of 1938 as Amended June 1951, for the Calendar Year 1955, notes that ‘Propaganda photographs (for the U.S.S.R.) are distributed by Edwin S. Smith, doing business under the name of Sovfoto Agency’ as well as ‘propaganda material from Communist China’.[13] Smith (1891–1975) was owner and manager of Am-Rus Literary and Music Agency, also Sovfoto and Eastfoto Agency from 1952–64, and represented legations and press and photo agencies Mezhdunarodnaja Kniga, Moscow; Czechopress, Prague; China Photo Service, Peking; Agerpress, Bucharest; Zentral Bild, East Berlin; Hungarian Review Photo Service (formerly Hungarian Bulletin), Budapest; Legation of the Hungarian People's Republic; Czechoslovakian Embassy; Legation of the People's Republic of Rumania; Polish Embassy; Czechoslovak Life, Prague; Cartimex (previously Centrul de Librarii Si Difuzare a Cartii "IMEX"), Bucharest; and Artia, Prague. The agency received $40,872.75 from sale of photographs in 1955.[14]

Current operation

Until the fall of the Communist/Soviet bloc, Sovfoto remained the exclusive legitimate source of news photography from the Communist countries and it continues to represent ITAR-TASS in Russia and Xinhua in China and others, while maintaining the historical archive. The Agency continues to operate from 263 West 20th St. #3 New York 10011 under the management of Vanya Edwards.[15]

Archive

The Sovfoto archive is of high historical and social value in representing perspectives from the other side of the Iron Curtain. It holds the largest collection of photographs of Stalinist USSR outside of the state archives in Moscow. Furthermore, it includes images of Russia from the time of the Tsars, through Lenin, Stalin, Khrushchev, Gorbachev, and Yeltsin, World War II and Militaria and a wide range of areas from Soviet society. Dr. Margarita Tupitsyn, curator and author of The Soviet Photograph, 1924–1937[16] wrote:

"The Sovfoto archive is of unquestionable status....Many of the photographs stand out as artistically remarkable and strong images as well as documentation of the human experience... The Sovfoto archive presents a visual depository for rich interdisciplinary studies, including photography, sociology, psychology and history...The annotations on the back of each photograph further enables the researcher to delve into invaluable historical layers of knowledge that would require a long time to find in other sources...The Sovfoto archive is the only one of its kind in North America."

The Sovfoto photographs present the state-sanctioned, propagandistic[6][17] promotion of the progress and achievements of communism. In 1950 Newsweek generated controversy around a Sovfoto picture of 70-year old Prime Minister Stalin casting his ballot for the March 12 Soviet elections; they showed that a head shot of Stalin from years before had been 'simply pasted' into the news photo.[18] Conversely, in 1956, Stewart Alsop in The Courier-Journal demonstrated how reliable information on Soviet weapons programs could be obtained from Sovfoto images. The magazine Aviation Week was called to The Pentagon for publishing 'top secret' photographs of flights over Moscow by the new Soviet heavy bomber, the Bison, the existence of which had been denied as 'fake' by Secretary of Defense Charles E. Wilson, to which charge the Aviation Week editor protested that they had simply obtained the pictures from Sovfoto.[19] When Lillian Hellman was writing the screenplay for The North Star she relied on Sovfoto location pictures for the recreation of Ukrainian cooperative Kamenetz Podolsk.[20]

Nevertheless, they also constitute historical record. At the outbreak of World War II, many Soviet photographers became war correspondents, incorporating the photographic invention of the revolutionary avant-garde in documenting the lives and deaths of Russian troops, conflict, destruction and German atrocities. During the Korean War, Eastfoto images of American POW's distributed by Sovfoto led to the identification of at least two of the US combatants pictured.[21]

The photographers

The archive contains images taken by many anonymous photographers, as well as the foremost Soviet photographers, documenting a period of history in the twentieth century which has had a very lasting impact. After the crackdown of 1932, many of the Soviet Union's leading avant-garde photographers found that their only available means of expression was press photography. The Sovfoto archive includes images from many Soviet photographers who have become historically important:

