GRSI model: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
nominate for deletion |
The Banner (talk | contribs) |
||
| (5 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
<!-- Please do not remove or change this AfD message until the discussion has been closed. --> |
|||
{{Article for deletion/dated|page=GRSI model|timestamp=20231222191121|year=2023|month=December|day=22|substed=yes}} |
|||
<!-- Once discussion is closed, please place on talk page: {{Old AfD multi|page=GRSI model|date=22 December 2023|result='''keep'''}} --> |
|||
<!-- End of AfD message, feel free to edit beyond this point --> |
|||
{{short description|Possible explanation by general relativity for Dark matter and Dark energy}} |
{{short description|Possible explanation by general relativity for Dark matter and Dark energy}} |
||
{{Afd-merge to|Alternatives to general relativity|GRSI model|29 December 2023}} |
|||
{{unsolved|physics|What is dark matter? What is dark energy?}} |
{{unsolved|physics|What is dark matter? What is dark energy?}} |
||
| Line 18: | Line 15: | ||
The GRSI model is inspired from the [[Strong interaction|Strong Nuclear Force]], where a comparable phenomenon occurs. The interaction between [[gluons]] emitted by static or nearly static [[quarks]] dramatically strengthens quark-quark interaction, ultimately leading to [[Color confinement|quark confinement]] on the one hand (analogous to the need of stronger gravity to explain away dark matter) and the [[Nuclear force|suppression of the Strong Nuclear Force outside hadrons]] (analogous to the repulsion of dark energy that balances gravitational attraction at large scales.) Two other parallel phenomena are the [[Tully-Fisher relation]] in galaxy dynamics that is analogous to the [[Regge theory|Regge trajectories]] emerging from the strong force. In both cases, the phenomenological formulas describing these observations are similar, albeit with different numerical factors. |
The GRSI model is inspired from the [[Strong interaction|Strong Nuclear Force]], where a comparable phenomenon occurs. The interaction between [[gluons]] emitted by static or nearly static [[quarks]] dramatically strengthens quark-quark interaction, ultimately leading to [[Color confinement|quark confinement]] on the one hand (analogous to the need of stronger gravity to explain away dark matter) and the [[Nuclear force|suppression of the Strong Nuclear Force outside hadrons]] (analogous to the repulsion of dark energy that balances gravitational attraction at large scales.) Two other parallel phenomena are the [[Tully-Fisher relation]] in galaxy dynamics that is analogous to the [[Regge theory|Regge trajectories]] emerging from the strong force. In both cases, the phenomenological formulas describing these observations are similar, albeit with different numerical factors. |
||
These parallels are expected from a theoretical point of view: General Relativity and the Strong Interaction [[Lagrangians]] have the same form.<ref>{{cite book |title=Quantum Field Theory in a Nutshell |author=Zee, A. |publisher=Princeton University Press |year=2010 |pages=576 }}</ref><ref name="Deur09" /> The validity of the GRSI model then simply hinges on whether the coupling of the gravitational fields is large enough so that the same effects that occur in [[hadrons]] also occur in very massive systems. This coupling is effectively given by <math>\sqrt{GM/L}</math>, where <math>G</math> is the [[gravitational constant]], <math>M</math> is the mass of the system, and <math>L</math> is a characteristic length of the system. The claim of the GRSI proponents, based either on [[Lattice gauge theory|lattice calculations]],<ref name="Deur09" /> a background-field model.<ref name="Deur21a" /> or the coincidental phenomenologies in galactic or hadronic dynamics mentioned in the previous paragraph, is that <math>\sqrt{GM/L}</math> is indeed sufficiently large for large systems such as galaxies. |
These parallels are expected from a theoretical point of view: General Relativity and the Strong Interaction [[Lagrangian mechanics|Lagrangians]] have the same form.<ref>{{cite book |title=Quantum Field Theory in a Nutshell |author=Zee, A. |publisher=Princeton University Press |year=2010 |pages=576 }}</ref><ref name="Deur09" /> The validity of the GRSI model then simply hinges on whether the coupling of the gravitational fields is large enough so that the same effects that occur in [[hadrons]] also occur in very massive systems. This coupling is effectively given by <math>\sqrt{GM/L}</math>, where <math>G</math> is the [[gravitational constant]], <math>M</math> is the mass of the system, and <math>L</math> is a characteristic length of the system. The claim of the GRSI proponents, based either on [[Lattice gauge theory|lattice calculations]],<ref name="Deur09" /> a background-field model.<ref name="Deur21a" /> or the coincidental phenomenologies in galactic or hadronic dynamics mentioned in the previous paragraph, is that <math>\sqrt{GM/L}</math> is indeed sufficiently large for large systems such as galaxies. |
||
==List of topics studied in the Model== |
==List of topics studied in the Model== |
||
| Line 24: | Line 21: | ||
The main observations that appear to require dark matter and/or dark energy can be explained within this model. Namely, |
The main observations that appear to require dark matter and/or dark energy can be explained within this model. Namely, |
||
* The [[Galaxy rotation curve|flat rotation curves of galaxies]].<ref name="Deur09">{{cite journal |arxiv=0901.4005|title=Implications of Graviton-Graviton Interaction to Dark Matter|year=2009|last1=Deur|first1=Alexandre|journal=Phys.Lett.B|volume=676 |issue= |
* The [[Galaxy rotation curve|flat rotation curves of galaxies]].<ref name="Deur09">{{cite journal |arxiv=0901.4005|title=Implications of Graviton-Graviton Interaction to Dark Matter|year=2009|last1=Deur|first1=Alexandre|journal=Phys.Lett.B|volume=676 |issue=1–3|pages=21–24|doi=10.1016/j.physletb.2009.04.060 |bibcode=2009PhLB..676...21D |s2cid=118596512 }}</ref><ref name="Deur21a">{{cite journal |arxiv=2004.05905|doi=10.1140/epjc/s10052-021-08965-5|title=Relativistic corrections to the rotation curves of disk galaxies|year=2021|last1=Deur|first1=Alexandre|journal=Eur. Phys. Jour. C|volume=81 |issue=3|page=213|bibcode=2021EPJC...81..213D |s2cid=215745418 }}</ref><ref name="Deur16a" >{{cite journal |title=Self-interacting scalar fields at high-temperature |author=Deur, A. |journal=Eur. Phys. J. C |volume=77 |issue=6 |year=2017 |pages=412 |doi=10.1140/epjc/s10052-017-4971-x |arxiv=1611.05515|bibcode=2017EPJC...77..412D |s2cid=254106132 }}</ref> These results, however, have been challenged.<ref>{{citation |arxiv=2303.11094 |title=Does gravitational confinement sustain flat galactic rotation curves without dark matter? |year=2023 |last1=Barker |first1=W. E. V. |last2=Hobson |first2=M. P. |last3=Lasenby |first3=A. N.}}</ref><ref>{{citation |arxiv=2306.00992 |title=Comment on "Does gravitational confinement sustain flat galactic rotation curves without dark matter?" |year=2023 |last1=Deur |first1=A.}}</ref> |
||
* The [[Cosmic Microwave Background]] [[anisotropies]].<ref name="Deur22a">{{cite journal |title=Effect of the field self-interaction of General Relativity on the cosmic microwave background anisotropies |author=Deur, A. |journal=Class. Quant. Grav. |volume=39 |issue=13 |year=2022 |pages=135003 |doi=10.1088/1361-6382/ac7029 |arxiv=2203.02350|bibcode=2022CQGra..39m5003D |s2cid=247244759 }}</ref> |
* The [[Cosmic Microwave Background]] [[anisotropies]].<ref name="Deur22a">{{cite journal |title=Effect of the field self-interaction of General Relativity on the cosmic microwave background anisotropies |author=Deur, A. |journal=Class. Quant. Grav. |volume=39 |issue=13 |year=2022 |pages=135003 |doi=10.1088/1361-6382/ac7029 |arxiv=2203.02350|bibcode=2022CQGra..39m5003D |s2cid=247244759 }}</ref> |
||
* The [[Accelerating expansion of the universe#Supernova observation|fainter luminosities of distant supernovae]] and their consequence on the [[accelerating expansion of the universe]].<ref name="Deur19a" /> |
* The [[Accelerating expansion of the universe#Supernova observation|fainter luminosities of distant supernovae]] and their consequence on the [[accelerating expansion of the universe]].<ref name="Deur19a" /> |
||
* The [[Structure formation|formation of the Universe's large structures]].<ref>{{cite journal |title=Effect of gravitational field self-interaction on large structure formation |author=Deur, A. |journal=Phys. Lett. B |volume=820 |year=2021 |pages=136510 |doi=10.1016/j.physletb.2021.136510 |arxiv=2108.04649|bibcode=2021PhLB..82036510D |s2cid=236965796 }}</ref> |
* The [[Structure formation|formation of the Universe's large structures]].<ref>{{cite journal |title=Effect of gravitational field self-interaction on large structure formation |author=Deur, A. |journal=Phys. Lett. B |volume=820 |year=2021 |pages=136510 |doi=10.1016/j.physletb.2021.136510 |arxiv=2108.04649|bibcode=2021PhLB..82036510D |s2cid=236965796 }}</ref> |
||
* The [[matter power spectrum]]. |
* The [[matter power spectrum]].<ref name="Deur22a" /> |
||
* The internal dynamics of [[galaxy clusters]], including that of the [[Bullet Cluster]].<ref name="Deur09" /> |
* The internal dynamics of [[galaxy clusters]], including that of the [[Bullet Cluster]].<ref name="Deur09" /> |
||
| Line 38: | Line 35: | ||
* The [[cosmic coincidence]], that is the fact that at present time, the purported repulsion of dark energy nearly exactly cancels the action of gravity in the [[Expansion of the universe|overall dynamics of the universe]].<ref name="Deur16a" /> |