Photographer birth death work
Max Alpert (Maks Al'pert) 1899 1980 for "Pravda", made portraits of major Soviet and many foreign politicians, military and writers; during the Great Patriotic War was a TASS correspondent and Information Bureau in the rear and at the front, in a combat situation. His most famous photograph "Combat" became a symbol of the Soviet war. Postwar years contributed to various publications and was the lead photographer for the press agency "Novosti".
Dmitri Baltermans 1912 1990 official Kremlin photographer, worked for Izvestia, picture editor of Ogonyok; in World War II, covered the Battle of Stalingrad, and the battles of the Red Army in Russia and Ukraine. Twice wounded. "Grief", depicts village women as they search for the bodies of their loved ones after 1942 Nazi massacre of Jews in the Crimean city of Kerch.
D. Samson Cernov 1887 1929 Balkan War and World War I 1912–18, Serbian Retreat.
Mark Markov-Grinberg 1907 2006 first worked on Sovyetski Yug ('Soviet South') 1925, freelancer for Ogonyok, then in Moscow, on numerous trade union newspapers.
Samary Mikhailovitch Gurary (Samarii Gurarii) 1916 1998 portrait of Stalin, Roosevelt and Churchill at the Yalta Conference appeared on the front page of Pravda 13 Feb 1945
Boris Vsevolodovich Ignatovich 1889 1976 press photographer on Bednota, appears in Sovetskoe Foto, Sovremennaia arkhitektura, Radioslushatel and Illiustrirovannaia rabochaia gazeta. Cinematographer during 1930s. In WW2, Western and Bryansk fronts, Potsdam Declaration, military photographer until 1950 then worked for Ogonyok, Pravda, Izogiz, Stroiizdat, and Zhurnal mod
Yevgeny Khaldei 1917 1997 Dnieper Dam project and its worker hero Alexey Stakhanov, covered World War II throughout, including "Victory Banner over the Reichstag", liberation of Sevastopol, the storming of Novorossiysk, Potsdam Conference, Nuremberg trials
Oleg Knorring 1907 1968 contributor to magazine Наши достижения ('Our achievements'), and other publications and during World War II for newspaper Red Star.
Nikolai Dzhemsovich Kolli (not to be confused with Nikolai Kolli, architect) 1894 1966 USSR in Construction
Vladimir Musinov LIFE 29 Mar 1943 (p. 114) special edition on Russia, and in an article in the 11 Jan 1943 edition.
Vladimir Savostyanov 1903 ? J. Nehru and I. Gandhi in Moscow metro, 1955; Shah of Iran Mohammed Reza Pahlavi and Soraya Pahlavi at Exhibition of Economic Achievements, Moscow, 1956
Arkady Shaikhet 1898 1959 worked on Ogonyok, a founder of Soviet Photo in 1926, contributed to USSR in Construction, in WW2 Battle of Stalingrad, liberation of Kiev, Ukraine.
Shakhovskoy work was collected by Philippe Halsman
Major David Sholomovich cameraman for the Moscow Newsreel Studios, he mastered the duties of gunner and navigator in order to fly to record the dive-bombing and strafing of Nazi troops by Soviet planes.
Abram Petrowitch Shterenberg (or Sterenberg) ? 1979 As a soldier he attended a school of art and design, worked in Red Army photographic department. Postwar in B. Kapustianskii’s photo atelier in Tashkent, Uzbekistan. Professional photographer in Moscow and was active there as a photojournalist and portraitist, contributed to exhibition “Ten Years of Soviet Photography”, mostly portraits.
Viktor Antonovich Temin 1908 1987 from 1922 worked for Izvestia, photographing Maxim Gorky in 1929, expedition to the North Pole in 1930, Russian-Finnish War (1939–40).
Alexander Uzylan 1908 198? staff photographer for Izvestia, Pravda and Ogoniok magazine. During the Second World War, assigned to the Black Sea Fleet as correspondent for the Soviet information Bureau.
Alexander Vorontsov photographs and film of rescue of children at the liberation of the Auschwitz-Birkenau camp by the Red Army, January 27, 1945[22][23]
Boris Borisovich Zeitlin (a.k.a. Tseitlin) "a fearless and indefatigable film-photographer."[24][25]
George Anatolievich 'Zelma' Zelmanovich 1906 1984 photojournalist on Izvestia, Ogonyok, Red Star 1920s and 30s; military photographer on "Izvestia" newspaper at the front in Moldavia, Odessa and Ukraine particularly during Battle of Stalingrad. After WW2, worked for "Ogonyok" magazine, and from 1962 for the agency "Novosti".