* The [[cosmic coincidence]], that is the fact that at present time, the purported repulsion of dark energy nearly exactly cancels the action of gravity in the [[Expansion of the universe|overall dynamics of the universe]].<ref name="Deur16a" /> |
||
Finally, the model made a prediction that the amount of missing mass (i.e., the dark mass in dark matter approaches) in elliptical galaxies correlates with the ellipticity of the galaxies.<ref name="Deur09" /> This was tested and verified.<ref>{{cite journal | last=Deur | first=A. | title=A relation between the dark mass of elliptical galaxies and their shape | journal=Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. | year=2014 | volume=438 | issue=2 | pages= |
Finally, the model made a prediction that the amount of missing mass (i.e., the dark mass in dark matter approaches) in elliptical galaxies correlates with the ellipticity of the galaxies.<ref name="Deur09" /> This was tested and verified.<ref>{{cite journal | last=Deur | first=A. | title=A relation between the dark mass of elliptical galaxies and their shape | journal=Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. | year=2014 | volume=438 | issue=2 | pages=1535–1551 | doi=10.1093/mnras/stt2293 | arxiv=1304.6932 }}</ref><ref>{{cite journal | last=Winters | first=D. | author2=Deur, A. | author3=Zheng, X. | title=Updated analysis of an unexpected correlation between dark matter and galactic ellipticity | journal=Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. | year=2022 | volume=518 | issue=2 | pages=2845–2852 | doi=10.1093/mnras/stac3236 | arxiv=2207.02945 | bibcode=2023MNRAS.518.2845W }}</ref> |
||
==Footnotes== |
==Footnotes== |
||
Latest revision as of 00:32, 4 March 2024
 | This article was nominated for deletion. The discussion was closed on 29 December 2023 with a consensus to merge the content into the article Alternatives to general relativity. If you find that such action has not been taken promptly, please consider assisting in the merger instead of re-nominating the article for deletion. To discuss the merger, please use the destination article's talk page. (December 2023) |
Unsolved problem in physics:
What is dark matter? What is dark energy?
The GRSI model[1] is an attempt to explain astrophysical and cosmological observations without dark matter, dark energy or modifying the laws of gravity as they are currently established. This model is an alternative to Lambda-CDM, the standard model of cosmology.
History and description[edit]
The model was proposed in a series of articles, the first dating from 2003.[2] The basic point is that since within General Relativity, gravitational fields couple to each other, this can effectively increase the gravitational interaction between massive objects. The additional gravitational strength then avoid the need for dark matter. This field coupling is the origin of General Relativity's non-linear behavior. It can be understood, in particle language, as gravitons interacting with each other (despite being massless) because they carry energy-momentum.
A natural implication of this model is its explanation of the accelerating expansion of the universe without resorting to dark energy.[3] The increased binding energy within a galaxy requires, by energy conservation, a weakening of gravitational attraction outside said galaxy. This mimics the repulsion of dark energy.
The GRSI model is inspired from the Strong Nuclear Force, where a comparable phenomenon occurs. The interaction between gluons emitted by static or nearly static quarks dramatically strengthens quark-quark interaction, ultimately leading to quark confinement on the one hand (analogous to the need of stronger gravity to explain away dark matter) and the suppression of the Strong Nuclear Force outside hadrons (analogous to the repulsion of dark energy that balances gravitational attraction at large scales.) Two other parallel phenomena are the Tully-Fisher relation in galaxy dynamics that is analogous to the Regge trajectories emerging from the strong force. In both cases, the phenomenological formulas describing these observations are similar, albeit with different numerical factors.
These parallels are expected from a theoretical point of view: General Relativity and the Strong Interaction Lagrangians have the same form.[4][5] The validity of the GRSI model then simply hinges on whether the coupling of the gravitational fields is large enough so that the same effects that occur in hadrons also occur in very massive systems. This coupling is effectively given by , where is the gravitational constant, is the mass of the system, and is a characteristic length of the system. The claim of the GRSI proponents, based either on lattice calculations,[5] a background-field model.[6] or the coincidental phenomenologies in galactic or hadronic dynamics mentioned in the previous paragraph, is that is indeed sufficiently large for large systems such as galaxies.
List of topics studied in the Model[edit]
The main observations that appear to require dark matter and/or dark energy can be explained within this model. Namely,
- The flat rotation curves of galaxies.[5][6][7] These results, however, have been challenged.[8][9]
- The Cosmic Microwave Background anisotropies.[10]
- The fainter luminosities of distant supernovae and their consequence on the accelerating expansion of the universe.[3]
- The formation of the Universe's large structures.[11]
- The matter power spectrum.[10]
- The internal dynamics of galaxy clusters, including that of the Bullet Cluster.[5]
Additionally, the model explains observations that are currently challenging to understand within Lambda-CDM:
- The Tully-Fisher relation.[5][6]
- The radial acceleration relation.[12]
- The Hubble tension.[13]
- The cosmic coincidence, that is the fact that at present time, the purported repulsion of dark energy nearly exactly cancels the action of gravity in the overall dynamics of the universe.[7]
Finally, the model made a prediction that the amount of missing mass (i.e., the dark mass in dark matter approaches) in elliptical galaxies correlates with the ellipticity of the galaxies.[5] This was tested and verified.[14][15]
Footnotes[edit]
- ^ Oks, Eugene (2023). "Review of latest advances on dark matter from the viewpoint of the Occam razor principle". New Astronomy Reviews. 96: 101673. Bibcode:2023NewAR..9601673O. doi:10.1016/j.newar.2023.101673. ISSN 1387-6473. S2CID 256262366.
- ^ Deur, Alexandre (2003), Non-Abelian Effects in Gravitation, arXiv:astro-ph/0309474, Bibcode:2003astro.ph..9474D
- ^ a b Deur, Alexandre (2019). "An explanation for dark matter and dark energy consistent with the Standard Model of particle physics and General Relativity". Eur. Phys. Jour. C. 79 (10): 883. arXiv:1709.02481. Bibcode:2019EPJC...79..883D. doi:10.1140/epjc/s10052-019-7393-0. S2CID 119218121.
- ^ Zee, A. (2010). Quantum Field Theory in a Nutshell. Princeton University Press. p. 576.
- ^ a b c d e f Deur, Alexandre (2009). "Implications of Graviton-Graviton Interaction to Dark Matter". Phys.Lett.B. 676 (1–3): 21–24. arXiv:0901.4005. Bibcode:2009PhLB..676...21D. doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2009.04.060. S2CID 118596512.
- ^ a b c Deur, Alexandre (2021). "Relativistic corrections to the rotation curves of disk galaxies". Eur. Phys. Jour. C. 81 (3): 213. arXiv:2004.05905. Bibcode:2021EPJC...81..213D. doi:10.1140/epjc/s10052-021-08965-5. S2CID 215745418.
- ^ a b Deur, A. (2017). "Self-interacting scalar fields at high-temperature". Eur. Phys. J. C. 77 (6): 412. arXiv:1611.05515. Bibcode:2017EPJC...77..412D. doi:10.1140/epjc/s10052-017-4971-x. S2CID 254106132.
- ^ Barker, W. E. V.; Hobson, M. P.; Lasenby, A. N. (2023), Does gravitational confinement sustain flat galactic rotation curves without dark matter?, arXiv:2303.11094
- ^ Deur, A. (2023), Comment on "Does gravitational confinement sustain flat galactic rotation curves without dark matter?", arXiv:2306.00992
- ^ a b Deur, A. (2022). "Effect of the field self-interaction of General Relativity on the cosmic microwave background anisotropies". Class. Quant. Grav. 39 (13): 135003. arXiv:2203.02350. Bibcode:2022CQGra..39m5003D. doi:10.1088/1361-6382/ac7029. S2CID 247244759.
- ^ Deur, A. (2021). "Effect of gravitational field self-interaction on large structure formation". Phys. Lett. B. 820: 136510. arXiv:2108.04649. Bibcode:2021PhLB..82036510D. doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2021.136510. S2CID 236965796.
- ^ Deur, A.; Sargent, C.; Terzić, B. (2020). "Significance of Gravitational Nonlinearities on the Dynamics of Disk Galaxies". Astrophys. J. 896 (2): 94. arXiv:1909.00095. Bibcode:2020ApJ...896...94D. doi:10.3847/1538-4357/ab94b6.
{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link) - ^ Sargent, C.; Deur, A.; Terzic, B. (2023), Hubble Tension and Gravitational Self-Interaction, arXiv:2301.10861
{{citation}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link) - ^ Deur, A. (2014). "A relation between the dark mass of elliptical galaxies and their shape". Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 438 (2): 1535–1551. arXiv:1304.6932. doi:10.1093/mnras/stt2293.
- ^ Winters, D.; Deur, A.; Zheng, X. (2022). "Updated analysis of an unexpected correlation between dark matter and galactic ellipticity". Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 518 (2): 2845–2852. arXiv:2207.02945. Bibcode:2023MNRAS.518.2845W. doi:10.1093/mnras/stac3236.