References

  1. ^ "Sovfoto/Eastfoto Agency. (New York).(offers images from Russia, China, Eastern Europe)(Brief Article)", Photo District News, 22 (4), The Nielsen Company: S16(1), 2002-04-01, ISSN 1045-8158
  2. ^ "Reviews: of leading stock industry source across the country & beyond. (Stock Photography Guide 2003)", Photo District News, 23 (4), The Nielsen Company: S10(13), 2003-04-01, ISSN 1045-8158
  3. ^ Hadzihasanovi; Wlasenko, O.; Pacific, R.C.; Beveridge, S.; Fraser, S.; MacLaren Art Centre (2007), September 2007: Broken Promises, Soviet Photography in the Age of Stalin : Olexander Wlasenko, Robin Pacific, Sadko Hadz̆ihasanovi, O., MacLaren Art Centre, ISBN 9780973882933
  4. ^ a b c "The Sovfoto Archive". MacLaren Art Centre. Retrieved 2020-10-08.
  5. ^ "Tass Sovfoto Photograph Collection – Special Collections and University Archives". Retrieved 2020-10-08.
  6. ^ a b "How Photos Became a Weapon in Stalin's Great Purge - HISTORY". www.history.com. Retrieved 2020-10-08.
  7. ^ Shneer, David; ebrary, Inc (2011), Through Soviet Jewish eyes photography, war, and the Holocaust, Rutgers University Press, retrieved 20 September 2015
  8. ^ McCann, Laura (2017-03-01). "The Whole Story: News Agency Photographs in Newspaper Photo Morgue Collections". The American Archivist. 80 (1): 163–188. doi:10.17723/0360-9081.80.1.163. ISSN 0360-9081.
  9. ^ 'Soviet design for living in transition,' Chattanooga Daily Times Sunday, 05 May 1935, p.35
  10. ^ Sandeen, Eric J. (1995). Picturing an exhibition : the family of man and 1950s America. Univ. of New Mexico Press. ISBN 0-8263-1558-5. OCLC 246958853.
  11. ^ Turner, Fred. The Family of man and the politics of attention in Cold War America. OCLC 794668775.
  12. ^ Edwin S. Smith, [in] 1948 was identified by Lewis F. Budenz as a Communist in sworn testimony. When asked about this and other evidence before this subcommittee in 1953, he invoked his privilege under the fifth amendment[…]Since his departure from government service, Smith has taken off his mask and become an official propagandist for the Soviet government, as American agent of Sovfoto, a Soviet agency, and a long list of Soviet and Chinese communist principals. In his capacity, among other duties, he distributes photographs purporting to show that American troops have been engaged in germ warfare in Korea United States. Congress. Senate. Committee on the Judiciary (1953), Interlocking subversion in Government Departments. : Hearing before the Subcommittee to Investigate the Administration of the Internal Security Act and Other Internal Security Laws of the Committee on the Judiciary, United States Senate, Eighty-third Congress, second session [-Eighty-fourth Congress, first session], U.S. Govt. Print. Off, retrieved 20 September 2015(p.569)
  13. ^ "There is very clear evidence that a man who is now working for Sovfoto, the Soviet propaganda organisation in America, decidedly influenced the administration of Labour policy in the late thirties.""McCARTHYISM ON TRIAL—II Communists In U.S.: Fact And Fiction". The Sydney Morning Herald. 8 November 1954. p. 2. Retrieved 24 September 2015 – via National Library of Australia.
  14. ^ REPORT of the ATTORNEY GENERAL to the CONGRESS of the UNITED STATES on the ADMINISTRATION of the FOREIGN AGENTS REGISTRATION ACT OF 1938, as AMENDED June 1951, for the Calendar Year 1955
  15. ^ "Sovfoto/Eastfoto - Visual Connections directory". www.visualconnections.com. Retrieved 2020-10-08.
  16. ^ Tupitsyn, Margarita (1996), The Soviet photograph, 1924-1937, Yale University Press, ISBN 978-0-300-06450-6
  17. ^ "Olexander Wlasenko Curatorial Essay - Broken Promises: Soviet Photography in the Age of Stalin". www.olexander.ca. Retrieved 2020-10-08.
  18. ^ 'Paste-up job seen in Stalin photo,' Chattanooga Daily Times, Friday 24 Mar 1950, p.9
  19. ^ Stewart Alsop, 'Intelligence Data Need Not Depend On Fair Spies,' The Courier-Journal Sat, Apr 14, 1956, p.8
  20. ^ Erskine Johnson, Poughkeepsie Journal Thursday 04 Mar 1943, p.14
  21. ^ 'Mother recognizes son in N. Korean POW photo,' Fort Worth Star-Telegram, Friday 22 Sep 1950, p.2
  22. ^ "Child Survivors at the Liberation of Auschwitz – 27 January 1945 | Through the Lens of History - Mini Exhibits from the Yad Vashem Collections". www.yadvashem.org. Retrieved 2020-10-08.
  23. ^ "The liberation of Auschwitz a documentary by Irmgard von zur Mühlen. - Collections Search - United States Holocaust Memorial Museum". collections.ushmm.org. Retrieved 2020-10-08.
  24. ^ Macfie, J. W. S (1936), An Ethiopian diary : a record of the British Ambulance Service in Ethiopia, Uni. Press of Liverpool, Hodder & Stoughton, retrieved 26 September 2015
  25. ^ Mochulsky, Fyodor Vasilevich; Kaple, Deborah A (2010), Gulag boss a Soviet memoir, Oxford University Press, ISBN 978-0-19-974266-0
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Sovfoto&oldid=982580104"